Paradox and Persuasion: Negotiating the Place of Molecular Evolution within Evolutionary Biology

@article{Dietrich1998ParadoxAP,
  title={Paradox and Persuasion: Negotiating the Place of Molecular Evolution within Evolutionary Biology},
  author={M. Dietrich},
  journal={Journal of the History of Biology},
  year={1998},
  volume={31},
  pages={85-111}
}
  • M. Dietrich
  • Published 1998
  • Biology, Medicine
  • Journal of the History of Biology
Les chercheurs en biologie moleculaire ont impose leurs recherches au sein de la biologie et ont du se distinguer des travaux effectues en biologie des organismes 
The centrality of evolution in biology teaching: towards a pluralistic perspective
The central importance of evolution to all biological sciences is recognised by many authors. Despite this scientific consensus, the theory of evolution is commonly presented as one discrete topic ...
Ernst Mayr and evolutionary biology: Polemics and synthesis
Here, I attempt to explore the interactions between evolutionary biologist Ernst Mayr and other biologists in the process that has been called the professionalizing of evolutionary biology, and inExpand
The structure of microbial evolutionary theory.
  • J. Sapp
  • Biology, Medicine
  • Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2007
TLDR
A trio of primary phylogenetic lineages, along with the recognition of symbiosis and lateral gene transfer as fundamental processes of evolutionary innovation, are core principles of microbial evolutionary biology today and their scope and significance remain contentious among evolutionists. Expand
Three Perspectives on Neutrality and Drift in Molecular Evolution
TLDR
Three contrasting cases of the use of neutrality and drift in molecular evolution are offered: neutrality is assumed as a simplest case for modeling, concepts of drift and neutrality are developed within the context of population genetics testing and the development of the molecular clock. Expand
The Experimental Study of Bacterial Evolution and Its Implications for the Modern Synthesis of Evolutionary Biology
TLDR
A historical overview of bacterial evolutionary research between the 1940s and 1980s concludes with reflections on whatacterial evolutionary research achieved in this period, and its implications for the still-developing modern synthesis. Expand
Molecular Evolution, History of
TLDR
The rise of DNA sequencing in the 1980s and 1990s reinforced the distinction between organismal and molecular evolution with new statistical tests to differentiate selection from neutrality at the sequence level. Expand
'Molecules and monkeys': George Gaylord Simpson and the challenge of molecular evolution.
  • J. D. Aronson
  • Philosophy, Medicine
  • History and philosophy of the life sciences
  • 2002
TLDR
Simpson's belief in the supremacy of natural selection as the primary driving force of evolution, as well as his view that biology was a historical science that seeks ultimate causes and highlights contingency, prevented him from acknowledging that the study of molecular evolution was an inherently valuable part of the life sciences. Expand
Rate variation during molecular evolution: creationism and the cytochrome c molecular clock
TLDR
This paper traces some of the history of extensive research into the topic of rate heterogeneity in cytochrome c including data from cy tochrome c pseudogenes to resolve the apparent anomaly of human cyto chrome c differs from that of an alligator but differs by 14 amino acids from a much more closely related primate. Expand
The Molecular Basis of Evolution and Disease: A Cold War Alliance
TLDR
Advances in research on protein structure and function as reflected in Christian Anfinsen's The molecular basis of evolution are connected with a political reading of Emilé Zuckerkandl and Linus Pauling’s identification of molecular disease and evolution. Expand
Molecular evolution: concepts and the origin of disciplines.
  • E. Suárez-Díaz
  • Philosophy, Medicine
  • Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2009
TLDR
The present essay suggests focusing on the role of scientific concepts in the double configuration of disciplines: the social/political and the epistemic order, in the case of Molecular Evolution the concepts of molecular clock and informational molecules played a central role. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 16 REFERENCES
Evolutionary Rate at the Molecular Level
Calculating the rate of evolution in terms of nucleotide substitutions seems to give a value so high that many of the mutations involved must be neutral ones.
Unifying biology: the evolutionary synthesis and evolutionary biology.
  • V. Smocovitis
  • Biology, Medicine
  • Journal of the history of biology
  • 1992
TLDR
This chapter discusses the construction of the Narrative of Unifying Biology, the history of science as Discourse and Culture, and the role of language in the development of science. Expand
The neutral theory of molecular evolution.
TLDR
It is stated that these sequences differed in the cytochromes c of various species to an extent that seemed unnecessary from the standpoint of their function. Expand
The origins of the neutral theory of molecular evolution
  • M. Dietrich
  • Medicine
  • Journal of the history of biology
  • 1994
TLDR
Molecular biology has had a profound impact on the nature of the biological sciences in the twentieth century and has also dramatically altered researchers' attitudes toward the question which problems or problem areas are of fundamental importance, nowhere more evident than in hybrid fields such as molecular evolution. Expand
Albumin evolution in frogs: a test of the evolutionary clock hypothesis.
TLDR
The serum albumins of numerous frog species were compared by the quantitative microcomplement fixation technique and revealed large differences between albumins among frogs, which can be explained by the hypothesis that albumin evolution has proceeded at the same rate in frogs as in mammals. Expand
The Politics of Macromolecules: Molecular Biologists, Biochemists, and Rhetoric
TLDR
It is shown that not until a generation later, in the 1 960s, did the scientific establishment begin to register and respond to this ongoing restructuring of the scientific order away from traditional disciplinary regimes, with their monopolies over the academic reproduction of "knowledgepower" systems and resulting social control. Expand
Evolutionary Divergence and Convergence in Proteins
TLDR
The evaluation of the amount of differences between two organisms as derived from sequences in structural genes or in their polypeptide translation is likely to lead to quantities different from those obtained on the basis of observations made at any other, higher level of biological integration. Expand
The importance of gene rearrangement in evolution: evidence from studies on rates of chromosomal, protein, and anatomical evolution.
TLDR
The rapid rate of gene rearrangement in mammals parallels both their rapid anatomical evolution and their rapid evolutionary loss of the potential for interspecific hybridization, and may be more important than point mutations as sources for evolutionary changes in anatomy and way of life. Expand
Two types of molecular evolution. Evidence from studies of interspecific hybridization.
TLDR
It is thought that the most likely explanation for the marked molecular restriction on hybridization among mammals is that the ratio of regulatory evolution to protein evolution is higher for mammals than for frogs. Expand
Molecular Evolutionary Genetics
TLDR
Recent developments of statistical methods in molecular phylogenetics are reviewed and it is shown that the mathematical foundations of these methods are not well established, but computer simulations and empirical data indicate that currently used methods produce reasonably good phylogenetic trees when a sufficiently large number of nucleotides or amino acids are used. Expand
...
1
2
...