Ownership and Justice for Animals

  title={Ownership and Justice for Animals},
  author={Alasdair Cochrane},
  pages={424 - 442}
This article argues that it is not necessary to abolish all incidents of animal ownership in order to achieve justice for them. It claims that ownership does not grant owners a right to absolute control of their property. Rather, it argues that ownership is a much more qualified concept, conveying different rights in different contexts. With this understanding of ownership in mind, the article argues that it is possible for humans to own animals and at the same time to treat them justly: to… 
Animal Justice as Non-Domination
Legal systems in the Western world currently regard animals as property. This status implies that they are not subjects of rights. None of the recent legal measures aimed at protecting animals have
The Five Freedoms of Animal Welfare are Rights
In this paper I defend a theory of welfare rights for nonhuman animals. I do this by demonstrating that a well-established framework for protecting the interests of farm animals, the ‘Five Freedoms
Liberalism and Animals
In the previous two chapters we saw that the rise of utilitarianism led to an increased concern for animals amongst political theorists. While writers such as Hutcheson, Primatt and Bentham all made
Two Forms of Abolitionism and the Political Rights of Animals: A Case Study
Abstract:Political theorists advocating the abolition of instrumental uses of groups of animals are divided with respect to how they evaluate welfare reforms. Radical abolitionists maintain that
Canine Justice: An Associative Account
A prominent view in contemporary political theory, the ‘associative view’, says that duties of justice are triggered by particular cooperative relations between morally significant agents, and that
Duties to Companion Animals
This paper outlines the moral contours of human relationships with companion animals. The paper details three sources of duties to and regarding companion animals: (1) from the animal’s status as
Feminism and Animals
In the last chapter, we saw that irrespective of the theoretical links between Marxism and justice for animals, the two social movements related to them possess close historical connections. Many
Shaving Ockham
Visa Kurki’s ‘A Theory of Legal Personhood’ makes an impressive effort to put legal personhood on a more rigorous analytical footing without shying away from contentious issues such as the legal
An Anti-Commodification Defense of Veganism
Abstract We develop an anti-commodification defense of ethical veganism which holds that common defenses of ethical veganism can benefit from treating the commodification of non-human animals as a
An Evolutionary Concept Analysis of Caring for a Pet as an Everyday Occupatio
This study explores the everyday occupations of caring for a pet, as conveyed in the North American print media spanning 1999-2008 that discusses pet ownership. The incidence of pet ownership is


Do Animals Have an Interest in Liberty?
Proponents of justice for animals often argue that non-human animals have an interest in liberty. Furthermore, they usually claim that this animal interest in liberty is intrinsic rather than
The Case for Animal Rights
I regard myself as an advocate of animal rights—as part of the animal rights movement. That movement, as I conceive it, is committed to a number of goals, including: the total abolition of the
Animals, Property, and the Law
Foreword - William M. Kunstler, Esq. Preface and Acknowledgments Introduction: Legal Welfarism: The Consequences of the Property Status of Animals Part I: The Status of Animals as Property 1. The
Beyond animal rights : a feminist caring ethic for the treatment of animals
This collection of essays seek to extend and further explore the feminist ethic-of-care theory to the issue of animal well-being. Together the contributors suggest ways that theorists may move beyond
Whose Body is it Anyway?: Justice and the Integrity of the Person
1. A Rights-based Theory of Justice 2. Good Samaritanism 3. A Civilian Service 4. Confiscating Cadaveric Organs 5. Confiscating Live Body Parts 6. Organ Sales 7. Prostitution 8. Surrogacy Contracts
Markets and Justice
In this thirty-first annual volume in the American Society of Legal and Political Philosophy's NOMOS series, entitled Markets and Justice, a number of distinguished authors consider a variety of
Animals and the law : property, cruelty, rights
Etude du statut legal de l'animal dans le systeme juridique americain. Soulevant la question de savoir si le droit considere les animaux comme des objets inanimes impropres a une protection
The Great ape project : equality beyond humanity
A new "community of equals" which would accept certain basic moral principles or rights as governing the authors' relations with each other, and enforceable by law, would include the right to life, the protection of individual liberty and the prohibition of torture.
  • I. Kant
  • Philosophy, Art
    The Development of Kant's View of Ethics
  • 2019
Introduction J. B. Schneedwind Part I. Kant's Practical Philosophy: 1. Herder's lecture notes (selections) Part II. Moral Philosophy: 2. Collins's lecture notes Part III. Morality According to
The Political Philosophy of Needs
Preface Introduction 1. Liberalism's rights-preferences couple 2. Beyond the rights-preferences couple 3. The form and outline of the argument Part I. The Nature of Needs: 4. Need categories 5. Vital