Numbers and Arithmetic: Neither Hardwired Nor Out There

@article{Nez2009NumbersAA,
  title={Numbers and Arithmetic: Neither Hardwired Nor Out There},
  author={Rafael E. N{\'u}{\~n}ez},
  journal={Biological Theory},
  year={2009},
  volume={4},
  pages={68-83}
}
  • R. Núñez
  • Published 1 March 2009
  • Philosophy
  • Biological Theory
What is the nature of number systems and arithmetic that we use in science for quantification, analysis, and modeling? I argue that number concepts and arithmetic are neither hardwired in the brain, nor do they exist out there in the universe. Innate subitizing and early cognitive preconditions for number— which we share with many other species—cannot provide the foundations for the precision, richness, and range of number concepts and simple arithmetic, let alone that of more complex… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

How Much Mathematics Is “Hardwired,” If Any at All

The investigation of mathematical cognition in developmental psychology has been primarily confined to the study of numerical cognition— basic facts involving quantity, such as the acquisition of

Is There Really an Evolved Capacity for Number?

Neurophilosophy of Number

ABSTRACT Neurosciences and cognitive sciences provide us with myriad empirical findings that shed light on hypothesised primitive numerical processes in the brain and in the mind. Yet, the hypotheses

The cultural origins of symbolic number.

This literature highlights the importance of economic and social factors in constructing fundamentally new cognitive systems to achieve culturally specific goals, and examines six natural predictions of strong numerical nativism from a multidisciplinary perspective.

Neurophilosophy of Number

ABSTRACTNeurosciences and cognitive sciences provide us with myriad empirical findings that shed light on hypothesised primitive numerical processes in the brain and in the mind. Yet, the hypotheses

Number Concepts without Number Lines in an Indigenous Group of Papua New Guinea

Results suggest that cardinal number concepts can exist independently from number line representations, and suggest that the number line mapping, although ubiquitous in the modern world, is not universally spontaneous, but rather seems to be learned through — and continually reinforced by — specific cultural practices.

Radicalizing numerical cognition

In recent decades, non-representational approaches to mental phenomena and cognition have been gaining traction in cognitive science and philosophy of mind. In these alternative approach, mental

Number Concepts Are Constructed through Material Engagement: A Reply to Sutliff, Read, and Everett

I respond to three responses to my 2015 Current Anthropology article, “Numerosity Structures the Expression of Quantity in Lexical Numbers and Grammatical Number.” This study examined the categorical

The Motion Behind the Symbols: A Vital Role for Dynamism in the Conceptualization of Limits and Continuity in Expert Mathematics

This article presents two studies of the role of dynamic conceptual systems in expert proof, showing that essential concepts in calculus that have been defined entirely in abstract, static terms are nevertheless conceptualized dynamically, in both contemporary and historical practice.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 88 REFERENCES

What Counts: How Every Brain is Hardwired for Math

Much has been written about our innate language sense and how it has shaped our evolution and our nature, but until now little has been known about what Brian Butterworth calls our "numerosity, " an

Bootstrapping & the origin of concepts

beings create scienti1⁄2c theories, mathematics, literature, moral systems, and complex technology. And only humans have the capacity to acquire such culturally constructed knowledge in the normal

Do Real Numbers Really Move? Language, Thought, and Gesture: The Embodied Cognitive Foundations of Mathematics

This chapter addresses the question of the nature of mathematics itself, that is, mathematics not as an application to some area of investigation, but as a human conceptual system with a precise inferential organization that can be investigated in detail in cognitive science.

The Metaphorical Structure of Mathematics: Sketching Out Cognitive Foundations For a Mind-Based Mathematics

(M121-liter The Metaphorical Structure of Mathematics: Sketching Out Cognitive Foundations for a Mind-Based Mathematics George Lakoff Rafael E. Nunez University ofCalIIf0mia, Berke’/fly WARNING! This

Addition and subtraction by human infants

5-month-old infants can calculate the results of simple arithmetical operations on small numbers of items, which indicates that infants possess true numerical concepts, and suggests that humans are innately endowed with arathmetical abilities.

The Cognitive Foundations of Mathematics: The Role of Conceptual Metaphor - eScholarship

Handbook of Mathematical Cognition New York : Psychology Press J. Campbell (Ed.). The Cognitive Foundations of Mathematics: The Role of Conceptual Metaphor Rafael Nunez and George Lakoff In The Tree

Log or Linear? Distinct Intuitions of the Number Scale in Western and Amazonian Indigene Cultures

The Mundurucu, an Amazonian indigene group with a reduced numerical lexicon and little or no formal education, mapped symbolic and nonsymbolic numbers onto a logarithmic scale, whereas Western adults used linear mapping with small or symbolic numbers and logarithsmic mapping when numbers were presented nonsymbolically under conditions that discouraged counting.

What Did Weierstrass Really Define? The Cognitive Structure of Natural and ∊-δ Continuity

The cognitive science of mathematics is the study of mathematical ideas from the perspective of research on our largely unconscious everyday conceptual systems as they are embodied in the human

Philosophy in the flesh

"We are neural beings," states Berkeley cognitive scientist George Lakoff. "Our brains take their input from the rest of our bodies. What our bodies are like and how they function in the world thus
...