Open access and accuracy: author‐archived manuscripts vs. published articles

@article{Goodman2007OpenAA,
  title={Open access and accuracy: author‐archived manuscripts vs. published articles},
  author={David Goodman and Sarah Dowson and Jean Yaremchuk},
  journal={Learned Publishing},
  year={2007},
  volume={20}
}
Some approaches to open access (OA) use authors' manuscript copies for the OA version, in the form accepted after peer review but prior to full editing. Advocates of such approaches are certain that these versions differ only trivially from the publishers' versions; many of those who oppose them are equally certain that there can be major discrepancies. In a pilot study, we have examined the actual differences in a small number of such article pairs in the social sciences and in biology. Using… 
Minding our ps and qs: Issues of property, provenance, quantity and quality in institutional repositories
TLDR
This paper will conceptually examine the complex interplay of rights, permissions and versions between publishers and repositories, focussing on the New Zealand situation and the challenges faced by university repositories in recruiting high-quality peer-reviewed documents for the open access domain.
What I've Learned about Publishing a Book
Many accounts that describe the procedures of academic writing focus on how authors can attract publishers by revising their dissertations so that they have appeal beyond their more narrow academic
Journals and repositories: an evolving relationship?
TLDR
This paper puts forward three possible models of interaction between repositories and journals; services such as arXiv and PubMed Central, and the work carried out by the RIOJA project, are working exemplars and pilot implementations of these models.
Review of the Ethics and Etiquettes of Time Management of Manuscript Peer Review
TLDR
This is a review of the studies that have followed up the suggestions made by Ingelfinger in 1974 for improvement of manuscript peer review and it is time for high earning publishers to consider compensation for the efforts of the reviewers.
Researchers' green open access practice: a cross-disciplinary analysis
TLDR
The research found that disciplinary cultures, norms and traditions shape authors' self‐archiving behaviour and readers' use of those versions of journal articles held in repositories.
Faculty self-archiving behavior: Factors affecting the decision to self-archive
TLDR
This dissertation investigates university faculty members’ self-archiving behavior the placement of research materials on publicly accessible web sites, such as personal web pages, research group web Sites, or Open Access repositories to assist stakeholders to design and implement repositories for self- archiving in a successful manner.
PEER behavioural research: authors and users vis-à-vis journals and repositories. D4.2 final report.
TLDR
The aim of the Behavioural research project was to address the role of stage-two manuscript repositories in the scholarly and scientific communication system by exploring perceptions, motivations and behaviours of authors and readers.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 29 REFERENCES
Author's version vs. publisher's version: an analysis of the copy‐editing function
This report describes an informal study carried out by Blackwell Publishing to assess whether the copy‐editing and proof‐correction process alone results in a significant difference between the
Do Open-Access Articles Have a Greater Research Impact?
Although many authors believe that their work has a greater research impact if it is freely available, studies to demonstrate that impact are few. This study looks at articles in four disciplines at
The Criteria for Open Access
TLDR
These criteria, both individually and also as each of them contributes to the different proposals for OA, are discussed, to improve the level of factual understanding in the ongoing discussions.
Institutional Repositories: Evaluating the Reasons for Non-use of Cornell University's Installation of DSpace
TLDR
The contents and participation in Cornell’s DSpace are described and compared with seven university DSpace installations and in-depth interviews with eleven faculty members in the sciences, social sciences and humanities are explored, exploring their attitudes, motivations, and behaviors for non-participation in institutional repositories.
Constructing Social Problems in an Age of Globalization: A French-American Comparison
Despite growing academic interest in political and cultural globalization, sociologists have failed to systematically account for the factors that favor cross-national convergence or divergence in
Judicial Checks and Balances
In the Anglo‐American constitutional tradition, judicial checks and balances are often seen as crucial guarantees of freedom. Hayek distinguishes two ways in which the judiciary provides such checks
Two Visual Processing Pathways Are Targeted by Gonadotropin-Releasing Hormone in the Retina
TLDR
The expression patterns of two GnRH receptor subtypes in the retina of a teleost fish suggest that GnRH from the TN could broadly influence processing of retinal signals both in lateral processing circuits through GnRH-R1 and in the vertical throughput pathway through Gn RH-R2.
...
...