Paved with Good Intentions

  title={Paved with Good Intentions},
  author={Barry Sautman},
  journal={Modern China},
  pages={10 - 39}
  • B. Sautman
  • Published 1 January 2012
  • Sociology
  • Modern China
Since 2004, academics concerned about a prospective fracturing of China’s territory have advanced proposals to phase out ethnic regional autonomy, preferential policies, and other minority rights. Riots in Lhasa, Tibet, in 2008 and Urumqi, Xinjiang, in 2009 gave greater impetus to the proposals, as they moved from academic to wider circles and complaints about preferential policies in criminal justice, family planning, and school admissions grew, with even state recognition of minorities… 
Ethnic Conflict and the New Legalism in China
In October 2014, the Chinese Communist Party committed to the establishment of a “socialist rule of law with Chinese characteristics.” Since then a group of Chinese political elites that we refer to
Self-representation and ethnic minority rights in China
Proposals to reform along liberal lines China’s system of discrete minority rights, such as ethnic regional autonomy and preferential policies, seek to ‘depoliticize’ minorities by treating them as
Ethnic Autonomy and Ethnic Inequality: An Empirical Assessment of Ethnic Policy in Urban China*
To balance ethno-cultural diversity with national integration, the Chinese government started formulating a series of ethnic policies in the early 1950s, including policies on identifying and
Reflections on the debate on China’s ethnic policy: my reform proposals and their critics
‘Minzu’ (nation or nationality) is a term that appeared in China after the Opium Wars. From 1949, the PRC established a two-level national structure with the term ‘minzu’: the Chinese nation
Tibet and the Segment-state Hypothesis
Abstract This study examines the claim that the existence of segment states within a country enhances the likelihood of nation-state crises through an examination of the case of Tibetan Autonomous
A Comparative Study of the Integration of Muslim Minorities in China and Singapore
Significant challenges exist for the integration of Muslim minorities in China and Singapore, countries that are overwhelmingly Han Chinese but with a significant Muslim population. This paper first
Iran's Karaj Dam Affair: Emerging Mass Consumerism, the Politics of Promise, and the Cold War in the Third World
  • C. Schayegh
  • Political Science
    Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • 2012
Abstract This paper examines two intertwined processes that shaped post-war Tehran. One was a ravenous demand for electricity, part of a surge in popular expectations for consumer goods and higher
Explaining the Chinese framing of the “terrorist” violence in Xinjiang: insights from securitization theory
This paper critically examines the Chinese framing of the “terrorist” violence in Xinjiang. Drawing on the Copenhagen school of securitization theory, it examines how the historical perception of the
The State of American Studies in Pakistan
attention to the history and evolution of other peoples and other contemporary societies. Although the United States has played a key role in the short and checkered history of Pakistan, no serious
Grand challenge: ELSI in a changing global environment
ELSI was born in a last minute revision of a 1988 James Watson speech, where Watson set aside funds specifically for the study of the ethical, legal, and social implications of the massive US government funded Human Genome Project, and has been a staple part of genomics grants ever since.


Negotiable Rights? China's Ethnic Minorities and the Right to Freedom of Religion
In order to get a fuller picture of the conditions for religious freedom for ethnic minorities in China, we must both look beyond laws and central policies as well as beyond the more publicised cases
China's Vulnerability to Minority Separatism
T wo watershed events frame China's current vulnerability to minority separatism: first, the disintegration of the Soviet Union and its client states from 1989-91, and second, the U.S. war against
Autonomy as a Source of Conflict: Caucasian Conflicts in Theoretical Perspective
The granting of autonomous status to minority populations has gained support among academics and practitioners alike as a way to solve, manage, and even preempt ethnic conflict. In spite of the
Unused Powers: Contestation over Autonomy Legislation in the PRC
is a paradox at the heart of current arrangements for autonomy for ethnic minorities in the PRC. The most important and distinctive power granted to autonomous areas in China's system of
France's ‘Ethnic’ Minorities and the Question of Exclusion
One year after the riots that rocked France’s outer-city suburbs, or banlieues, has there been any change in the economic, social and political situation of the young residents of the banlieues? Have
Preferential policies for ethnic minorities in China: The case of Xinjiang
Preferential policies for ethnic minorities in China are implemented in family planning, school admissions, the hiring and promotion, the financing and taxation of businesses, and regional
Regional National Autonomy under Challenge: Law, Practice and Recommendations
Regional national autonomy is claimed to be the "basic policy" of the Chinese Communist Party and a "basic political system" of the State to solve the minority nationalities' issues in China. Within
Developing Minority Nationalities in Contemporary Urban China
It is not unusual for gender and ethnic studies to borrow from each other. In the previous chapter, we saw that economic reforms from the late 1970s onward have altered the relationship between state
Ethnicity and Chinese identity: ethnographic insight and political positioning
Ethnic identity is never static; nor is it a consistent social category. This very fluidity accounts for the presence of competing postures within a community. The internal conflict between
Southern Discomfort: Separatist Conflict in the Kingdom of Thailand
Separatist violence in Thailand's southern provinces has claimed the lives of more than 3,000 people since January 2004 and represents the kingdom's—arguably the region's—most serious security