Personal Experience and Public Opinion: A Theory and Test of Conditional Policy Feedback

  title={Personal Experience and Public Opinion: A Theory and Test of Conditional Policy Feedback},
  author={Amy E. Lerman and Katherine T. McCabe},
  journal={The Journal of Politics},
  pages={624 - 641}
Using a regression discontinuity design, we show that personal experience with public health insurance programs exerts a causal influence on attitudes toward both Medicare and the Affordable Care Act. However, we argue that the conditional dynamics of these policy feedback effects differ from standard models of opinion formation and change. Specifically, we find that personal experience can shape preferences among those whose partisanship might otherwise make them resistant to elite messaging… Expand
Attitude Responsiveness and Partisan Bias: Direct Experience with the Affordable Care Act
This study evaluates the competing influences of motivated reasoning and personal experience on policy preferences toward the Affordable Care Act. Using cross-sectional and panel survey data, theExpand
The Feedback Effects of a Market-Based Policy : Evidence from Public Opinion on the Affordable Care Act ∗
Can politicized, market-based policies generate policy feedbacks? The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is complex, relying partly on exchanges to increase health insurance enrollment. Yet prior researchExpand
When and How New Policy Creates New Politics: Examining the Feedback Effects of the Affordable Care Act on Public Opinion
Following E. E. Schattschneider’s observation that “a new policy creates a new politics,” scholars of “policy feedback” have theorized that policies influence subsequent political behavior and publicExpand
New Policy , New Politics ? The Effect of Medicaid Expansion on Public Support for the Affordable Care Act ∗
Can social policy affect public opinion? We leverage state-level variation in policy implementation, more than 220,000 individual responses from 175 polls, and an original nationally representativeExpand
Policy Effects, Partisanship, and Elections: How Medicaid Expansion Affected Public Opinion toward the Affordable Care Act
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is one of the most consequential policies enacted in recent decades, but its political divisiveness and complexity call into question whether its effects can changeExpand
Concentrated Burdens: How Self-Interest and Partisanship Shape Opinion on Opioid Treatment Policy
When does self-interest influence public opinion on contentious public policies? The bulk of theory in political science suggests that self-interest is only a minor force in public opinion. UsingExpand
Making What Government Does Apparent to Citizens: Policy Feedback Effects, Their Limitations, and How They Might Be Facilitated
  • Suzanne Mettler
  • Sociology
  • The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
  • 2019
Public policies sometimes generate “policy feedback effects,” reshaping public opinion and political participation among beneficiaries or the public generally, often with the effects of generatingExpand
The Politics of Policy: The Initial Mass Political Effects of Medicaid Expansion in the States
Whether public policy affects electoral politics is an enduring question with an elusive answer. We identify the impact of the highly contested Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) ofExpand
Can Health Insurance Regulations Generate Citizen Constituencies?
Context: A political science literature has emerged on the policy feedback effects of alternative health care coverage expansions, focusing on whether programs like Medicare, Medicaid, and theExpand
The Medicaid Expansion and Attitudes toward the Affordable Care Act: Testing for a Policy Feedback on Mass Opinion
Enacted in 2010, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) has reshaped U.S. health policy. Yet overall opinions on the law remained relatively stable during the few years before and afterExpand


Policy feedbacks and the impact of policy designs on public opinion.
  • A. Campbell
  • Political Science, Medicine
  • Journal of health politics, policy and law
  • 2011
Three cases--senior citizens' opposition to the Obama health care reform, tax breaks for employer-provided health insurance, and the Medicare Part D prescription drug program--demonstrate how policy designs affect subsequent policy outcomes. Expand
The dynamics of health care opinion, 2008-2010: partisanship, self-interest, and racial resentment.
It is found that health care policy preferences, already tinged with racial attitudes in 2008, became increasingly so by 2010, with Republicans growing more opposed to universal health insurance and those personally worried about medical expenses less likely to abandon support. Expand
Political Ignorance and Collective Policy Preferences
In contrast with the expectations of many analysts, I find that raw policy-specific facts, such as the direction of change in the crime rate or the amount of the federal budget devoted to foreignExpand
Does Policy Debate Reduce Information Effects in Public Opinion? Analyzing the Evolution of Public Opinion on Health Care
Because most citizens fall short of the normative ideal of being politically knowledgeable, it is important to assess the nature of information effects in public opinion. This paper identifies policyExpand
Policy Makes Mass Politics
This review examines policy feedback effects among the mass public, with a focus on social policies in the United States and Europe. It shows that existing policies feed back into the politicalExpand
When Self-Interest Matters
The relative influence of self-interest and values on policy preferences was assessed experimentally in a national survey that posed questions about three contemporary political issues—SocialExpand
Elite Influence on Public Opinion in an Informed Electorate
An enduring concern about democracies is that citizens conform too readily to the policy views of elites in their own parties, even to the point of ignoring other information about the policies inExpand
A Source of Bias in Public Opinion Stability
A long acknowledged but seldom addressed problem with political communication experiments concerns the use of captive participants. Study participants rarely have the opportunity to chooseExpand
Social Construction of Target Populations: Implications for Politics and Policy.
We argue that the social construction of target populations is an important, albeit overlooked, political phenomenon that should take its place in the study of public policy by political scientists.Expand
When Effect Becomes Cause: Policy Feedback and Political Change
As governmental activity has expanded, scholars have been increasingly inclined to suggest that the structure of public policies has an important influence on patterns of political change. YetExpand