On the history of Ludwig von Bertalanffy’s “General Systemology”, and on its relationship to cybernetics – part III: convergences and divergences

@article{Drack2015OnTH,
  title={On the history of Ludwig von Bertalanffy’s “General Systemology”, and on its relationship to cybernetics – part III: convergences and divergences},
  author={Manfred Drack and David Pouvreau},
  journal={International Journal of General Systems},
  year={2015},
  volume={44},
  pages={523 - 571}
}
  • M. Drack, D. Pouvreau
  • Published 23 February 2015
  • Environmental Science
  • International Journal of General Systems
Bertalanffy’s so-called “general system theory” (GST) and cybernetics were and are often confused: this calls for clarification. In this article, Bertalanffy’s conceptions and ideas are compared with those developed in cybernetics in order to investigate the differences and convergences. Bertalanffy was concerned with first order cybernetics. Nonetheless, his perspectivist epistemology is also relevant with regard to developments in second order cybernetics, and the latter is therefore also… 
Reconceiving Cybernetics in Light of Thomistic Realism
Since its origins in the early twentieth century as a transdisciplinary approach connecting the fields of electrical and computer engineering, mechanical engineering, dynamical systems theory, logic
Cybernetics of Observing Systems and Lonergan’s Generalized Empirical Method
Cybernetics is inherently interdisciplinary and reflexive; second-order cybernetics stresses reflective interaction of knowledge and action with the observer. The same themes are central to the work
The Potential of General Systemology as a Transdiscipline
The pioneers of the general systems movement envisioned the development of a new scientific ‘meta-discipline’ grounded in a “General Systems Theory” (GST*), a theory that encompasses universal
Systems and Relations All the Way Down, All the Way Across
This article proposes a hyper-relational theory of the world, conjoining cybernetics, information theory, general systems theory, the philosophy of Deleuze and Guattari and quantum physics in order
An Affinity to Theories in Biology
TLDR
Kant outlined many interesting issues involving concepts, such as system, self-organization, teleology, etc and today these are also relevant for systems biology and looking back at such philosophical considerations is crucial for science in order to get a clear view on basic questions.
THE STRUCTURE OF REALITY: AN EMERGENT HIERARCHY OF AUTONOMOUS LEVELS?
This paper starts with a question: is the structure of reality a hierarchy of autonomous levels emerging from the increasing complexity of matter through evolution? I will critique this deeply held
Ludwig von Bertalanffy's Organismic View on the Theory of Evolution
  • M. Drack
  • Environmental Science
    Journal of experimental zoology. Part B, Molecular and developmental evolution
  • 2015
TLDR
This article begins by outlining the rather unknown (because often written in German) research of Bertalanffy in the field of theoretical biology, and then introduces his own, organismic, view on evolution, leading to the demand for finding laws of evolution.
The Basis of Theory Building in Biology Lies in the Organism Concept – A Historical Perspective on the Shoulders of Three Giants
The rise of molecular biology went hand in hand with a marginalization of the integrative unit in biology – the organism. Although the new methodological approaches contributed to eminent progress in
The Road to Servomechanisms: The Influence of Cybernetics on Hayek from the Sensory Order to the Social Order
TLDR
The concept of negative feedback, borrowed from cybernetics, was central to Hayek’s attempt of giving an explanation of the principle to the emergence of human purposive behavior.
The Road to Servomechanisms : The Influence of Cybernetics on Hayek from The Sensory Order to the Social Order
TLDR
The concept of negative feedback was central to Hayek’s attempt of giving an explanation of the principle to the emergence of human purposive behavior in his works on the spontaneous formation of social orders.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 202 REFERENCES
On the history of Ludwig von Bertalanffy’s “general systemology”, and on its relationship to cybernetics - Part II: Contexts and developments of the systemological hermeneutics instigated by von Bertalanffy
TLDR
The history of “general system theory” is investigated in order to clarify its meanings, vocations, foundations and achievements and finds out the potential systematic unity underlying the diversity of the contributions to this both scientific and philosophical project.
On the history of Ludwig von Bertalanffy's “General Systemology”, and on its relationship to cybernetics
TLDR
The context of “general crisis” in which he developed his intellectual schemes; his “perspectivist” philosophy of knowledge; his elaboration of an “organismic” theoretical biology; his non-reductionist approach to the problem of mathematization of biology and his theory of organic growth.
The project of "general systemology" instigated by Ludwig von Bertalanffy: Genealogy, genesis, reception and advancement
TLDR
The unity of the diverse contributions to the latter's development is asserted in a framework put forward by the author in order to account for its structure and functions.
Second‐order cybernetics: an historical introduction
TLDR
The author gives a brief account of the developments in cybernetics that lead to von Foerster's making his distinction, and includes some recollections of events that were observed and participated in at first hand.
’Neuer Anti-Kant oder Krüfung ber Kritik der reinen Vernunft nach den in Bolzano’s Wissenschaftslehre niebergelegten Begriffen / New Anti-Kant, Or Examination of the Critique of Pure Reason According to the Concepts Laid Down in Bolzano’s Theory of Science
Even today, an examination of Kantian philosophy would not prove to be a belated endeavour. Two different editions of Kant’s works* have appeared in just the past few years, which amply testifies to
The Origins and Purposes of Several Conceptions of Systems Theory and Cybernetics
TLDR
This paper will discuss the books and people, conferences and institutes, and politics and technology that have influenced the systems theory movement and three viewpoints within the heading of cybernetics are discussed.
Comments on a Mechanistic Conception of Purposefulness
In a highly original and provocative essay entitled "Behavior, Purpose and Teleology", published a few years ago,' Professors Arturo Rosenblueth, Norbert Wiener and Julian Bigelow attempt to indicate
An Introduction to Radical Constructivism
The experiencing consciousness creates structure in the flow of its experience, and that structure is what conscious cognitive organisms experience as “reality.” Since that reality is created almost
CYBERNETICS AND GENERAL SYSTEMS—A UNITARY SCIENCE?
TLDR
It is shown how these ideas can provide unified approaches to the problems facing mankind and lead to the development of a new synthesis, bringing together into a whole the fundamental ideas of philosophy, science, religion, personal experience, ethics and the arts in a way that is relevant to the human situation and to practical living.
The science of cybernetics and the cybernetics of science
TLDR
This paper compares cybernetics with two important schools of thought within the philosophy of science, lists several different assumptions that lead to misunderstandings between scientists and cyberneticians, and suggests a way of resolving the differences not by rejecting science but by enlarging it.
...
...