Older Adults’ Responses to Patronizing Advice

@article{Hummert2001OlderAR,
  title={Older Adults’ Responses to Patronizing Advice},
  author={Mary Lee Hummert and Debra C. Mazloff},
  journal={Journal of Language and Social Psychology},
  year={2001},
  volume={20},
  pages={168 - 196}
}
Following Okamoto and Robinson, two studies extended the study of politeness in context to a consideration of how older individuals respond to advice delivered in a patronizing (impolite) or affirming (polite) manner. Study 1 involved older persons in focus groups that considered contexts for, perceptions of, and responses to patronizing advice. Study 2 collected oral responses from other older individuals in a 2 (advice style: patronizing/affirming) 2 (context: community/hospital) design… 

Tables from this paper

Politeness Strategies in Imagined Conversation Openers About Eldercare

In the United States, many adult children and their aging parents reach the point when it is necessary to address future care needs of the parent. Given that the prevailing culture values

Constructive or cruel? Positive or patronizing? Reactions to expressions of positive and negative stereotypes of the mentally ill.

TLDR
Participants were more sensitive, agreed less, and evaluated the speaker less favourably when comments came from the out-group rather than the in-group source, however contrary to previous research participants also responded less favourable to positive comments from theout-groups source.

Politeness at work: Issues and challenges

Abstract In this article we will attempt to address some of the issues that arise in researching politeness in the workplace, especially, though not exclusively, in the context of multicultural and

“I Was Impolite to Her Because That's How She Was to Me”: Perceptions of Motive and Young Adults' Communicative Responses to Underaccommodation

Past research has shown that underaccommodation, defined as communication that at least one participant in an interaction perceives as insufficiently adjusted for his or her needs, has negative

Technology and the Marginalization of Older Adults: How Politeness Theory and Stereotype Embodiment Interact in Older Adults' Technology Use

Marginalization of older adults is a long-time and pervasive fact of society. Technology use can make older adults feel less marginalized by connecting them socially, such as with communication

Older Adults’ Evaluations of Middle-Aged Children’s Attempts to Initiate Discussion of Care Needs

We explored how older adults evaluated the strategies used by an adult child to initiate discussion of future care needs, and subsequently, whether these judgments affected older adults’ willingness

Upward Advice Transmission to Leaders in Organizations: Review and Conceptual Analysis

Advice is often given by individuals who have greater experience, expertise, and wisdom, in order to help someone with less experience, expertise, or wisdom in decision making and problem solving. In

Imagining Recovery, Resilience, and Vulnerability at 75: Perceptions of Social Work Students

BSW and MSW students (N = 183) read one of three vignettes and were asked to respond to 21 items investigating their perceptions about depression, anxiety, and resilience of the vignette's character.

Harmonies and Tensions in Chinese Intergenerational Communication: Younger and Older Adults' Accounts

This study examined interview accounts of intergenerational communication from twenty younger adults (M age = 24.05; Age range: 19 to 33) and thirteen older adults (M age = 67.10; Age range: 62 to
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 42 REFERENCES

Reactions to Older People being Patronized

This article examines young people's evaluations of young and elderly targets in a patronizing encounter. Intergenerational patronizing vignettes were presented to respondents who evaluated the

Patronizing the Young: Forms and Evaluations

TLDR
Three distinct clusters representing young adults' own conceptions of patronizing speech emerged (“non-listening,” “disapproving,’ and “parental”), and an evaluative hierarchy differentiated between the three patronizing forms, and in ways that differed depending on the nature of the judgmental task.

Patronizing young and elderly adults: Response strategies in a community setting

Abstract Within the context of an elaborated model of the communication predicament of aging, the effects of particular response strategies to patronizing, intergenerational talk were investigated

Communication With Older Adults The Influence of Age Stereotypes, Context, and Communicator Age

Forty young, 40 middle-aged, and 40 older adults rated their beliefs about the vocal style that they would use in addressing two older targets-one fitting a negative (Despondent) and one a positive

Evaluations of patronizing speech and three response styles in a non‐service‐providing context

Abstract Earlier studies have documented observers’ negative evaluations of patronizing speech directed towards elderly individuals. In addition, such studies have demonstrated that evaluations of

Determinants of Gratitude Expressions in England

A field experiment (Study 1, N = 228) and a questionnaire study (Study 2, N = 120) were conducted to investigate determinants of gratitude expressions of British speakers. Based on Brown and

Patronizing speech to the elderly as a function of stereotyping

This study tested the predictions of a model of the role of the stereotypes of the elderly in interaction. Young adult subjects participated in a role playing task with two elderly targets, one

Patterns of Communication in Old Age: The Dependence-Support and Independence-Ignore Script

Most research to date on communication and interaction patterns in aging is based on linguistic and discourse analyses. This article is aimed at the behavioral analysis of interaction patterns. A

Academic achievement and self-concepts of Latvian adolescents in a changed social context

Three questions were posed. Would low achieving 13 to 14 year olds in Latvia have followed the predictions derivable from Social Identity Theory and formed a counter-culture or would they display

Evaluations by staff, residents, and community seniors of patronizing speech in the nursing home: impact of passive, assertive, or humorous responses.

TLDR
Ratings of the humorous response in Study 2 suggested that humor could be a good compromise response style for allowing the receiver of patronizing speech to express opposition to a request, yet still maintain an appearance of competence and politeness.