On Sharpness and Scholarship in the Debate on “Shamanism”1

@article{LewisWilliams2004OnSA,
  title={On Sharpness and Scholarship in the Debate on “Shamanism”1},
  author={J.David LewisWilliams},
  journal={Current Anthropology},
  year={2004},
  volume={45},
  pages={404 - 406}
}
Criticism has been directed at the proposition that certain archaeologically known ritual practices and arts may be termed “shamanistic.” Cecelia Klein and coauthors (CA 43:383–419) have attacked the Mayan research of, amongst others, Peter Furst, Kent Reilly, Linda Schele, Joy Parker, and David Freidel. Declaring the use of the words “shaman” and “shamanistic” “symptomatic of some very serious problems in Mesoamerican art studies,” they impute to other researchers a “deliberate [my emphasis… 
1 Citations
Coins, Beads, and Necklaces: On Light, Brilliance, and Sacredness in the Northern Andes
Abstract This paper explores the profoundly material dimensions of Andean Catholicism, an aspect that has been under-examined by anthropological inquiries of the Catholic expansion in the “New

References

SHOWING 1-3 OF 3 REFERENCES
A Forest of Kings: The Untold Story of the Ancient Maya
The mystique of the pre-Columbian Maya has prompted much speculation about the nature of this sophisticated people. With the breaking of their elaborate hieroglyphic code, Schele and Freidel, Mayan
A cosmos in stone: Interpreting religion and society through rock art
  • 2002
Shamanisms today
  • Annual Review of Anthropology
  • 1992