Neuroimaging of Language: Why Hasn't a Clearer Picture Emerged?

@article{Fedorenko2009NeuroimagingOL,
  title={Neuroimaging of Language: Why Hasn't a Clearer Picture Emerged?},
  author={Evelina Fedorenko and Nancy G. Kanwisher},
  journal={Lang. Linguistics Compass},
  year={2009},
  volume={3},
  pages={839-865}
}
Two broad questions have driven dozens of studies on the neural basis of language published in the last several decades: (i) Are distinct cortical regions engaged in different aspects of language? (ii) Are regions engaged in language processing specific to the domain of language? Neuroimaging has not yet provided clear answers to either question. In this paper, we discuss one factor that is a likely contributor to the unclear state of affairs in the neurocognition of language, and that, in our… 

Figures from this paper

Functional specificity for high-level linguistic processing in the human brain
TLDR
Functional MRI is used to define classic language regions functionally in each subject individually and then examined the response of these regions to the nonlinguistic functions most commonly argued to engage these regions: arithmetic, working memory, cognitive control, and music, which support a clear distinction between language and other cognitive processes.
Dynamic Functional Organization of Language
  • S. Blumstein, D. Amso
  • Biology, Psychology
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2013
One of the oldest questions in cognitive science is whether cognitive operations are modular or distributed across domains. We propose that fMRI has made a unique contribution to this question by
New method for fMRI investigations of language: defining ROIs functionally in individual subjects.
TLDR
The selectivity of these regions is stronger using the method than when standard group analyses are conducted on the same data, suggesting that the future application of this method may reveal clearer functional specificity than has been evident in prior neuroimaging research on language.
Title : A new method for fMRI investigations of language : Defining ROIs 1 functionally in individual subjects 2 3 Authors :
TLDR
It is hypothesize that clearer functional specificity may emerge if candidate language-sensitive regions are identified functionally within each subject individually, a method that has revealed striking functional specificity in visual cortex but that has rarely been applied to neuroimaging studies of language.
Can neuroimaging help aphasia researchers? Addressing generalizability, variability, and interpretability
TLDR
It is argued for an approach that circumvents the critical assumption that a given anatomical landmark corresponds to the same functional unit(s) across individuals, and it eliminates the need for post hoc “reverse inference” from anatomical landmarks back to cognitive operations, thus improving data interpretability.
Functional neuroimaging of theory of mind
TLDR
A perspective on the contribution that neuroimaging has made to the science of ToM in the last decade is offered, and some thoughts on the contributions that it could make in the next one are highlighted.
Broca's Area and Language Processing: Evidence for the Cognitive Control Connection
TLDR
New empirical evidence from various fields is reviewed that supports a hypothesis that Broca’s area is responsible for biasing production and comprehension processes when there are strong demands to resolve competition among incompatible characterizations of linguistic stimuli.
Domain-General Brain Regions Do Not Track Linguistic Input as Closely as Language-Selective Regions
TLDR
It is found that MD regions track stories less closely than language regions, which constrains the possible contributions of the MD network to comprehension, contrasts with accounts positing that this network has continuous access to linguistic input, and suggests a new typology of comprehension processes based on their extent of input tracking.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 180 REFERENCES
Rethinking the neurological basis of language
Does functional neuroimaging solve the questions of neurolinguistics?
Does functional neuroimaging solve the questions of neurolinguistics?
TLDR
It is proposed that the often-inconsistent superfluity of outcomes arising from functional imaging studies of language awaits adjustment at both "ends" of the process: model and data.
Combined Analysis of Language Tasks in fMRI Improves Assessment of Hemispheric Dominance for Language Functions in Individual Subjects
TLDR
A simple method to assess language lateralization that allows for some variation of tasks and statistical thresholding, but at the same time yields reliable and reproducible results is presented.
Functional MRI of language: new approaches to understanding the cortical organization of semantic processing.
  • S. Bookheimer
  • Psychology, Biology
    Annual review of neuroscience
  • 2002
TLDR
Three lines of fMRI research into how the semantic system is organized in the adult brain are discussed, which broaden the understanding of how the brain stores, retrieves, and makes sense of semantic information and challenge some commonly held notions of functional modularity in the language system.
Renewal of the neurophysiology of language: functional neuroimaging.
TLDR
The impact of the functional neuroimaging revolution on the understanding of language is characterized to show how functional imaging can allow fine-grained approaches to adaptation, the fundamental property of the brain.
Neuroimaging studies of the cerebellum: language, learning and memory
...
...