Of Cabbages and Kings: Concepts and Inferences Curiously Attributed to Lev Vygotsky (Commentary on McVee, Dunsmore, and Gavelek, 2005)

@article{Gredler2007OfCA,
  title={Of Cabbages and Kings: Concepts and Inferences Curiously Attributed to Lev Vygotsky (Commentary on McVee, Dunsmore, and Gavelek, 2005)},
  author={Margaret E. Gredler},
  journal={Review of Educational Research},
  year={2007},
  volume={77},
  pages={233 - 238}
}
  • M. E. Gredler
  • Published 1 June 2007
  • Education
  • Review of Educational Research
A major problem in understanding a new theory is that rapid gains in popularity are accompanied by misconceptions and distortions (Valsiner, 1988). For example, scholars have noted that some writings in Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory were so distorted that he was criticized for positions he had never taken (Bickhard, 1997; Chapman, 1988; Lorenqo & Machado, 1996). Unfortunately, these and other enlightening critiques came more than 30 years after Piaget had captivated educational… 
View on SAGE
14 Citations
Background Citations
5

14 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Chasing Vygotsky’s Dogs: Retrieving Lev Vygotsky’s Philosophy for a Workers’ Paradise
In an article published in 1930, Lev Vygotsky refers explicitly to the seventeenth century Dutch philosopher Benedictus de Spinoza. From a close reading of Vygotsky’s remarkable piece, ‘The socialist…
Revisionist Revolution in Vygotskian Science: Toward Cultural-Historical Gestalt Psychology
Lev Vygotsky is presumably the best-known and the most-cited Russian psychologist today. At least this seems to be true of contemporary Russia and North America (Aleksandrova-Howell, Abramson, and…
Beyond bounds? The terrorist teachers of Lev Vygotsky
Purpose – The purpose of the paper is to explore socio-cultural-historical influences on the ideas of Soviet educational psychologist Lev Vygotsky, since these have become transferable to the point…
Traditions and texts: how two young women learned to interpret the Qur’an and hadiths in Kazakhstan
After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, translations of the Qur’an and books of hadiths became widely available in Kazakhstan for the first time in 70 years. However, most Kazakhs do not read the…
On the Cultural Schema and Iranian EFL Learners' Reading Performance: A Case of Local and Global Items.
Reading skill has taken on an important role in most EFL teaching situations. While linguistic knowledge is only one aspect of this skill, background knowledge including culture can also play an…
Children's working theories: invoking disequilibrium
One of the outcomes of the New Zealand early childhood curriculum, Te Whāriki, is ‘working theories'. Prior research on this concept has primarily utilised sociocultural theoretical underpinnings and…
Instructional Coaching
Instructional coach initiatives aimed at teachers’ professional development are expanding in reforming school districts across the United States. This study addresses the lack of research regarding…
Instructional Coaching : Building Theory About the Role and Organizational Support for Professional Learning
Instructional coach initiatives aimed at teachers’ professional development are expanding in reforming school districts across the United States. This study addresses the lack of research regarding…
Participatory learning theories: a framework for early childhood pedagogy
This paper continues scholarly conversations about appropriate theories of development to underpin early childhood pedagogy. It focuses on sociocultural theoretical perspectives and proposes that…
WED Bibliography
This is the bibliography for Wurts, Henry. “An illustration of a modified-Machlup (mM) assessment for resolving when experts disagree (WED) issues as applied to three archetypal examples for model…
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 39 REFERENCES
In defense of Piaget's theory: A reply to 10 common criticisms.
The developmental theory of Jean Piaget has been criticized on the grounds that it is conceptually limited, empirically false, or philosophically and epistemologically untenable. This study attempts…
Schema Theory Revisited
During the 1970s, schema theory gained prominence as reading researchers took up early work by cognitive scientists to explore the role of schemas in reading. In the 1980s and ’90s, the field shifted…
Thought and language.
From aphasics' self records, common experience, changes in signification of sentences according to a verbal or non-verbal context, animals and non speaking children performances, it seems possible to…
Several Bridges Too Far: A Commentary on Richard S. Prawat’s “Dewey Meets the ‘Mozart of Psychology’ in Moscow: The Untold Story,” in American Educational Research Journal, Fall 2000
L'article reproduit une critique d'une recherche proposee dans l'American Education Research Journal en 2000 portant sur la rencontre probable de Dewey et de Vygotsky au cours de laquelle les deux…
Constructive Evolution: Origins and Development of Piaget's Thought
Introduction: Piaget from within 1. The seeker and the search 2. The investigation of children's thinking 3. From the logic of thought to the logic of action 4. Concrete operation and…
Problems of the theory and history of psychology : including the chapter on the crisis in psychology
Some Major Themes in Vygotsky's Theoretical Work: An Introduction R. van der Veer. On Vygotsky's Creative Development A.N. Leont'ev. Problems of the Theory and Methods of Psychology: The Methods of…
The Development of Higher Psychological Functions
Soviet psychologists' views of the relationship between psychology and Pavlovian psychophysiology (or the study of higher nervous activity, as it is referred to in the Soviet literature) has long…
Personal Being: A Theory for Individual Psychology
The undoubted fact of human individuality has remained outside the field of interest of scientific psychology. Neither the central organization of consciousness nor individual powers of action have…
A Review and Analysis of Constructivism for School-Based Practice
Abstract Constructivism, a multifaceted philosophical position on the nature of knowledge and educational practice, has recently emerged both in the literature on learning and in school reform…
On Psychological Systems
TLDR
This attempt (not formally, but according to its essence) can be regarded as an attempt to point out the new problems that emerge here.
...
...