One-Thirteenth of a Data Point Does Not a Generalization Make: A Response to Dulić

@article{Rummel2004OneThirteenthOA,
  title={One-Thirteenth of a Data Point Does Not a Generalization Make: A Response to Duli{\'c}},
  author={Rudolph J. Rummel},
  journal={Journal of Peace Research},
  year={2004},
  volume={41},
  pages={103 - 104}
}
  • R. Rummel
  • Published 1 January 2004
  • Political Science
  • Journal of Peace Research
While Dulić’s article is a helpful assessment of the sources Rummel used, it fails as a test of his general democide estimation methods or as an evaluation of his democide estimate for Tito’s Yugoslavia. Aside from mistakenly generalizing from one regime to Rummel’s results for 218, Dulić ignores 39 years of Rummel’s estimates for 1949–87 to concentrate on his own estimation of what Rummel’s estimate would be for 1944–48 (12.8% of the period Rummel covered). Dulić loads his estimate with war… 

A Reply to Rummel

Dulić argues that Rummel has avoided the central point of his critique, namely, that of source criticism, and argues that the case study on Tito’s Yugoslavia might well have wider implications, since it focuses on Rummels method.

Violence against civilians 1900-87: A four-part analysis using av new dataset to test the relationship between the severity of democide and type of government

The study of violence against civilians with its over 200 million dead in the 20th century is understudied if viewed in terms of the death toll compared to the studies of inter-state and civil war.

Chapter 8 The Liberal Moment Fifteen Years On

  • Political Science
  • 2015
Fifteen years ago, Charles Kegley spoke of a neoidealist moment in international relations. This article examines how the number of armed conflicts has declined in the decade and a half since

The Liberal Moment Fifteen Years On

Fifteen years ago, Charles Kegley spoke of a neoidealist moment in international relations. This article examines how the number of armed conflicts has declined in the decade and a half since

R.J. Rummel—A Multi-faceted Scholar

Rudolph J. Rummel always published just as R.J. Rummel but was well known in the profession as Rudy. He was a man of many talents, and to some of his readers he may also have seemed to present many

Data and progress in peace and conflict research

We highlight how efforts to collect systematic data on conflict have helped foster progress in peace and conflict research. The Journal of Peace Research has played a key role in these developments,

References

Tito’s Slaughterhouse: A Critical Analysis of Rummel’s Work on Democide

The article provides a critical analysis of the quantitative method used by Rudolph J. Rummel in order to estimate the democide rate for various political systems in the 20th century. The first part