On argumentation in Old English philology, with particular reference to the editing and dating of Beowulf

  title={On argumentation in Old English philology, with particular reference to the editing and dating of Beowulf},
  author={Robert D. Fulk},
  journal={Anglo-Saxon England},
  pages={1 - 26}
  • R. Fulk
  • Published 1 December 2003
  • Linguistics, Art
  • Anglo-Saxon England
If poststructuralist literary and cultural theory does not pervade Anglo-Saxon literary studies as thoroughly as it does scholarship in later periods, as it has sometimes been said, to a considerable extent the cause is surely the field's dependence on philology. Some see this as cause for regret. It may be, however, that philology is the field's greatest asset. Given the high value that recent literary studies accord textual alterity, Old English texts are of unparalleled worth in the English… 
Philology, Allegory, and the Dating of Beowulf
According to Helen Damico’s new monograph, two centuries of philological scholarship on Old English language and literature have accumulated a body of knowledge about the dating of Beowulf and its
The Dating of Widsið and the Study of Germanic Antiquity
A consensus once existed in support of the claim that Widsið is the oldest extant poem in English and one of the earliest substantial documents written in any Germanic language. This consensus came
‘Giving’ and ‘Making’ in Early Runic Epigraphy
A survey of the early Germanic etymological semantics of 'giving' and 'making' is presented in light of the recent reaffirmation that early Nordic *taujan is etymologically related to Old Norse tœja
The Ruthwell Cross Inscription and The Dream of the Rood line 58
ABSTRACT This article examines the divergence between line 58a of the text of The Dream of the Rood preserved in the Vercelli Book (tō þām æðelinge) and the corresponding verse in the text inscribed
A Comparative Grammar of the Early Germanic Languages
  • R. Fulk
  • Linguistics
    Studies in Germanic Linguistics
  • 2018
Fulk’s Comparative Grammar offers an overview of and bibliographical guide to the study of the phonology and the inflectional morphology of the earliest Germanic languages, with particular attention
On the Epistemology of Old English Scholarship
This article analyzes a recent dispute over the dating of Widsið in order to discuss the epistemological and methodological issues involved. Its first half concerns the protocols of hypotheticism,
Bliss’s Rule and Old English Metrics
  • Rafael J. Pascual
  • Linguistics
    ANQ: A Quarterly Journal of Short Articles, Notes and Reviews
  • 2018
Old English poetry is characterized by its varying and unpredictable number of syllables per verse. In Beowulf, for example, tetrasyllabic verses such as l. 42a, on flōdes ǣht, are very frequent, but
The Textual Criticism of The Dream of the Rood
ABSTRACT This article surveys and reassesses a series of problems in the transmitted text of The Dream of the Rood (ll. 9b, 17b, 47b, 70a, 71b, 91a, 117a, and 142a), then reconsiders several special
Three-position Verses and the Metrical Practice of the "Beowulf" Poet
This article assesses the authenticity of the three-position SS verse type in Beowulf on the basis of its unambiguous incidence both in Beowulf and in a larger corpus of Old English poetry. The
The Language of Hrothgar’s Sermon
ABSTRACT This article surveys linguistic archaisms in Hrothgar’s sermon in order to argue for the authenticity of this passage and for the unselfconscious nature of archaism in Beowulf. It furnishes


Perusing a recent critical appraisal of the numerous attempts at dating Old English poetry by linguistic and metrical criteria is a sobering but not a disheartening experience. None of the tests
The metre of Beowulf
Tilman Westphalen insists that the marks inserted in the manuscript are not an': see Beowulf 3150-3155: Textkritik und Editionsgeschichte
  • Julius Zupitza saw an' here, standing for Lat. ānus 'old woman', a gloss on what he believed to be the word geō-mēowle: see his 'Beowulf ' Reproduced in Facsimile from the Unique Manuscript British Museum MS. Cotton Vitellius A. xv
  • 1966
Metrically aberrant verses are regularly omitted from consideration in the compilation of figures in my History
Zur Betonungs-und Verslehre des Altenglischen
  • Festschrift zum siebzigsten Geburtstage Oskar Schade