# Niels Bohr on the wave function and the classical/quantum divide

@article{Zinkernagel2016NielsBO, title={Niels Bohr on the wave function and the classical/quantum divide}, author={Henrik Zinkernagel}, journal={arXiv: History and Philosophy of Physics}, year={2016} }

It is well known that Niels Bohr insisted on the necessity of classical concepts in the account of quantum phenomena. But there is little consensus concerning his reasons, and what he exactly meant by this. In this paper, I re-examine Bohr's interpretation of quantum mechanics, and argue that the necessity of the classical can be seen as part of his response to the measurement problem. More generally, I attempt to clarify Bohr's view on the classical/quantum divide, arguing that the relation… Expand

#### Figures from this paper

#### 21 Citations

Bohr’s Relational Holism and the Classical-Quantum Interaction

- Physics
- 2016

In this paper I present and critically discuss the main strategies that Bohr used and could have used to fend off the charge that his interpretation does not provide a clear-cut distinction between… Expand

Niels Bohr and the Formalism of Quantum Mechanics

- Mathematics
- 2016

It has often been remarked that Bohr's writings on the interpretation of quantum mechanics make scant reference to the mathematical formalism of quantum theory; and it has not infrequently been… Expand

Are we living in a quantum world? Bohr and quantum fundamentalism

- Physics
- 2015

The spectacular successes of quantum physics have made it a commonplace to assert that we live in a quantum world. This idea seems to imply a kind of “quantum fundamentalism” according to which… Expand

Barad, Bohr, and quantum mechanics

- Philosophy
- 2021

The last decade has seen an increasing number of references to quantum mechanics in the humanities and social sciences. This development has in particular been driven by Karen Barad’s agential… Expand

Are we living in a quantum world ?

- 2016

The spectacular successes of quantum physics have made it a commonplace to assert that we live in a quantum world. This idea seems to imply a kind of “quantum fundamentalism” according to which… Expand

Bohr meets Rovelli: a dispositionalist account of the quantum limits of knowledge

- Mathematics, Physics
- 2020

I begin by examining the question of the quantum limits of knowledge by briefly presenting the constraints of the theory that derive from its mathematical structure (in particular the no-go theorems… Expand

Did bohr succeed in defending the completeness of quantum mechanics?

- Philosophy
- 2020

This study posits that Bohr failed to defend the completeness of the quantum mechanical description of physical reality against Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen’s (EPR) paper. Although there are many papers… Expand

The Primacy of the Classical? Saul Kripke Meets Niels Bohr

- Philosophy
- International Studies in the Philosophy of Science
- 2019

ABSTRACT Kripke's theory of partial truth offers a natural solution of the Liar paradox and an appealing explanation of why the Liar sentence seems to lack definite content. It seems vulnerable,… Expand

Bohrification: From classical concepts to commutative algebras

- Mathematics, Physics
- 2016

The Bohrification program is an attempt to interpret Bohr's mature doctrine of classical concepts as well as his earlier correspondence principle in the operator-algebraic formulation of quantum… Expand

Agents in Healey’s Pragmatist Quantum Theory: A Comparison with Pitowsky’s Approach to Quantum Mechanics

- Philosophy
- 2020

In a series of related papers and in a book (Healey R. The quantum revolution in philosophy. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2017b), Richard Healey has proposed and articulated a new pragmatist… Expand

#### References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 64 REFERENCES

Are we living in a quantum world? Bohr and quantum fundamentalism

- Physics
- 2015

The spectacular successes of quantum physics have made it a commonplace to assert that we live in a quantum world. This idea seems to imply a kind of “quantum fundamentalism” according to which… Expand

Niels Bohr as Philosopher of Experiment: Does Decoherence Theory Challenge Bohr's Doctrine of Classical Concepts?

- Physics
- 2015

Niels Bohr's doctrine of the primacy of "classical concepts" is arguably his most criticized and misunderstood view. We present a new, careful historical analysis that makes clear that Bohr's… Expand

The quantum-to-classical transition: Bohr's doctrine of classical concepts, emergent classicality, and decoherence

- Physics
- 2008

It is now widely accepted that environmental entanglement and the resulting decoherence processes play a crucial role in the quantum-to-classical transition and the emergence of "classicality" from… Expand

The EPR Experiment: A Prelude to Bohr's Reply to EPR

- Mathematics, Physics
- 2002

Bohr’s (1935) reply to Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen’s (EPR’s) (1935) argument for the incompleteness of quantum theory is notoriously difficult to unravel. It is so diffcult, in fact, that over 60… Expand

Idealization and Formalism in Bohr’s Approach to Quantum Theory

- Mathematics
- Philosophy of Science
- 2004

I reinterpret Bohr’s attitude towards quantum mechanical formalism and its empirical content, based on his understanding of the correspondence principle and its approximate applicability. I suggest… Expand

Niels Bohr’s Interpretation and the Copenhagen Interpretation—Are the Two Incompatible?

- Philosophy
- Philosophy of Science
- 2007

The Copenhagen interpretation, which informs the textbook presentation of quantum mechanics, depends fundamentally on the notion of ontological wave‐particle duality and a viewpoint called… Expand

Who Invented the “Copenhagen Interpretation”? A Study in Mythology

- Philosophy
- Philosophy of Science
- 2004

What is commonly known as the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, regarded as representing a unitary Copenhagen point of view, differs significantly from Bohr’s complementarity… Expand

Bohr’s Response to EPR

- Physics
- 1994

The EPR paper (Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen, 1935; hereafter “EPR”) appeared in the May 15, 1935 issue of Physical Review. The paper’s impact was due in large part to their demonstration of an… Expand

In defence of non-ontic accounts of quantum states

- Philosophy, Physics
- 2012

The paper discusses objections against non-hidden variable versions of the epistemic conception of quantum states — the view that quantum states do not describe the properties of quantum systems but… Expand

Niels Bohr’s Generalization of Classical Mechanics

- Mathematics
- 2005

We clarify Bohr’s interpretation of quantum mechanics by demonstrating the central role played by his thesis that quantum theory is a rational generalization of classical mechanics. This thesis is… Expand