Paternity Uncertainty and Evolutionary Psychology: How a Seemingly Capricious Occurrence Fails to Follow Laws of Greater Generality

@article{Gilding2009PaternityUA,
  title={Paternity Uncertainty and Evolutionary Psychology: How a Seemingly Capricious Occurrence Fails to Follow Laws of Greater Generality},
  author={Michael Gilding},
  journal={Sociology},
  year={2009},
  volume={43},
  pages={140 - 157}
}
  • M. Gilding
  • Published 1 February 2009
  • Psychology
  • Sociology
Evolutionary psychologists aspire to show how —contrary to `soft' social sciences such as sociology — `seemingly capricious' occurrences in the realm of human behaviour follow biologistic `laws of greater generality' (Pinker, 2005: xii).This article is a case study of the `seemingly capricious occurrence' of paternity uncertainty. According to evolutionary psychologists, paternity uncertainty arises from the fact that men are `hard wired' to seek as many sexual partners as they can, and women… 

Tables from this paper

TESTING EVOLUTIONARY THEORIES OF DISCRIMINATIVE GRANDPARENTAL INVESTMENT

TLDR
The results raise doubts over the relevance of paternity uncertainty as an explanation of a grandparental investment bias towards daughters' children that is often found in Western populations and suggest that discriminative grand parental investments are better understood as the outcome of cultural prescriptions and economic motives.

Reflexivity over and above convention: the new orthodoxy in the sociology of personal life, formerly sociology of the family.

  • M. Gilding
  • Sociology
    The British journal of sociology
  • 2010
TLDR
It is argued that the new orthodoxy not only overstates reflexivity at the expense of convention, but abdicates understanding to frameworks grounded in biologistic and economistic understandings of human behaviour.

Choice at the expense of convention: the new orthodoxy in the sociology of personal life and families

There is a new orthodoxy in the field that was once understood as the sociology of the family, and is increasingly understood as the sociology of ‘personal life’ or ‘intimacy’. The orthodoxy

Over Her Dismembered Body : The Crime Fiction of Mo Hayder and Jo Nesbø

Images of dismembered women can affect crime fiction readers in a number of ways: they may shock, enrage, disgust, or titillate them. In her novel Birdman, British author Mo Hayder presents a woman

Adolescent grandchildren’s perceptions of grandparents’ involvement in UK: an interpretation from life course and evolutionary theory perspective

TLDR
The study shows that it is advantageous to merge sociological and evolutionary viewpoints when studying a grandparental involvement in a modern society.

Mas Porquê? Um Estudo Multiteórico dos Preditores da Infidelidade

This study intended to contribute to the advancement of knowledge on marital infidelity, through the identification of its main predictors, from multiple theoretical perspectives and comparing their

Grandparental investments and family dynamics in contemporary Europe

.................................................................................................................. 6 Tiivistelmä

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 42 REFERENCES

How Well Does Paternity Confidence Match Actual Paternity?

Evolutionary theory predicts that males will provide less parental investment for putative offspring who are unlikely to be their actual offspring. Crossculturally, paternity confidence (a mans

The Appalling Appeal of Nature: The Popular Influence of Evolutionary Psychology as a Problem for Sociology

Evolutionary psychology represents a major challenge to sociology, since it claims to provide an alternative, more `objective' account of the human condition and of social problems. It receives

The Optimal Number of Fathers: Evolution, Demography, and History in the Shaping of Female Mate Preferences

  • S. Hrdy
  • Psychology
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
  • 2000
TLDR
Understanding this takes us beyond narrow research programs intent on demonstrating “universal” differences between the sexes, and allows us to study females as flexible and opportunistic individuals who confront recurring reproductive dilemmas and tradeoffs within a world of shifting options.

DNA Paternity Tests: A comparative analysis of the US and Australia

Abstract There are five times as many DNA paternity tests per capita in the US than Australia. This is not a consequence of ‘technological lag’, but a combination of political, cultural and economic

Measuring paternal discrepancy and its public health consequences

TLDR
Using information from genetic and behavioural studies, the article identifies those who conceive younger, live in deprivation, are in long term relationships (rather than marriages), or in certain cultural groups are at higher risk ofaternal discrepancy.

Matrilateral biases in the investment of aunts and uncles

In a study of the kin investment of aunts and uncles we show that the laterality effect expected as a result of paternity uncertainty is statistically reliable but somewhat smaller than the sex

The Optimal Number of Fathers

TLDR
This presumption of monandrous females coupled with males who ranged from monogamous to polygynous shaped the authors' reconstructions of early hominid mating systems.

Aggression *

Aggression as a basic drive was considered by Freud to arise from the Death Instinct i.e. it was viewed as a counter-drive to libido. Objectors to this theory view aggression as normal if it tends to

The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature

The blank slate, the noble savage and the ghost in the machine: the official theory silly putty the last wall to fall culture vultures the slate's last stand. Fear and loathing: political scientists