On Ian Hacking’s Notion of Style of Reasoning

@article{Sciortino2017OnIH,
  title={On Ian Hacking’s Notion of Style of Reasoning},
  author={Luca Sciortino},
  journal={Erkenntnis},
  year={2017},
  volume={82},
  pages={243-264}
}
The analytical notion of ‘scientific style of reasoning’, introduced by Ian Hacking in the middle of the 1980s, has become widespread in the literature of the history and philosophy of science. However, scholars have rarely made explicit the philosophical assumptions and the research objectives underlying the notion of style: what are its philosophical roots? How does the notion of style fit into the area of research of historical epistemology? What does a comparison between the Hacking’s… 

Styles of Reasoning, Human Forms of Life, and Relativism

ABSTRACT The question as to whether Ian Hacking’s project of scientific styles of thinking entails epistemic relativism has received considerable attention. However, scholars have never discussed it

The emergence of objectivity: Fleck, Foucault, Kuhn and Hacking.

  • Luca Sciortino
  • Philosophy
    Studies in history and philosophy of science
  • 2021

Abduction and styles of scientific thinking

It is argued that abduction, as a general mode of reasoning, can have a variety of specific expressions enabled and constrained by the styles of scientific thinking, and that scientific discovery is a dynamical goal-directed activity within the scientific community that benefits from distinct styles of thinking and doing research.

Imagination in Scientific Practice

  • S. French
  • Philosophy
    European Journal for Philosophy of Science
  • 2020
What is the role of the imagination in scientific practice? Here I focus on the nature and role of invitations to imagine in certain scientific texts as represented by the example of Einstein’s

Styles of reasoning for mathematics education

Although reasoning is a central concept in mathematics education research, the discipline is still in need of a coherent theoretical framework of mathematical reasoning. With respect to

Styles of reasoning in mathematics education in post-factual times

This essay introduces the theory of styles of reasoning as an answer to the question how truth or factuality can be conceived within relativist epistemologies, that do not locate truth in a reality

The logic of the surface: on the epistemology of algorithms in times of big data

A third perspective on algorithms and big data is introduced, which holds that algorithms follow their own ‘style of reasoning’ and thus create new realities, while at the same time they ‘reduce reality’, as they lack access to the world of human sense making.

Considerations about the Origins of French Style in History of Sciences

This paper aims to reconstruct some steps of the emergence and consolidation of the so-called French style in the history of sciences, from the perspective of Georges Canguilhem, one of its main

The Exigencies of War and the Stink of a Theoretical Problem: Understanding the Genesis of Feynman’s Quantum Electrodynamics as Mechanistic Modelling at Different Levels

1. A Question of Style In 1949, Richard Feynman (1918–1988) published the essentials of his solution to the recalcitrant problems that plagued quantum theories of electrodynamics of his days (Feynman

Structure-preserving representations, constitution, and the relative a priori

It is argued that a comprehensive account of the role of representations in science should reconsider some neglected theses of the classical philosophy of science, in which the representational accounts of Helmholtz and Hertz still deserve attention for contemporary debates.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 58 REFERENCES

Hacking’s historical epistemology: a critique of styles of reasoning

‘Language, Truth and Reason’ 30 years later

Historical Epistemology: On the Diversity and Change of Epistemic Values in Science.

  • M. Carrier
  • Philosophy
    Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
  • 2012
This work draws attention to the double role of epistemic values, which are important in the process of confirmation in that they entail that certain forms of agreement with the facts are superior and preferable to other such forms.

Genesis and development of a scientific fact

Originally published in German in 1935, this monograph anticipated solutions to problems of scientific progress, the truth of scientific fact and the role of error in science now associated with the

The emergence of sexuality: historical epistemology and the formation of concepts

As the author himself recognizes, much work still needs to be done to further the authors' understanding of sexual politics and the treatment of sexual dissent in the Soviet Union, as well as their implications for understanding Soviet experience in general.

Kant and Newtonian Science: The Pre-Critical Period

NT EWTONIAN IDEAS were vigorously developed and disseminated in Prussia during the mid-eighteenth century. The cental figures in that movement were Maupertuis and Euler, who had been invited to join

The Taming of Chance.

Acknowledgements 1. The argument 2. The doctrine of necessity 3. Public amateurs, secret bureaucrats 4. Bureaux 5. The sweet despotism of reason 6. The quantum of sickness 7. The granary of science

Historical Ontology

This chapter lays out the historical methodology of the book. The primary inquiry of this book is ontological, but not foundational. It is historical. In other words, it does not aim to identify the
...