On the ‘wave momentum’ myth

@article{McIntyre1981OnT,
  title={On the ‘wave momentum’ myth},
  author={Michael E. McIntyre},
  journal={Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year={1981},
  volume={106},
  pages={331 - 347}
}
  • M. McIntyre
  • Published 1 May 1981
  • Physics, Education
  • Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Controversies over ‘the momentum’ of waves have repeatedly wasted the time of physicists for over half a century. The persistence of the controversies is surprising, since regardless of whether classical or quantum dynamics is used the facts of the matter are simple and unequivocal, are well checked by laboratory experiment, are clearly explained in several published papers, and on the theoretical side can easily be verified by straightforward calculations. They are illustrated here by some… 

Figures from this paper

The Quantum State of Classical Matter I: Solids and Measurements
Using the kinematic constraints of classical bodies we construct the allowable wavefunctions corresponding to classical solids. These are shown to be long lived metastable states that are
The Quantum State of Classical Matter I: Solids and Measurements
Using the kinematic constraints of classical bodies we construct the allowable wavefunctions corresponding to classical solids. These are shown to be long lived metastable states that are
Ponderomotive Forces, Stokes Drift, and Momentum in Acoustic and Electromagnetic Waves
We reveal universal connections between three important phenomena in classical wave physics: (i) the ponderomotive force acting on the medium particles in an oscillatory wavefield, (ii) the Stokes
“ Hidden ” Momentum in a Sound Wave
The gas molecules appear to have zero average velocity in the rest frame of the pressure vessel, so it appears that they have zero average momentum in this frame. Of course, the gas molecules exert a
Difference between angular momentum and pseudoangular momentum
In condensed matter systems it is necessary to distinguish between the momentum of the constituents of the system and the pseudomomentum of quasiparticles. The same distinction is also valid for
Field theory spin and momentum in water waves
TLDR
The canonical spin and momentum in water waves are revealed and directly observe these fundamental relativistic field-theory properties as microscopic mechanical properties of particles in a classical wave system.
"Hidden" Momentum in a Sound Wave
The gas molecules appear to have zero average velocity in the rest frame of the pressure vessel, so it appears that they have zero average momentum in this frame. Of course, the gas molecules exert a
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 88 REFERENCES
The momentum of light in a refracting medium
  • R. Peierls
  • Physics
    Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences
  • 1976
It is shown that neither Minkowski’s result, according to which the ratio of momentum to energy for a light wave in a medium of refractive index n is n/c, nor that of Abraham, who found 1/nc, is
On wave-action and its relatives
Conservable quantities measuring ‘wave activity’ are discussed. The equation for the most fundamental such quantity, wave-action, is derived in a simple but very general form which does not depend on
Momentum of Light in a Refracting Medium.
It is pointed out that neither Minkowski’s nor Abraham’s proposal gives correctly the momentum density of light in a refracting medium. The correct result due to Peierls is simply derived. The
Two-timing, variational principles and waves
In this paper, it is shown how the author's general theory of slowly varying wave trains may be derived as the first term in a formal perturbation expansion. In its most effective form, the
INTERACTION BETWEEN HYDROMAGNETIC WAVES AND A TIME-DEPENDENT, INHOMOGENEOUS MEDIUM.
  • R. Dewar
  • Physics, Environmental Science
  • 1970
Consider a system made up of a hydromagnetic wave and the slowly varying background fluid in which it propagates. It is shown that both the effect of the background on the wave and that of the wave
Energy-Momentum Tensors for Dispersive Electromagnetic Waves
Classical relativistic field theory is used as a basis for a general discussion of the problem of splitting up the total energy–momentum tensor of a system into contributions from its component
Hamilton's Principle for Electromagnetic Fluids
Hamilton's principle is used to derive the force equation for both nonrelativistic and relativistic flow of a compressible, inviscid fluid with polarization and magnetization. The resulting
On the mean motion induced by internal gravity waves
  • F. Bretherton
  • Physics, Environmental Science
    Journal of Fluid Mechanics
  • 1969
A train of internal gravity waves in a stratified liquid exerts a stress on the liquid and induces changes in the mean motion of second order in the wave amplitude. In those circumstances in which
...
...