Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes

@article{Karkazis2012OutOB,
  title={Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes},
  author={Katrina Karkazis and Rebecca M. Jordan-Young and Georgiann Davis and Silvia Camporesi},
  journal={The American Journal of Bioethics},
  year={2012},
  volume={12},
  pages={16 - 3}
}
In May 2011, more than a decade after the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) and the International Olympic Committee (IOC) abandoned sex testing, they devised new policies in response to the IAAF's treatment of Caster Semenya, the South African runner whose sex was challenged because of her spectacular win and powerful physique that fueled an international frenzy questioning her sex and legitimacy to compete as female. These policies claim that atypically high levels of… 
The New Policy on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes is Not About “Sex Testing”
TLDR
Reactions to claims that the new regulation promotes a sex-verification test, claims that intersex athletes will automatically be disqualified from competition, and proposals to either divide athletes based on variables beyond sex or completely eliminate sex groupings are offered.
Same Tricks, New Name: The IAAF’s New 2018 Testosterone Regulation Policy for Female Athletes
  • Anna Posbergh
  • Education
    The International Journal of Information, Diversity, & Inclusion (IJIDI)
  • 2019
On April 26, 2018, the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) released its updated version of its policy on athletes with hyperandrogenism, in a discriminatory attempt to define
Testosterone: ‘the Best Discriminating Factor’
In 2011 the IAAF introduced the Hyperandrogenism Regulations in an attempt to deal with a difficult problem; that of ensuring ‘fair’ competition in female athletics as a result of athletes with
Rupturing the World of Elite Athletics: A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis of the Suspension of the 2011 IAAF Regulations on Hyperandrogenism
In 2011 the International Association of Athletic Federations (IAAF) published the Regulations on Hyperandrogenism, a health policy banning female athletes from track and field competition if their
The Interconnected Histories of Endocrinology and Eligibility in Women’s Sport
This report illustrates the links between history, sport, endocrinology, and genetics to show the ways in which historical context is key to understanding the current conversations and controversies
Sport Is Arbitrary, and That's OK
TLDR
It is suggested that elite sport is more accurately characterized as entertainment, pure and simple, and this alternative characterization of sport has implications for the moral arguments made by the authors regarding the androgenic exclusion criteria.
Hormonal Eligibility Criteria for ‘Includes Females' Competition: A Practical but Problematic Solution
  • D. Allen
  • Education
    Hormone Research in Paediatrics
  • 2016
TLDR
An analysis of available evidence suggests that androgen-based criteria can, in fact, be rationally defended as the best currently available and practical approach to determine eligibility for competition in the ‘includes females' category.
Determination and regulation of body composition in elite athletes
TLDR
This review covers the scientific knowledge about the development and regulation of body composition in humans but also considers the lessons learnt from evolution and breeding in animals and the key factors determining body composition are considered.
What do we do about women athletes with testes?
TLDR
This approach discusses this approach and considers alternative methods of approaching the problem of women with testes in athletics.
Good enough? The ‘wicked’ use of testosterone for defining femaleness in women’s sport
Abstract Since the 1930s, sports administrators have insisted on various mechanisms to assess ‘femaleness’ for the purpose of competition in women’s sport. Most recently, the criterion has turned to
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 131 REFERENCES
The history and current policies on gender testing in elite athletes : review article
TLDR
The abandonment of compulsory sex verification tests of female athletes was followed by most international sports federations, and in the end also by the International Olympic Committee (IOC), although initially only provisionally.
Gender verification of female athletes
TLDR
The history and rationales for fairness in female-only sports that have led to the rise and fall of on-site, chromosome-based gender verification at international sporting events are reviewed.
The science of sex verification and athletic performance.
TLDR
This review will provide the historical context of the debate, aim to discuss relevant physiological and performance aspects of the sex verification process, and provide sound scientific evidence to determine whether a performance advantage actually exists and how large it might be.
Sex Typing for Sport
  • A. Dreger
  • Education
    The Hastings Center report
  • 2010
TLDR
In January, the International Olympic Committee sponsored a meeting of medical professionals in Miami aimed at revising the "gender verification" policies of the IOC and the International Association of Athletics Federations, which failed to produce any clear consensus and only seemed to create confusion about what is now considered fair or allowable so far as sports gender divisions go.
Gender verification in the Olympics.
TLDR
The medical community should applaud the decision of the IOC to abolish onsite gender verification preceding athletic events, effective with the current Summer Olympics in Sydney, Australia.
Testing sex and gender in sports; reinventing, reimagining and reconstructing histories
Gender Verification in Competitive Sports
TLDR
Sex chromatin testing unfairly excludes many athletes because of the current use of urine testing to exclude doping, and still fails to address the fundamental inequities of laboratory based gender verification tests.
Time to re-evaluate gender segregation in athletics?
TLDR
The case of Caster Semenya provides a vivid illustration of the ways in which natural genetic variation can generate large differences in athletic performance, but since she is a female, her case also highlights problems with the current approach to justice in sporting competition.
Genetics of athletic performance.
TLDR
What is known regarding the genes and gene families, including the mitochondrial genome, that are believed to play a role in human athletic performance are discussed and the implications on the future for competitive athletics are discussed.
Intersex and the Olympic Games
TLDR
The historical impact of intersex in the area of international sports is reviewed and current thinking with regard to determination of sex in sports men and women is discussed.
...
...