Party and Leader Effects in Parliamentary Elections: Towards a Reassessment

  title={Party and Leader Effects in Parliamentary Elections: Towards a Reassessment},
  author={Diego Garzia},
  pages={175 - 185}
Social-psychological models of voting behaviour systematically downsize the relevance of party leader evaluations by conceiving them as mere consequences of causally prior partisan attachments. However, the validity of this interpretation depends heavily on the effectively exogenous status of party identification. Empirical research shows that the assumed exogeneity of partisanship is, at best, doubtful. In such a context, single-equation models of voting are likely to provide seriously biased… 

Tables from this paper

Electoral infidelity: Why party members cast defecting votes
Party politics and electoral research generally assume that party members are loyal voters. This article first assesses the empirical basis for this assumption before providing individual-level
Losers' Second Chances and Control of the Party Machine: Aspirant Premiers in Regional Spain
In parliamentary democracies, controlling party machines has traditionally been a key asset for nascent political leaders, allowing them to continue in their position even after suffering a bad
Personalization of Politics between Television and the Internet Leader Effects in the 2013 Italian Parliamentary Election
ABSTRACTThis paper provides an empirical assessment of the relationship between media exposure and leader effects on voting through an analysis of Italy––an ideal case for the study of the
Leader Change, Time in Office and the Determinants of Voter Perceptions
There is a significant literature on the role of both parties and leaders in electoral politics and a broad understanding of the strength of the relationship between the two in voters’ minds.
Leaders as cognitive shortcuts: on the representation of political competition at the European elections of 2014 in Italy
ABSTRACT The huge success of the Democratic Party at the last European Parliament (EP) election in Italy has been widely interpreted as due to the unusual ability of its new leader Matteo Renzi to
Personalization of Politics Between Television and the Internet: Leader Effects in the 2013 Italian Parliamentary Election
ABSTRACT This paper provides an empirical assessment of the relationship between media exposure and leader effects on voting through an analysis of Italy––an ideal case for the study of the
Party transformation, leadership change and closeness to parties: the case of Italy, 2013
ABSTRACT Previous studies have portrayed the personalisation of politics as a consequence of changes in the electoral market and the resulting transformations at the party level. However, empirical
The effect of voters’ economic perception, Brexit and campaigns on the evaluation of party leaders over time
When and why do voters change their evaluation of party leaders? Voters’ evaluations of party leaders are an increasingly important determinant of electoral behaviour. Which factors influence these
Does It Pay Off? The Effects of Party Leadership Elections on Parties’ Trustworthiness and Appeal to Voters
In the last few decades, political parties in several Western countries have opened up the process of leadership selection to all party members. So far, research has mainly focused on the drivers of
The sources of mass partisanship in newer democracies: Social identities or performance evaluations? Southern Europe in comparative perspective
  • M. Lisi
  • Psychology, Political Science
  • 2014
This study seeks to improve the current conceptualisation of partisanship and to provide empirical evidence about the nature of partisan identities in new democracies. Conventional theories suggest


Economics, Party, and the Vote: Causality Issues and Panel Data
Conventional wisdom argues that national economic perceptions generally have an important impact on the vote choice in democracies. Recently, a revisionist view has arisen, contending that this link,
Reciprocal Effects of Policy Preferences, Party Loyalties and the Vote
Past studies have offered diverse estimates of the role of policy preferences, party loyalties, candidate personalities and other factors in voting decisions. Most have postulated recursive (that is,
Changing Parties, Changing Partisans: The Personalization of Partisan Attachments in Western Europe
This article investigates the effects of the deep transformations in the relationship between West European class-mass parties and their electorates. Particular attention is paid to the changing
PARTY IDENTIFICATION: Unmoved Mover or Sum of Preferences?
▪ Abstract Are party identifications relatively fixed features on the political landscape in the United States and elsewhere? If they are relatively fixed, do identifications move substantive issue
Big expectations, small outcomes: The impact of leaders' personal appeal in the 2004 Greek election
Abstract The 2004 Greek election provides an interesting case study for examining the impact of party leaders on the vote. A change in governing party leadership a few months before polling day had
The Personalization of Politics in Western Democracies: Causes and Consequences on Leader-Follower Relationships
The article provides an assessment of the most recent literature on political leadership by focusing on its effects on voters' cognition and behavior, in the light of the ongoing personalization of
Leaders' personalities and the outcomes of democratic elections
A widely held belief concerning democratic elections is that the votes of many individuals are influenced by their assessments of the competing candidates’ personalities and other personal
Partisanship and the vote in Australia: Changes over time 1967–1990
This study investigates the influence of partisanship on the vote in Australia between 1967 and 1990. The investigation is the context of a model of electoral choice based on the “revisionist”
A Simultaneous Equation Model of Canadian Voting Behaviour
Recent research on voting in United States presidential elections has begun to disentangle long-term and short-term components of electoral choice. This has been achieved through the use of complex
The European Voter. A Comparative Study of Modern Democracies
1. The European Voter 2. Political Parties and Party Systems 3. Electoral Turnout 4. Social Structure and Party Choice 5. Party Identification and Party Choice 6. Value Orientations and Party Choice