New Qing History: Dispute, Dialog, and Influence

  title={New Qing History: Dispute, Dialog, and Influence},
  author={Guo Wu},
  journal={The Chinese Historical Review},
  pages={47 - 69}
  • Guo Wu
  • Published 2016
  • History
  • The Chinese Historical Review
This article studies the New Qing History approach that arose in the US in the 1980s and the ensuing responses to it, and how these responses can be understood in the context of American China studies, twentieth-century historiographical trends, and Chinese nationalism. It argues that the New Qing History approach should be considered in a contextualized and de-politicized way. After examining how Chinese-born scholars responded to the controversial issues (sinicization, the nature of the Qing… Expand
5 Citations
The reception of the “New Qing History” in China: confrontation between global and nationalist historical narratives
Purpose This paper aims to explore various tensions related to the diffusion and reception of the New Qing History (NQH) in China, and more specifically, it aims at underlying a recurrent tensionExpand
What would Chinese history look like if we were to examine it from the perspective of the peoples living along China's periphery? How might a non-Chinese perspective challenge the dominant themes inExpand
Competing visions of a postmodern world order: the Philadelphian system versus the Tianxia system
Abstract This article analyses competing discourses on a postmodern world order perpetuated by the United States and the People’s Republic of China (PRC), which are themselves built on their ownExpand


Politics and Sinology: The Case of Naito Konan, 1866-1934
Naito Konan's periodization of Chinese history is responsible for shaping the twentieth-century Western view of China. Naito was a journalist in the vibrant Meiji press for twenty years, during whichExpand
Research Trends in Asia: “Writing History during a Prosperous Age”: The New Qing History Project
Ever since its collapse in 1911, the Qing Empire has attracted widespread scholarly attention both in China and abroad. At the turn of the twentieth-first century, the study of Qing history gainedExpand
Reinventing modern China : imagination and authenticity in Chinese historical writing
This work offers the first systematic analysis of writings on modern Chinese history by historians in China from the early twentieth century to the present. It traces the construction of majorExpand
Qing Colonial Enterprise: Ethnography and Cartography in Early Modern China
Laura Hostetler here shows how Qing China (1636-1911) used cartography and ethnography to pursue its imperial ambitions. She argues that far from being on the periphery of developments in the earlyExpand
The "Localist Turn" and "Local Identity" in Later Imperial China
�� For many years historians of the middle period of Chinese history—roughly from mid-eighth century into the fifteenth century—found considerable appeal in the idea that the Tang-Song transitionExpand
Reflections on the "New Qing History" School in the United States
The rise of the "New Qing History" school in the United States has opened new vistas for the study of Qing history. The school challenged the long-received idea of "sinification" in evaluating theExpand
Reinventing China
This article uses both Manchu and Han sources to interrogate the relationship between Qing and China. After toppling the Ming reign, the Qing rulers identified their state with China as theirExpand
White Lotus Rebels and South China Pirates: Crisis and Reform in the Qing Empire
The reign of Emperor Jiaqing (1796-1820 CE) has long occupied an awkward position in studies of China's last dynasty, the Qing (1644-1911 CE). Conveniently marking a watershed between the prosperousExpand
Introduction: The Significance of the Qianlong-Jiaqing Transition in Qing History
Over the past decades, we have learned a great deal about the Qing’s “prosperous age” (shengshi) of the eighteenth century, and about the first kaifang era of the late nineteenth and early twentiethExpand
The New Qing History
Pamela K. Crossley, A Translucent Mirror: History and Identity in Qing Imperial Ideology. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999. Mark C. Elliott, The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and EthnicExpand