Patriarchy and Wife Assault: The Ecological Fallacy

  title={Patriarchy and Wife Assault: The Ecological Fallacy},
  author={Donald G. Dutton},
  journal={Violence and Victims},
  pages={167 - 182}
  • D. Dutton
  • Published 1 January 1994
  • Medicine
  • Violence and Victims
A critical review is made of feminist analyses of wife assault postulating that patriarchy is a direct cause of wife assault. Data are reviewed from a variety of studies indicating that (a) lesbian battering is more frequent than heterosexual battering, (b) no direct relationship exists between power and violence within couples, and (c) no direct relationship exists between structural patriarchy and wife assault It is concluded that patriarchy must interact with psychological variables in order… 
Male abusiveness in intimate relationships
Existing theories of wife assault (psychiatric, sociological, sociobiological, and social learning) fail in a variety of ways to explain the empirical data generated by research in the last two
A Framework for Understanding Women's Use of Nonlethal Violence in Intimate Heterosexual Relationships
This article reviews current research on domestic violence by women and attempts to answer two questions: (a) Are women who assault their heterosexual partners different from male batterers? If so,
Intimate Partner Violence: The Legacy of Marvin Wolfgang’s Thinking
As we enter the 21st Century, an ever-growing body of research continues to demonstrate an inordinate level of violence among intimate partners throughout American society. Estimates of intimate
The Relationships Among Different Traits of Masculinity and Intimate Partner Violence
The Relationships Among Different Traits of Masculinity and Intimate Partner Violence by Jennifer E. Loveland Advisor: Dr. Chitra Raghavan Research has shown that distinct yet overlapping concepts of
The "Great Taboo" and the Role of Patriarchy in Husband and Wife Abuse
The role of historical memes such as the “Rule of Thumb” is explored and documented to illustrate how the notion of patriarchy defined as “male dominance over women” is deeply flawed. The “Rule of
Violence and Maltreatment in Relational Ecologies: Toward an Epistemology of Corresponsability
This article is about family violence. Firstly, it synthesizes the panoramic vision of hegemonic explicative models, classified as psychological and sociological. It also contrasts, exposes and
Husband violence: Personality disorders among male batterers
It is proposed that consideration of personality dimensions, rather than diagnosable personality disorders, is the most productive method of examining the role of personality in husband violence.
Personality Dynamics of Intimate Abusiveness
  • D. Dutton
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Journal of psychiatric practice
  • 2002
A new theory is proposed to account for individual differences in the tendency to be abusive, assaultive, or homicidal in intimate relationships. The focus of this theory is on men whose abuse is
Knowledge About Heterosexual versus Lesbian Battering Among Lesbians
Abstract There is growing evidence to suggest that abuse in lesbian relationships does exist and may occur on a greater scale than most people are aware of. This paper will define battering in
Intimate Partner Violence: Psychological Effects and Legal Defenses
This chapter reviews research on the prevalence of intimate partner violence (IPV) and describes the psychological effects of IPV in different populations. The evolution of the term battered woman


The Domestic Assault of Women: Psychological and Criminal Justice Perspectives
Preface Acknowledgments 1. History and Incidence of Wife Assault 2. Explanations for Wife Assault: Psychiatry, Sociobiology, and Sociology 3. The Social Psychology of the Wife Assaulter: The Theory
Patriarchal Ideology and Wife Beating: A Test of a Feminist Hypothesis
  • M. Smith
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Violence and Victims
  • 1990
Feminist theory suggests that husbands who adhere to an ideology of familial patriarchy are more likely to beat their wives than husbands who do not adhere to such an ideology. This research provides
Intimate Violence in Lesbian Relationships
This paper describes the findings of a survey of 1109 lesbians who attended the Women's Music Festival held in Michigan in carly August 1985. The primary objectives of the study were to document the
Male sexual jealousy
Abstract Sexual jealousy functions to defend paternity confidence and is therefore expected to be a ubiquitous aspect of male psychology. Several lines of evidence confirm this expectation.
The Myth of Sexual Symmetry in Marital Violence
A currently fashionable claim is that violence against husbands is about as prevalent as violence against wives; spousal violence has been said to be symmetrical in its extent, severity, intentions,
Psychology and violence against women.
  • L. Walker
  • Psychology, Medicine
    The American psychologist
  • 1989
The new scientific psychology data base formed by integrating feminist gender analysis methods into more traditional psychological methodology is discussed, as are the implications of the resulting empirical data on which are based newer assessment, treatment, and forensic applications.
Love and violence: gender paradoxes in volatile attachments.
It is argued that abusive relationships exemplify, in extremis, the stereotypical gender arrangements that structure intimacy between men and women generally.
Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse
Foreword - Lenore Walker Introduction - Michele Bograd Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse PART ONE: THE POLITICS OF RESEARCH Political and Methodological Debates in Wife Abuse Research - Kersti Yllo
Violence against women by male partners. Prevalence, outcomes, and policy implications.
  • A. Browne
  • Medicine
    The American psychologist
  • 1993
Empirical literature on the physical and sexual assault of women by their male intimates is reviewed and potential physical and psychological outcomes are discussed, with a focus on linking what is known about abused women's reactions with the rich literature on survivors' responses to trauma.
Psychological Differences Between Court-Referred and Self-Referred Wife Assaulters
Assessed on a battery of psychopathology and personality measures were 40 court-referred and 40 self-referred men in treatment for wife assault. Although both groups exhibited high degrees of