On Language Savants and the Structure of the Mind Review of: The Mind of a Savant: Language Learning and Modularity by Neil Smith and Ianthi-Maria Tsimpli, 1995

  title={On Language Savants and the Structure of the Mind Review of: The Mind of a Savant: Language Learning and Modularity by Neil Smith and Ianthi-Maria Tsimpli, 1995},
  author={Elizabeth A. Bates},
  journal={International Journal of Bilingualism},
  pages={163 - 179}
  • E. Bates
  • Published 1997
  • Psychology
  • International Journal of Bilingualism
Ackiioivlerlgriieiits * hly thanks to Annette Karmiloff-Smith for her criticisms and suggestions on an earlier draft of this revien: She is, ofcourse, in no \vay responsible for any errors of fact or interpretation that may remain. During preparation of this review, I received partial support from NIHMIDCD Program Project P50 DC01289-0351, NIHMINDS Program Project P50 NS22343, and NIHMIDCD 2-R01-DC00216. 
Reply to Bates
We appreciate Elizabeth Bates’ (‘B’ hereinafter) lengthy and critical review of our book, and we are grateful for this opportunity to reply. Our response will be in part concessionary and in partExpand
Language against the odds, or rather not: The weak central coherence hypothesis and language
EV is a child with a talent for learning language combined with Asperger syndrome. EV’s talent is evident in the unusual circumstances of her acquisition of both her first (Bulgarian) and secondExpand
Biological Foundations of Linguistic Cognition
This chapter attempts to show that the biological foundations of language and language-cognition relations are rife with conundrums that are far deeper than is generally assumed among mostExpand
Language death and diversity: philosophical and linguistic implications
Much of this reflects (or even summarizes) Davidson’s philosophical program, but much of it also reflects a (perhaps, defining) tendency in analytic philosophy as a whole: language, especiallyExpand
Le langage est-il un instinct? Une critique du nativisme de Chomsky à Pinker
In this paper, I review the main arguments which purportedly establish that the language faculty is innate. In its modern guise, this linguistic nativism goes back to Chomsky, whose views on theExpand
The role of domain-general cognitive control in language comprehension
It is argued that the authors should stop asking whether domain-general cognitive control mechanisms play a role in language comprehension, and instead focus on characterizing the division of labor between the cognitive control brain regions and the more functionally specialized language regions. Expand
Prodigies and Savants
This chapter describes cited contemporary models of intelligence for each of the three levels: psychometric, physiological, and social. The contemporary models that bridge more than one level areExpand
Prodigious Polyglot Savants: The Enigmatic Adjoining of Language Acquisition and Emaciated Potentials
Affluent research has profoundly dealt with the aggregate umbrella term of developmental disorders. It has equally identified a host of disparate types that in one way or another daunt afflictedExpand
Bilingualism in autism: Language learning profiles and social experiences
This first study describing the language history and social experiences of a substantial sample of bilingual and multilingual autistic adults provides valuable insight into how autistic people can learn and use a new language, and how their bilingualism experiences shape their social life. Expand
I. The Neurocognitive Profile of Williams Syndrome: A Complex Pattern of Strengths and Weaknesses
The rare, genetically based disorder, Williams syndrome (WMS), produces a constellation of distinctive cognitive, neuroanatomical, and electrophysiological features which we explore through theExpand


The mind of a savant: Language learning and modularity.
The author presents a model of the mind and meta--representation, which describes how language and intelligence are influenced by the role of language and meta-representation in a person's life. Expand
Laura : a case for the modularity of language
The case of Laura (also known as Marta), a young retarded woman with a testable IQ of 40, provides the opportunity to address key issues concerning the relationships between language and other mentalExpand
The Handbook of Child Language
List of Contributors. Acknowledgments. Part I: Theory, Method, and Context. Introduction. Theoretical Approaches. 1. Parameters in Acquisition: Jurgen M. Meisel (University of Hamburg). 2.Expand
Language learning: Cues or rules?
Child language researchers have often taken gender and case paradigms to be interesting test cases for theories of language learning. In this paper we develop a computational model of the acquisitionExpand
Précis of Beyond modularity: A developmental perspective on cognitive science
Beyond modularity attempts a synthesis of Fodor's anticonstructivist nativism and Piaget's antinativist constructivism. Contra Fodor, I argue that: (1) the study of cognitive development is essentialExpand
Discourse ability and brain damage : theoretical and empirical perspectives
Nonspecialists are often surprised by the issues studied and the perspectives assumed by basic scientific researchers. Nowhere has the surprise traditionally been greater than in the field ofExpand
Connectionism: theory and practice
A central theme of this book reviews the adequacy of recent attempts to implement higher cognitive processes in connectionist networks. Expand
An Extraordinary Gift. (Book Reviews: The Mind of a Mnemonist. A Little Book about a Vast Memory)
Foreword to the 1987 Edition Foreword to the First Edition Preface 1. Introduction 2. The Beginning of the Research 3. His Memory The Initial Facts Synesthesia Words and Images DifficultiesExpand
Linguistic Abilities in Italian Children With Williams Syndrome
Evaluated subjects with Williams syndrome look similar to normal controls in lexical comprehension, but they appear to perform more poorly in grammatical comprehension, and look deviant from normals in some morphosyntactic aspects of their production. Expand
The Time Course of Grammaticality Judgement
Correlations among the three experiments were extremely high and all significant, suggesting that some error types elicit a broad and variable “decision region" instead of a more punctate ”decision point" in grammaticality judgement. Expand