Natural Selection, Energetics, and "Cultural Materialism" [and Comments and Reply]

  title={Natural Selection, Energetics, and "Cultural Materialism" [and Comments and Reply]},
  author={Richard Newbold Adams and Donald T. Campbell and Ronald Cohen and Richard A. Curtin and Whitney M. Davis and Arie de Ruijter and Paul W. Diener and Robert C. Dunnell and Jeffrey David Ehrenreich and Kajsa Ekholm and Jonathan Friedman and Ronn Parker and J. Iain Prattis and Jim Weil},
  journal={Current Anthropology},
  pages={603 - 624}
Harris's cultural materialistic strategy of research must be more explicit in recognizing that it deals with nonlinear events that are constantly modified by natural-selective processes. These processes require a different kind of explanation, called here "selection explanation." Moreover, the tripartite notion of infrastructure/structure/superstructure and the mental/behavioral, emic/etic, and culture/nature dichotomies do not allow unambiguous classification of elements pertaining to the… 
Cultural Materialism: Food for Thought or Bum Steer? [and Comments and Replies]
In its specific theories Harris's cultural materialism has often proven illuminating. As a model of and method for studying culture, however, it is seriously flawed. One of the dilemmas it faces is
Cultural Materialism: A Theoretical Review
A review of the principles of cultural materialism (a synthesis of Marx's causal primacy of the infrastructure and Darwinian mechanisms of natural selection), this paper addresses certain substantive
Transgenerational Cultural Dynamics: From Neo-Evolutionism To a Truly Evolutionary Theory
This analysis attempts a careful re-examination of central issues that were posed, if not resolved, in cultural evolutionism through a critique of neo-evolutionism from within in the search for a ’truly evolutionary’ theory as yet untried.
Where Do You Go When You Die? A Cross-Cultural Test of the Hypothesis That Infrastructure Predicts Individual Eschatology
Cultural materialism gives priority to infrastructure, that is, to productive and reproductive processes, in explaining sociocultural systems. It predicts that social structures and
Cultural Performance and Differential Fitness in a U.S. University Population
The notion of "cultural performance" is proposed as a theoretical paradigm for the cross-cultural understanding of the relationship between cultural and biological goals. The concepts of conformity
Telling Tales at Work
This article explores the adaptive functions of storytelling in the workplace from an evolutionary perspective. Based on the analysis of ethnographic studies on hunter-gatherer and modern work
Americanist Archaeological Literature: 1981
  • R. Dunnell
  • Sociology
    American Journal of Archaeology
  • 1982
The 1981 Americanist literature is, in terms of content, not radically different from its predecessors. Cultural Resource Management, in spite of the economic downturn, is still an important force in
Anarchism and the Archaeology of Anarchic Societies
Throughout human history, people have lived in societies without formalized government. We argue that the theory of anarchism presents a productive framework for analyzing decentralized societies.
The evolution of early Egyptian civilization: Issues and evidence
Egypt's cultural evolution between 4000 and 2000 B.C. is reviewed in and related to methodological and theoretical issues in contemporary archaeology. Recent archaeological evidence from the Nile


Evolutionary Epistemology and Human Values [and Comments and Reply]
The theory of evolution is a body of concepts and relations that applies to social and cultural phenomena as well as to biological ones. The fundamental ideas of the theory-taxonomy, developmental
Genetic and cultural pools: Some suggestions for a unified theory of biocultural evolution
The proposed theory states that individuals are the generating force behind the origin, spread, and transformations of sociocultural complexes and that all sociOCultural phenomena are explicable in terms of the differential replication of ideas by individuals as this is conditioned by selective pressures generated by particular material conditions of life.
Our Obsolete Production Mentality: The Heresy of the Communal Formation [and Comments and Reply]
Nonmaterial aspects of social practices such as symbolic exchange, modes of destruction of wealth-in short, the broad field of "antieconomic" activities-have not been fully examined by economic
"'Capital' imperialism and exploitation in ancient world systems"
The above title may appear provocative to those who would maintain that capital is, by definition, wage-labor capital, that imperialism is the highest stage of capitalism, and that before the
Style and Function: A Fundamental Dichotomy
Consideration of an evolutionary approach suggests that such processes as natural selection have considerable explanatory potential, but it is also suggested that a substantial segment of the archaeological record is not best understood in terms of adaptation.
A multiple-level model of evolution and its implications for sociobiology
An alternative multiple-level, multiple-process model of evolution is presented which posits that the primary process that operates via selection upon the genes cannot account for certain kinds of biological phenomena, especially complex, learned, social behaviours.
Man, Energy, and Anthropology: I Can Feel the Heat, But Where's the Light?
Anthropology should deal with man holistically, but has failed to do so. The field is unfortunately split between mentalistic and materialistic schools and has not developed a theory to cope with the
The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptationist programme
  • S. Gould, R. Lewontin
  • Biology
    Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B. Biological Sciences
  • 1979
The adaptationist programme is faulted for its failure to distinguish current utility from reasons for origin, and Darwin’s own pluralistic approach to identifying the agents of evolutionary change is supported.
seem religious. A century ago E. B. Tylor (1871), whom some consider "the father " of modern anthropol ogy, attempted to accou nt for the univer­ sality of religion by reference to the psychic unity
Quantum Adjustment, Macroevolution, and the Social Field: Some Comments on Evolution and Culture [and Comments and Reply]
In this paper, some biological ideas are used as "creative analogies" for cultural theory, taking the origin of Indian sacred-cattle practices as an example.