On Good Scholarship, Goal Setting, and Scholars Gone Wild

@article{Ordez2009OnGS,
  title={On Good Scholarship, Goal Setting, and Scholars Gone Wild},
  author={Lisa D. Ord{\'o}{\~n}ez and Maurice E. Schweitzer and Adam D. Galinsky and Max H. Bazerman},
  journal={Harvard Business School Working Papers},
  year={2009}
}
Executive Overview In this article, we define good scholarship, highlight our points of disagreement with Locke and Latham (2009), and call for further academic research to examine the full range of goal setting's effects. We reiterate our original claim that goal setting, like a potent medication, can produce both beneficial effects and systematic, negative outcomes (Ordonez, Schweitzer, Galinsky,& Bazerman, 2009), and as a result, it should be carefully prescribed and closely monitored. 
Work Motivation: Directing, Energizing, and Maintaining Effort (and Research)
This chapter provides an overview of contemporary research on work motivation. We start by identifying the central premises, controversies, and unanswered questions related to five core theoretical
Alterity: The passion, politics, and ethics of self and scholarship
I propose that the choices we make about the type of work we do as scholars are not just intellectual ones, they are intricately interwoven with who we are, made in poetic moments, in relation to
How to avoid the problems of target‐setting
Purpose – Advocates and critics of target‐setting in the workplace seem unable to reach beyond their own well‐entrenched battle lines. While the advocates of goal‐directed behaviour point to what
Motivated to disengage: The ethical consequences of goal commitment and moral disengagement in goal setting
A growing literature has suggested that high performance goals can have unintended consequences within organizations as employees engage in unethical behavior to achieve outcomes associated with goal
Investigating the Effects of Moral Disengagement and Participation on Unethical Work Behavior
With massive corruption uncovered in numerous recent corporate scandals, investigating psychological processes underlying unethical behavior among employees has become a critical area of research for
Susceptibility to the ‘Dark Side’ of Goal-Setting: Does Moral Justification Influence the Effect of Goals on Unethical Behavior?
Setting goals in the workplace can motivate improved performance but it might also compromise ethical behavior. In this paper, we propose that individual differences in the dispositional tendency to
Paradoxes in Approaches to Goal-Setting and Change: The Enigmatic Power of Questions and Small Steps
Writing on goal-setting and change commonly emphasizes setting “difficult” or “challenging” goals that enhance the motivation to change or progress. However, difficult or challenging goals also have
Perverse Effects of Other-Referenced Performance Goals in an Information Exchange Context
We argue and demonstrate that an emphasis on outperforming others may lead to perverse effects. Four studies show that assigning other-referenced performance goals, relative to self-referenced
Motivation through incentives: A cross-disciplinary review of the evidence
Over the last decades, the accounting and control literature has featured much studying of and debate about the role and designing of incentives. Over the last year or so, the debate over incentives
The Effects of Goals and Pay Structure on Managerial Reporting Dishonesty
Organizations often address agency concerns through reward systems such as goal setting and monetary incentives, and while these are important mechanisms for increasing and aligning employee effort,
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES
Goals as Reference Points
TLDR
It is argued that goals serve as reference points and alter outcomes in a manner consistent with the value function of Prospect Theory and is used to explain previous empirical results in the goal literature on affect, effort, persistence, and performance.
Task Revision: A Neglected Form of Work Performance
This study addressed the problem of task revision, a virtually unresearched issue in the work performance literature. We defined task revision as action taken to correct a faulty procedure, an
UNDERSTANDING THE ETHICAL COST OF ORGANIZATIONAL GOAL-SETTING: A REVIEW AND THEORY DEVELOPMENT.
Goal-setting has become a popular and effective motivational tool, utilized by practitioners and substantiated with decades of empirical research. However, the potential for goal-setting to enhance...
Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk — Source link
This paper presents a critique of expected utility theory as a descriptive model of decision making under risk, and develops an alternative model, called prospect theory. Choices among risky
Has Goal Setting Gone Wild, or Have Its Attackers Abandoned Good Scholarship?
Executive Overview We believe that Ordonez, Schweitzer, Galinsky, and Bazerman (2009), in their critique of goal setting, have breached the principles of good scholarship. Rather than conducting or
Goals gone wild: How goals systematically harm individuals and organizations
  • Academy of Management Perspectives,
  • 2009
Goals Gone Wild: The Systematic Side Effects of Overprescribing Goal Setting
Executive Overview Goal setting is one of the most replicated and influential paradigms in the management literature. Hundreds of studies conducted in numerous countries and contexts have
The hazards of goal pursuit.
Goal-Induced Risk Taking in Negotiation and Decision Making
Three experiments test whether specific, challenging goals increase risk taking. We propose that goals serve as reference points, creating a region of perceived losses for outcomes below a goal
...
...