Niépce–Bell or Turing: how to test odour reproduction

  title={Ni{\'e}pce–Bell or Turing: how to test odour reproduction},
  author={David Harel},
  journal={Journal of the Royal Society Interface},
  • D. Harel
  • Published 29 March 2016
  • Computer Science, Medicine
  • Journal of the Royal Society Interface
Decades before the existence of anything resembling an artificial intelligence system, Alan Turing raised the question of how to test whether machines can think, or, in modern terminology, whether a computer claimed to exhibit intelligence indeed does so. This paper raises the analogous issue for olfaction: how to test the validity of a system claimed to reproduce arbitrary odours artificially, in a way recognizable to humans. Although odour reproduction systems are still far from being viable… Expand
3 Citations
Olfactory Processing as a Function of Population and Pathway Anatomy
From odors in the environment to a behavior in response to those odors there are a lot of brain structures and neural populations involved in make critical decisions. Understanding how odorExpand
A conceptual design for smell based augmented reality: case study in maintenance diagnosis
The aim of this paper is to evaluate the feasibilities, identify challenges, and summarise initial results of overlaying information through smell augmentations, via a case study in maintenance. Expand
Dietary protein sources and their effects on faecal odour and the composition of volatile organic compounds in faeces of French Bulldogs.
The source of protein in the foods had little impact on the composition of VOCs, and a greater perception of the odour was determined by sensory analysis when foods containing animal protein were administered. Expand


A Turing-like test for biological modeling
  • D. Harel
  • Computer Science, Medicine
  • Nature Biotechnology
  • 2005
It is argued that a variant of Alan Turing's 'imitation game', but with a Popperian twist, is applicable to the computerized modeling of natural systems, particularly in systems biology. Expand
Computing Machinery and Intelligence.
The question, “Can machines think?” is considered, and the question is replaced by another, which is closely related to it and is expressed in relatively unambiguous words. Expand
Computing Machinery and Intelligence
  • A. Turing
  • Computer Science
  • The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence
  • 1990
If the meaning of the words “machine” and “think” are to be found by examining how they are commonly used it is difficult to escape the conclusion that the meaning and the answer to the question, “Can machines think?” is to be sought in a statistical survey such as a Gallup poll. Expand
Chemical and behavioural characterization of the rabbit mammary pheromone
The nature of an odour signal emitted by the female rabbit to which newborn pups respond by attraction and oral grasping is focused on, and a complete chemical and behavioural description of a pheromone of mammary origin in a mammalian species is provided. Expand
Quantification of odor quality.
This review scrutinizes how psychophysicists and others have measured quality and offers criteria for useful techniques, including nonsubjective techniques that have high sensitivity, can have counterparts in infrahuman research, are suitable to examine individual differences and yield non-negotiable answers with potential archival value. Expand
Predicting Odor Pleasantness with an Electronic Nose
These findings suggest that unlike in vision and audition, in olfaction there is a systematic predictable link between stimulus structure and stimulus pleasantness, and may provide a new method for odor screening and environmental monitoring, as well as a critical building block for digital transmission of smell. Expand
Global Features of Neural Activity in the Olfactory System Form a Parallel Code That Predicts Olfactory Behavior and Perception
It is concluded that in parallel with spatiotemporal pattern coding, the Olfactory system can use simple global computations to read vital olfactory information from the neural population response. Expand
Information coding in the olfactory system: Evidence for a stereotyped and highly organized epitope map in the olfactory bulb
Evidence is obtained that information highly distributed in the nose is transformed in the olfactory bulb of the brain into a highly organized spatial map, which is in essence an epitope map, whose approximately 1000 distinct components are used in a multitude of different combinations to discriminate a vast array of different odors. Expand
Neural activity at the human olfactory epithelium reflects olfactory perception
It is found that the extent of an individual's perceptual span predicted their span in evoked response, which suggests that, similarly to receptor surfaces for vision and audition, organization of the olfactory receptor surface reflects key axes of perception. Expand
Towards an odor communication system
The heart of the system is the novel algorithmic scheme that makes the scheme feasible, and some of the components that constitute the algorithm are currently at work researching and developing. Expand