Patients, clinicians and open notes: information blocking as a case of epistemic injustice

@article{Blease2021PatientsCA,
  title={Patients, clinicians and open notes: information blocking as a case of epistemic injustice},
  author={Charlotte R Blease and Liz Salmi and Hanife Rexhepi and Maria H{\"a}gglund and Catherine M. DesRoches},
  journal={Journal of Medical Ethics},
  year={2021}
}
In many countries, including patients are legally entitled to request copies of their clinical notes. However, this process remains time-consuming and burdensome, and it remains unclear how much of the medical record must be made available. Online access to notes offers a way to overcome these challenges and in around 10 countries worldwide, via secure web-based portals, many patients are now able to read at least some of the narrative reports written by clinicians (‘open notes’). However, even… 
View on BMJ
jme.bmj.com
7 Citations
Background Citations
1

7 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

The benefits and harms of open notes in mental health: A Delphi survey of international experts
TLDR
There was consensus that offering online access to mental health notes could enhance patients’ understanding about their diagnosis, care plan, and rationale for treatments, and that access could enhance patient recall and sense of empowerment.
Patients’ Access to Their Psychiatric Notes: Current Policies and Practices in Sweden
TLDR
The results show that regional differences concerning sharing psychiatric notes persist, despite Swedish regulations and a national policy that stipulates equal care for everyone, and there is evidence that the regions are moving toward increased transparency for psychiatry patients.
Sharing Clinical Notes and Electronic Health Records With People Affected by Mental Health Conditions: Scoping Review
TLDR
PAEHRs in MHC may strengthen user involvement, patients’ autonomy, and shift medical treatment to a coproduced process and further research is needed to examine the clinical effectiveness, efficiency, and implementation of this sociotechnical intervention.
Open Notes and Closed-Loop Communication: A Case of Factitious Disorder in the Age of Transparent Medical Records
TLDR
This case provides an opportunity to consider implications of the Final Rule policy of “open notes” for patients with sensitive psychiatric diagnoses, highlighting the need for effective communication and collaboration between inpatient teams and realistic approaches to the integration of documentation in patient care.
Sharing Clinical Notes and Electronic Health Records with People Affected by Mental Health Conditions: Scoping Review (Preprint)
TLDR
PAEHRs in MHC may strengthen user involvement, patients' autonomy and shift medical treatment to a co-produced process and identify potential research gaps.
Acceptability of Health Information Exchange and Patient Portal Use in Depression Care Among Underrepresented Patients
TLDR
While HIE was perceived to improve the overall quality of depression care, stigma associated with mental illness undermined more robust adoption of this technology among underserved populations.
Trust and medical ethics

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 95 REFERENCES
Empowering patients and reducing inequities: is there potential in sharing clinical notes?
TLDR
It is suggested that open notes may, over time, prove important in the care of patients who are at risk of experiencing healthcare disparities, and evidence suggests strongly that the benefits of open notes outweigh the risks.
Sharing Clinical Notes in Psychotherapy: A New Tool to Strengthen Patient Autonomy
TLDR
It is proposed that open notes may provide an important new strategy to strengthen patient autonomy and improve clinical outcomes without sacrificing professional autonomy.
The Views and Experiences of Clinicians Sharing Medical Record Notes With Patients.
TLDR
In this survey of clinicians in a wide range of specialties who had several years of experience offering their patients ready access to their notes, more than two-thirds supported this new practice.
Embracing the new age of transparency: mental health patients reading their psychotherapy notes online
TLDR
The pilot findings indicate that most patients who read open therapy notes find them valuable for understanding and engaging in their mental health care, with minimal adverse effects.
Words Matter: What Do Patients Find Judgmental or Offensive in Outpatient Notes?
TLDR
Responses from a large Internet survey of adult patients who used secure patient portals and had at least 1 visit note available in a 12-month period at 2 large academic medical systems in Boston and Seattle, and in a rural integrated health system in Pennsylvania identified three thematic domains: errors and surprises, labeling, and disrespect.
Inviting Patients to Read Their Doctors' Notes: A Quasi-experimental Study and a Look Ahead
TLDR
Patients accessed visit notes frequently, a large majority reported clinically relevant benefits and minimal concerns, and virtually all patients wanted the practice to continue, with doctors experiencing no more than a modest effect on their work lives.
Easy Access, Difficult Consequences? Providing Psychiatric Patients With Access to Their Health Records Electronically
TLDR
The uptake of “opening up” mental health clinical notes remains slow, due to the ongoing discomfort and concerns that providers have had, and it is shown that working in psychiatry is a predictor of discomfort in providing clinical notes to patients.
Patients Contributing to Their Doctors' Notes: Insights From Expert Interviews
TLDR
This study has limitations, including small sample size, nonrandom participant selection, lack of direct patient participation, and potential positive bias if participants sought to please the interviewers, Nevertheless, it is believed that this work raises valuable insights worthy of further exploration.
Epistemic injustice in healthcare: a philosophial analysis
TLDR
It is suggested that a phenomenological toolkit may be part of an effort to ameliorate epistemic injustice and that many aspects of the experience of illness are difficult to understand and communicate and this often owes to gaps in collective hermeneutical resources.
Ethical Challenges Raised by OpenNotes for Pediatric and Adolescent Patients
TLDR
Ethics Rounds discusses 3 illustrative cases highlighting common pediatric OpenNotes concerns and provides guidance for organizations and clinicians regarding documentation practices and patient portal policies to promote patient engagement and information transparency while upholding patient and parent confidentiality and the patient- and/or parent-provider relationship.
...
...