New Evidence About the Existence of a Bandwagon Effect in the Opinion Formation Process

  title={New Evidence About the Existence of a Bandwagon Effect in the Opinion Formation Process},
  author={R. Nadeau and Edouard Cloutier and J. Guay},
  journal={International Political Science Review},
  pages={203 - 213}
This study undertakes an empirical test of the "bandwagon effect"—individuals rallying to the majority opinion. The study is done outside the electoral context on two issues: abortion and the constitutional future of Quebec. A panel is used, as well as an experimental design in which respondents are told the state and direction of public opinion. Three methodological criteria are used as minimal requirements for a satisfac tory test of the bandwagon thesis. "Underdogging," as well as opinion… Expand

Tables from this paper

The Influence of Public Opinion Polls on Issue Preferences
We investigate the impact of the polling “bandwagon effect,” which is the tendency for people to modify their beliefs to conform to the majority opinion presented by a poll. While most research onExpand
Think Twice before Jumping on the Bandwagon: Clarifying Concepts in Research on the Bandwagon Effect
The potential influence of perceived popularity of political parties or candidates on individual vote choice is most commonly studied in terms of a ‘bandwagon effect’. However, there is confusionExpand
The Prevention Effect of Third-Person Perception: A Study on the Perceived and Actual Influence of Polls
This study ties the third-person effect phenomenon to social comparison research by positing that a downward comparison is made when people regard “others” as more influenced than themselves byExpand
Are public opinion polls self-fulfilling prophecies?
Psychologists have long observed that people conform to majority opinion, a phenomenon sometimes referred to as the ‘bandwagon effect’. In the political domain people learn about prevailing publicExpand
The Media's Persuasive Effects: The Priming of Leadership in the 1988 Canadian Election *
This article examines the effect of the media during the 1988 Canadian election. Using National Election Study data, three questions are investigated: do those with different patterns of mediaExpand
Attitudinal and Behavioral Consequences of Published Opinion Polls
It is a truism to speak of the key normative role that public opinion polls play in contemporary democratic societies. Theorists and practitioners have long extolled how polls inextricably linkExpand
Exploring the effects of polls on public opinion: How and when media reports of policy preferences can become self-fulfilling prophesies
Recent work has suggested that media reporting about the public’s policy preferences may be self-reinforcing, contributing to greater policy conformity. This article presents additional evidence inExpand
Distinguishing Strategic Voting from Bandwagon Effects – How did Voters ' Subjective Expectations Affect Results
Most previous empirical studies about strategic voting counted the bandwagon effect into the effect from strategic consideration, and might overestimate the extent of strategic voting. Hence, thisExpand
Funhouse Mirrors: Do Polls Reflect Public Opinion or Refract Democracy?
The news media’s dissemination of public opinion polls has increased exponentially over the past decade. While most citizens treat polls as reliable sources of information upon which to base theirExpand
The Downside of Democracy Polarization through Choice Induced Attitude Change in a Political Context
  • 2016
Polarization is becoming an increasingly visible and damaging phenomenon. Recent studies have suggested that one factor that increases polarization is the simple act of voting. This thesis builds onExpand


Previous explanations of bandwagons from election polls have exclusively emphasized conformity causes. We propose, in addition, “indirect' causes, in which election predictions first affect keyExpand
The Impact of Polls on Public Opinion
There are three ways in which polls can influence the public opinion they purport merely to measure. Just being interviewed tends to arouse interest and to encourage some respondents to informExpand
Candidate Choice and the Dynamics of the Presidential Nominating Process
Data from the NES "rolling cross-section" survey are used to investigate the dynamics of popular support for Gary Hart during the 1984 primary season. A model is developed that relates preferencesExpand
Back on the Bandwagon: The Effect of Opinion Polls on Public Opinion
The bandwagon was the caravan in a circus that carried the band, and usually took the lead in a procession. It has come to stand as a symbol for a party or a cause which is successful; we talk ofExpand
Do the polls affect elections? Some 1980 evidence
This paper finds that the relatively favorable standing of Ronald Reagan in the preelection polls helped to generate a bandwagon effect in the 1980 presidential election. The models tested hereExpand
Expectations and Preferences in Presidential Nominating Campaigns
Survey data from the preconvention waves of the 1980 National Election Study are used to estimate the effect of expectations about who will be nominated on respondents' own preferences. The resultsExpand
Bandwagon and Underdog Effects in Minimal-Information Elections *
This investigation is based on an experimental study of voting behavior in what the author terms a minimal-information election. This type of election is characterized by a dearth of publicExpand
Attitudinal Conformity and Anonymity
Past research has shown that surveillance, unanimity of others, and ambiguous stimuli all contribute to conformity. This study sought to determine whether people will conform to a group they identifyExpand
Strategic voting in Britain
Formal political theory has raised serious doubts about the existence of strategic voting, and this in turn has challenged the prevailing wisdom in comparative politics about phenomena likeExpand
An Experimental Approach to Bandwagon Research
This article describes an experiment in which experimental and control questionnaires were sent to two different sample groups of respondents. Both questionnaires contained the same four opinionExpand