On the Importance of Environmental Claims-Making: The Role of James O. Wright in Promoting the Drainage of Florida's Everglades in the Early Twentieth Century

  title={On the Importance of Environmental Claims-Making: The Role of James O. Wright in Promoting the Drainage of Florida's Everglades in the Early Twentieth Century},
  author={Christopher F. Meindl and Derek Hilton Alderman and Peter R. Waylen},
  journal={Annals of the Association of American Geographers},
  pages={682 - 701}
Responding to recent calls to analyze the authoritative role of scientists in producing environmental knowledge, this article conceptualizes applied scientists as “environmental claims-makers” who play an influential role in shaping how the public perceives and interacts with the environment. Analyzing the knowledge claims of scientists, particularly applied scientists, requires a consideration of both cognitive and interpretive claims-making activities. The concept of environmental claims… Expand
Interpreting Salt Marsh Dynamics: Challenging Scientific Paradigms
From its inception as an object of study, salt marshes were conceived as a form of continual accumulation. For more than a century this paradigm structured the understanding of tidal marshes inExpand
Channing Cope and the Making of a Miracle Vine*
The history of kudzu illustrates the fluidity with which people can redefine their cultural relationship with exotic species. Although much of American society views the fast‐growing Asian vine as aExpand
Economy and culture are dead! Long live economy and culture!
This essay critically evaluates the debate in human geography and cognate fields about economy-culture relationships. It takes issue with the terms of the debate, wherein different authors haveExpand
Alien Invaders, Plant Thugs, and the Southern Curse: Framing Kudzu as Environmental Other through Discourses of Fear
Employing a post-structural political ecology approach, we examine the extent to which exotic species are represented as an environmental ‘other’ that is morally inferior as well as threatening. FewExpand
Theorizing an Alternative Understanding of ‘Disconnects’ between Science and Management
In some management discourses, challenges to using environmental health science in land use decision-making and policy formulation result from ‘disconnects’ between the tools and findings ofExpand
Theorizing Land-Cover and Land-Use Change: The Case of the Florida Everglades and Its Degradation
Abstract This paper possesses two related objectives. The first is to unite the bid-rent model of von Thünen and urban theorists with historical analysis in the interest of providing a theoreticalExpand
Retrospective on Nature–Society Geography: Tracing Trajectories (1911–2010) and Reflecting on Translations
This study uses an intellectual history approach to construct a retrospective on Annals nature–society geography during the past century (1911–2010). It begins by identifying six areas of topics andExpand
Creating the Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument: Discourse, Media, Place-making, and Policy Entrepreneurs
President George W. Bush established the Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument in 2006. Environmental conservation efforts surrounding the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands began more than 100 yearsExpand
Environmental Research and Education in US Geography
This article evaluates geography as an appropriate home for environmental education. First, it argues that many geographers have defined geography as a discipline with a major, if not primary,Expand
Woodfuel Discourses and the Re-framing of Wood Energy
Abstract This article capitalises on the global resurgence of interest in energy issues to reflect anew on discourses surrounding woodfuel production, use and change. Three extant discoursesExpand


Ecology, objectivity and critique in writings on nature and human societies
Abstract Inspired by the Green Movement and invoking many of the analytical concepts of ecological science, environmental historians have offered trenchant criticisms of modern society and itsExpand
The Construction of Global Warming and the Politics of Science
Having outlined a theory of heterogeneous social construction, this article describes the scientific construction of climate change as a global-scale environmental problem caused by the universalExpand
How do we know we have global environmental problems? Science and the globalization of environmental discourse
Science has a central role in shaping what count as environmental problems. This has been evident most recently in the success of planetary science and environmental activism in stimulating awarenessExpand
Environmental issues: knowledge, uncertainty and the environment
Environmental issues have now surfaced in all the social sciences, especially geography, sociology and political science. Yet the unbounded character of the environment has evaded territorialization,Expand
The Everglades: An Environmental History
This work, aimed at general readers and environmentalists alike, offers a dicussion of the formation, development and history of the Everglades, considered by many to be the most endangered ecosystemExpand
Writing in this journal, Michael Redclift (1987a: 223) argued that “Marxist approaches to the ’production of nature’ remain a largely unexplored dimension of theoretical concern” within humanExpand
Contested Ground: Colonial Narratives and the Kenyan Environment, 1920–1945
This article focuses on the relationship between the creation of colonial agricultural and environmental knowledge and the exercise of state power in Kenya during a 25 year period that saw growingExpand
Discovering the Unknown Landscape: A History of America's Wetlands
Review: Discovering the Unknown Landscape: A History of America's Wetlands By Ann Vileisis Reviewed by Graham E.L. Holton Institute of Latin American Studies, La Trobe University, Australia AnnExpand
Environmental Discourses and the Ivorian Savanna
The African continent is portrayed in development texts as experiencing environmental crises of staggering proportions. Despite a lack of reliable data, the World Bank considers environmentalExpand
Intellectual of Empire: Eric Dutton and Hegemony in British Africa
This essay examines the career of Eric Dutton in five British African colonies from 1919 to 1952, with case studies of his work in Lusaka and Zanzibar. In analyzing Dutton's career, I use a GramscianExpand