Perfect Competition, Historically Contemplated

@article{Stigler1957PerfectCH,
  title={Perfect Competition, Historically Contemplated},
  author={George Joseph Stigler},
  journal={Journal of Political Economy},
  year={1957},
  volume={65},
  pages={1 - 17}
}
  • G. Stigler
  • Published 1 February 1957
  • Economics
  • Journal of Political Economy
No concept in economics — or elsewhere — is ever defined fully, in the sense that its meaning under every conceivable circumstance is clear. Even a word with a wholly arbitrary meaning in economics, like ‘elasticity’, raises questions which the person who defined it (in this case, Marshall) never faced: for example, how does the concept apply to finite changes or to discontinuous or stochastic or multiple-valued functions ? And of course a word like ‘competition’, which is shared with the whole… 
View on U Chicago Press
450 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
19
Background Citations
147
Methods Citations
11
Results Citations
5

450 Citations

Perfect competition, methodologically contemplated

Abstract: The concept of perfect competition embodies a formal contradiction, precisely as would that of “the largest integer.” The ascription of legitimate meaning to the concept, as in George J.…

Economics and Mis-Mathematics

There are at least two different infinites: countable ones such as the Integers, the Rational Numbers, and the Algebraic Numbers, and non-countable ones, such as for the Real Number continuum. These…

Noncooperative Approaches to the Theory of Perfect Competition

The Paradoxes of Market Economics

For Adam Smith and his contemporary followers, an economy is comprised almost solely of individual transactions. This idea is called “methodological individualism”. For the theory based on this to be…

Price Theory, Historically Considered: Smith, Ricardo, Marshall and Beyond

Abstract Terminology is important. Price theory as the name given to the study of the determination of prices in markets reached ascendancy around the middle of the last century, having been little…

Free From What? Classical Competition and the Early Decades of American Antitrust

ABSTRACT Classical economists characterised free competition as, alternatively, freedom of contract and freedom to trade. These notions were still at centre stage of the economic discourse during the…

Uber and Society

This chapter examines the flaws in perfect competition and in competition regulation. Perfect competition takes agents in the market processes to do what all others do. This has nothing to do with…

The classical notion of competition revisited

We compare and analyse two different conceptions of market competition: the walrasian notion of perfect competition and the Classical notion of free competition: while the former may be described as…

Perfect Competition and the Creativity of the Market

From the perspective of the Walrasian general equilibrium model, entrepreneurial and opportunistic behavior seems foreign. Can the model be refashioned so that it can accommodate such behavior? Many…

A pluralist approach to microeconomics

A great strength of traditional economics is the absence of a welldeveloped, coherent alternative. The pressure to teach something often results in orthodox microeconomics ruling the roost. However,…
...