Order matters: Alphabetizing in-text citations biases citation rates

@article{Stevens2019OrderMA,
  title={Order matters: Alphabetizing in-text citations biases citation rates},
  author={Jeffrey R. Stevens and Juan F. Duque},
  journal={Psychonomic Bulletin \& Review},
  year={2019},
  volume={26},
  pages={1020-1026}
}
Though citations are critical for communicating science and evaluating scholarly success, properties unrelated to the quality of the work—such as cognitive biases—can influence citation decisions. The primacy effect, in particular, is relevant to lists, which for in-text citations could result in citations earlier in the list receiving more attention than those later in the list. Therefore, how citations are ordered could influence which citations receive the most attention. Using a sample of… 

Analysis of the scientific literature's abstract writing style and citations

This study analyses the differences between the abstracts of highly cited and those of zero-cited papers, reveals the common external and deep semantic features ofhighly cited papers in abstract writing styles, and provides suggestions for researchers on abstract writing.

Article Length and Citation Outcomes

Focusing on articles published between 2010 and 2014 in the top five journals in economics and their citation count in Google Scholar, it is found that a one per cent increase in page length generates a 0.55 per cent rise in the number of citations.

Scholarly Communication and Open Access in Psychology: Current Considerations for Researchers

Scholarly communication and open access practices in psychological science are rapidly evolving. However, most published works that focus on scholarly communication issues do not target the specific

Behavior of the References Cited by the Colombian Engineering Scientific Journals

The continuous work of scientific journals leads to evaluate different aspects that allow establishing a quality seal and, therefore, recognition of researchers, and thus drawing attention of

Citations in scientific articles: possibly biased reflections on the field of diagnostic imaging

This Editorial Comment refers to the article “Citation Bias in Imaging Research: Are studies with higher diagnostic accuracy estimates cited more often?” by Frank RA, Sharifabadi AD, Salameh JP et

Does word order predict ethnocentric helping behavior? Results of a ‘lost letter’ field experiment in Berlin

Word order in intergroup labels may strengthen ethnocentrism as people tend to name their in-group first and perceive it as more important than the second. To test for corresponding helping behavior

Psychological and behavioral effects of personal names in real world: Evidence and theories

: Personal names not only can influence others’ impression and evaluation, but also may affect individuals’ own psychology and behavior in real world. Over the past century, psychologists have

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 40 REFERENCES

DO ABCs GET MORE CITATIONS THAN XYZs

type="main" xml:id="ecin12125-abs-0001"> Using a sample of U.S.-based scientific journal articles, I examine the relationship between author surname initials and paper citations, finding that the

The Effects of Listing Authors in Alphabetical Order: A Review of the Empirical Evidence

This article reviews the empirical literature and finds convincing evidence that alphabetical discrimination exists and that researchers react to it.

Source References and the Scientist’s Mind-Map: Harvard vs. Vancouver Style

As a scientist develops, a referencing system (linking results/hypotheses to sources) evolves in the mind. This mind-map is an essential working tool that uses indexing features—such as author

Citation systems in the biosciences: A history, classification and descriptive terminology

This paper is to document an analysis of their designs in the biosciences in order to construct a classification and to assess their comparative effectiveness for information transfer.

Does Presentation Order Impact Choice After Delay?

Using 25 years of citation data, and a unique identification strategy, the relationship between article order (i.e., position in a journal issue) and citation count and results indicate that mere serial position affects the prominence that research achieves.

What's in a Surname? The Effects of Surname Initials on Academic Success

In this paper, we focus on the effects of surname initials on professional outcomes in the academic labor market for economists. We begin our analysis with data on faculty in all top 35 U.S.

The Most Influential Paper Gerard Salton Never Wrote

The vector space model (VSM) as it is understood today evolved over a longer time period than is usually acknowledged, and an articulation of the model and its assumptions did not appear in print until several years after those assumptions had been criticized and alternative models proposed.

A general theory of bibliometric and other cumulative advantage processes

  • D. Price
  • Mathematics
    J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci.
  • 1976
It is shown that such a stochastic law is governed by the Beta Function, containing only one free parameter, and this is approximated by a skew or hyperbolic distribution of the type that is widespread in bibliometrics and diverse social science phenomena.

How Does the Market Use Citation Data? The Hirsch Index in Economics

A large literature following Hirsch (2005) has proposed citation-based indexes that could be used to rank academics. This paper examines how well several such indexes match labor market outcomes