New theory about old evidence

  title={New theory about old evidence},
  author={Sylvia Wenmackers and Jan-Willem Romeijn},
We present a conservative extension of a Bayesian account of confirmation that can deal with the problem of old evidence and new theories. So-called open-minded Bayesianism challenges the assumption—implicit in standard Bayesianism—that the correct empirical hypothesis is among the ones currently under consideration. It requires the inclusion of a catch-all hypothesis, which is characterized by means of sets of probability assignments. Upon the introduction of a new theory, the former catch-all… CONTINUE READING
Related Discussions
This paper has been referenced on Twitter 27 times. VIEW TWEETS

From This Paper

Topics from this paper.


Publications referenced by this paper.
Showing 1-10 of 35 references

Bayesian epistemology

W. Press. Talbott
In Zalta N (Ed.), Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy • 2008
View 14 Excerpts
Highly Influenced

Bayesianism II: Applications and criticisms

K. MIT Press. Easwaran
Philosophy Compass, 6, 321–332. Garber, D. (1983). Old evidence and logical omniscience in Bayesian confirmation theory. In J. Earman • 2011
View 3 Excerpts
Highly Influenced

The reference class problem is your problem too

Synthese • 2006
View 1 Excerpt
Highly Influenced

Theory Change and Bayesian Statistical Inference

Jan-Willem Romeyn
View 2 Excerpts
Highly Influenced

The foundations of causal decision theory

J. Minneapolis. Joyce
in the philosophy of science (pp. 133–156) • 1999
View 5 Excerpts
Highly Influenced

1% Skepticism

E. University of Minnesota Press. Schwitzgebel
Unpublished manuscript, • 2014

A formal model of the Lockean thesis in terms of context-dependent infinitesimals is given by Wenmackers

Raton Chapman, Hall
Schwitzgebel • 2013

The humble Bayesian: model checking from a fully Bayesian perspective.

The British journal of mathematical and statistical psychology • 2013
View 9 Excerpts

Similar Papers

Loading similar papers…