Nemesis reconsidered: Nemesis reconsidered

@article{Melott2010NemesisRN,
  title={Nemesis reconsidered: Nemesis reconsidered},
  author={Adrian L. Melott and Richard K. Bambach},
  journal={Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters},
  year={2010},
  volume={407}
}
  • A. Melott, R. Bambach
  • Published 2 July 2010
  • Physics
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters
The hypothesis of a companion object (Nemesis) orbiting the Sun was motivated by the claim of a terrestrial extinction periodicity, thought to be mediated by comet showers. The orbit of a distant companion to the Sun is expected to be perturbed by the Galactic tidal field and encounters with passing stars, which will induce variation in the period. We examine the evidence for the previously proposed periodicity, using two modern, greatly improved paleontological datasets of fossil biodiversity… 

Figures from this paper

Periodic mass extinctions and the Planet X model reconsidered
The 27 Myr periodicity in the fossil extinction record has been confirmed in modern data bases dating back 500 Myr, which is twice the time interval of the original analysis from thirty years ago.
Do Periodicities in Extinction—with Possible Astronomical Connections—Survive a Revision of the Geological Timescale?
TLDR
It is found that the spectral power in this period is somewhat increased, and persists at a narrow bandwidth, which supports the previous contention that the Nemesis hypothesis is untenable as an explanation for the periodicity of marine extinction rates.
Are Impact Craters and Extinction Episodes Periodic? Implications for Planetary Science and Astrobiology.
TLDR
Questions arise with regard to the compatibility of such periodic pulses of comet flux with the makeup of the steady-state Near Earth Object (NEO) population, the estimated long-term NEO cratering rates on the terrestrial planets, and the predicted small contribution of Oort Cloud-derived comets to the terrestrial cratering record.
Mass extinctions over the last 500 myr: an astronomical cause?
A Fourier analysis of the magnitudes and timing of the Phanerozoic mass extinctions (MEs) demonstrates that many of the periodicities claimed in other analyses are not statistically significant.
Analysis of periodicity of extinction using the 2012 geological timescale
TLDR
Analysis of two independent data sets with increased taxonomic resolution using the revised 2012 timescale reveals that an extinction periodicity first detected by Raup and Sepkoski (1984) for only the post-Paleozoic actually runs through the entire Phanerozoic.
Constraints on the location of a putative distant massive body in the Solar System from recent planetary data
We analytically work out the long-term variations caused on the motion of a planet orbiting a star by a very distant, pointlike massive object X. Apart from the semi-major axis a, all the other
On the anomalous secular increase of the eccentricity of the orbit of the Moon
A recent analysis of a Lunar Laser Ranging (LLR) data record spanning 38.7 yr revealed an anomalous increase of the eccentricity e of the lunar orbit amounting to u emeas = (9 ± 3) × 10 12 yr 1 . The
Giant comets and mass extinctions of life
I find evidence for clustering in age of well-dated impact craters over the last 500 Myr. At least nine impact episodes are identified, with durations whose upper limits are set by the dating
Limits to biodiversity cycles from a unified model of mass-extinction events
  • G. Feulner
  • Environmental Science, Geography
    International Journal of Astrobiology
  • 2011
TLDR
It is shown that if there is a periodic extinction signal at all, it is much more likely to result from a combination of a comparatively weak periodic cause and various random factors.
A tale of clusters: no resolvable periodicity in the terrestrial impact cratering record
Rampino & Caldeira (2015) carry out a circular spectral analysis (CSA) of the terrestrial impact cratering record over the past 260 million years (Ma), and suggest a ~26 Ma periodicity of impact
...
1
2
3
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 34 REFERENCES
Terrestrial catastrophism—Nemesis or Galaxy?
The ∼30 Myr periodicity associated with the Sun's motion through the central plane has been linked to geomagnetic reversals1,2, biological extinctions3 and crater ages4–6. This periodicity is
Extinction of species by periodic comet showers
A 26-Myr periodicity has recently been seen in the fossil record of extinction in the geological past1. At least two of these extinctions are known to be associated with the impact on the Earth of a
Orbital stability of the unseen solar companion linked to periodic extinction events
Recent suggestions of astronomical causes for the closely periodic extinction events in the geological record1 and the possible periodicities in the cratering record2 have involved two basic ideas.
How stable is an astronomical clock that can trigger mass extinctions on Earth?
  • P. Hut
  • Physics, Geology
    Nature
  • 1984
The periodicity in mass extinctions observed in the fossil record1,2 may be driven by an astronomical clock consisting of a companion star to the Sun3,4. Each perihelion passage of the companion star
Dynamical constraints on the mass and perihelion distance of Nemesis and the stability of its orbit
It has been suggested1,2 that the observed periodic extinction of species at intervals of 26 Myr (ref. 3) may be catalysed by a hypothetical stellar companion of the Sun, Nemesis, with an orbital
Are periodic mass extinctions driven by a distant solar companion?
Raup and Sepkoski1–3 have recently reported evidence for a 26-Myr cycle in biological mass extinctions which, if real, requires an astronomical explanation. Here we investigate a model in which this
Constraints on planet X/Nemesis from Solar System's inner dynamics
We use the corrections Δ to the standard Newtonian/Einsteinian perihelion precessions of the inner planets of the Solar system, recently estimated by E.V. Pitjeva by fitting a huge planetary data set
Periodicity in extinction and the problem of catastrophism in the history of life
  • J. Sepkoski
  • Environmental Science, Geography
    Journal of the Geological Society
  • 1989
TLDR
The hypothesis that extinction events have recurred periodically over the last quarter billion years is greatly strengthened by new data on the stratigraphic ranges of marine animal genera, and most arguments against periodicity are weakened or negate.
Considering the Case for Biodiversity Cycles: Re-Examining the Evidence for Periodicity in the Fossil Record
TLDR
The signal is robust against variations in methods of analysis, and is based on fluctuations in the Paleozoic and a substantial part of the Mesozoic.
Periodicity of extinctions in the geologic past.
  • D. Raup, J. Sepkoski
  • Geography, Environmental Science
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
  • 1984
TLDR
The temporal distribution of the major extinctions over the past 250 million years has been investigated statistically using various forms of time series analysis and contains 12 extinction events that show a statistically significant periodicity.
...
1
2
3
4
...