Nuisance Law: Corrective Justice and Its Utilitarian Constraints

  title={Nuisance Law: Corrective Justice and Its Utilitarian Constraints},
  author={Richard A. Epstein},
  journal={The Journal of Legal Studies},
  pages={49 - 102}
  • R. Epstein
  • Published 1 January 1979
  • Economics
  • The Journal of Legal Studies
Finally, the tax without compensation cannot protect both parties' entitlements, but otherwise may protect or may violate the factory's and the laundry's entitlements. Obviously, relative to the tax with marginal compensation, entitlement protection is more difficult to accomplish. If the entitlement point is in the first or second region, whether the parties' entitlements are protected still depends on the level of the marginal tax and the parties' behavior. If the entitlement point is in the… 
Hayek’s Constitution of Liberty—a guarded retrospective
Hayek’s Constitution of Liberty is justly regarded as making a comprehensive case for the protection of individual liberty against excessive government intrusion. But even as its ends are correct,
An Information Saving and Efficient Nuisance Rule
The existing literature postulates that in nuisance suits courts should balance, for a property right under conflict, several values of the litigating parties. This practice, however, is
Epstein's Theory of Strict Tort Liability
Alan Brudner recently observed that a significant tendency within contemporary legal scholarship has been “the movement toward comprehending private law in terms of non-legal ‘perspectives’ that
Aristotle's Forms of Justice
. In Aristotle's account, corrective and distributive justice are not (as they are today) particular substantive ideals, but are rather the formal patterns that inhere in interactions and in the
An Essay on Private Remedies
One of the assumptions of our legal system is that when a violation of law has occurred, we (society) should provide a remedy for individuals who were harmed. More specifically, we should provide
Classical Liberal Property and the Question of Institutional Choice
Richard Epstein’s property scholarship tracks his classical liberal theory of government. The classical liberal would permit state intervention to overcome collective-action problems but not to
Legislation, the Courts and the Demand for Compensation
The appropriateness of including the subject of law and economics and indeed the participation of myself, an academic lawyer, in a book devoted to the theme of ‘Economy and Democracy’ requires,
Constitutional Principles of Regulatory Takings: A Utilitarian Perspective
The question of when a regulation may result in a government taking of private property that must be compensated has long been a contentious issue. Although economic models have attempted to answer
Ethical Issues in the Law of Tort
This paper surveys some leading issues in the extant law of tort with a view to exposing some of its assumed values. Three different ethical theories provide the basis for discussion, namely the
The Proportional Internalization Principle in Private Law
According to common conception, laws should make actors internalize all the costs and benefits of their actions to make them behave efficiently. This article shows that even when only partial