Pascal's Wager and the Many Gods Objection

@article{Saka2001PascalsWA,
  title={Pascal's Wager and the Many Gods Objection},
  author={Paul Saka},
  journal={Religious Studies},
  year={2001},
  volume={37},
  pages={321 - 341}
}
  • P. Saka
  • Published 1 September 2001
  • Philosophy
  • Religious Studies
Pascal's Wager is finding ever more defenders who aim to undermine the old Many Gods Objection. It is my thesis that they are mistaken. After describing the Wager and the objection, I report on Jeff Jordan's repeated attempt to limit legitimate religious hypotheses to those that are traditional. In separate sections I criticize Jordan, first coming from epistemology and second from anthropology. Then I describe George Schlesinger's repeated appeal to the ‘simplest’ religious hypothesis, and… 
View on Cambridge Press
14 Citations
Background Citations
5

14 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Pascal, Pascalberg, and friends
Pascal’s wager has to face the many gods objection. The wager goes wrong when it asks us to chose between Christianity and atheism, as if there are no other options. Some have argued that we’re…
Gambling on God： A Qualified Defense of Pascal＇s Wager
The paper critically examines and refutes some of the standard arguments against Pascal’s Wager, particularly, the “Many Gods Objection”. The paper argues that Pascal’s philosophical and theological…
Pascal’s Wager and the Nature of God
This paper argues that Pascal’s formulation of his famous wager argument licenses an inference about God's nature that ultimately vitiates the claim that wagering for God is in one’s rational…
THE MANY GODS OBJECTION
The Many Gods Objection (MGO) is widely viewed as a decisive criticism of Pascal’s Wager. Some have attempted to rebut it by employing criteria drawn from the theological tradition. This paper will…
Is a Jamesian Wager the Only Safe Bet? On Jeff Jordan's new book on Pascal's Wager
Abstract In his new book on Pascal's Wager, Jeff Jordan argues that only the ‘Jamesian’ version of the wager argument, as he sees it presented in William James' essay The Will to Believe, constitutes…
Restaging the Will to Believe: Religious Pluralism, Anti‐Syncretism, and the Problem of Belief
In this article, I examine anthropological conceptions of religious belief by concentrating on the problems that arise in employing them in socioreligious fields characterized by pluralism, a high…
Does thinking about the meaning of life make you happy in a religious and globalised world? A 75-nation study
This paper reports on a multilevel study of 75 nations, which tests two hypotheses that arose from considering Tolstoy's experience of thinking about the meaning and purpose of life. The…
Lexicographic preferences in Pascal’s Wager
  • P. Blavatskyy
  • Economics
    The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
  • 2021
TLDR
This paper reformulates Pascal’s wager in terms of two-outcome finite payoffs (one before death and one afers death) to show that the wager must be placed before death or after death.
To believe or not believe…or not decide: A decision-theoretic model of agnosticism
Using decision theory, we construct a stylized theory of agnosticism, defined as choosing not to choose a religion. The theory indicates agnosticism can be supported as a rational choice if (a)…
An offer you can't (rationally) refuse: systematically exploiting utility-maximisers with malicious gambles.
Decision theory aims to provide mathematical analysis of which choice one should rationally make in a given situation. Our current decision theory norms have been very successful, however, several…
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 46 REFERENCES
On Rescher on Pascal's Wager
In Pascal's Wager: A Study Of Practical Reasoning In Philosophical Theology} Nicholas Rescher aims to show that, contrary to received philosophical opinion, Pascal's Wager argument is "the vehicle of…
Betting against Pascal's Wager
Only one traditional objection to Pascal's wager is telling: Pascal assumes a particular theology, but without justification. We produce two new objections that go deeper. We show that even if…
Pascal's wager revisited
Pascal's wager attempts to provide a prudential reason in support of the rationality of believing that God exists. The wager employs the idea that the utility of theistic belief, if true, is…
A defence of Pascal's wager
Pascal's Wager, and the issues raised by it, have, despite a few notable exceptions, been an object of some neglect in recent Philosophy of Religion. Whether this neglect is from an assumption that…
Two caricatures, I: Pascal's wager
Pascal’s wager and Leibniz’s theory that this is the best of a ll possible worlds are latecomers in the Faith-and-Reason tradition. They have remained interlopers; they have never been taken as…
On four critiques of Pascal's Wager
It is perhaps well known that Pasca l ' s Wager is not taken seriously by con temporary philosophers; it is usually quickly dismissed. What is perhaps not so widely known is that some of these con…
"Infini rien" : Pascal's wager and the human paradox
The wager fragment in Blaise Pascal's "Pensees "opens with the phrase ""infini rien""--"infinite nothing"--which is meant to describe the human condition. Pascal was responding to what was, even in…
Pascal's wager and the atheist's dilemma
Le dilemme du doute de l'athee (n'ayant pas de preuve de l'existence de Dieu, il n'a pas de preuve de sa non-existence, et par la doute de son doute) et l'argument de Pascal qui lui est destine
Recent criticisms and defenses of Pascal's Wager
Le pari pascalien est un des arguments les plus interessants de la philosophie de la religion. Il fonde la foi et l'existence de Dieu sur des bases prudentes et avantageuses. Envisager le pari comme…
Conservatism and Tacit Confirmation
i. Methodological conservativism holds that believing a statement is a reason to continue to believe it. It also favours hypotheses that are introduced earlier than competitors. Other conservative…
...
1
2
3
4
5
...