National Identities and Attitudes to Constitutional Change in Post-Devolution UK: A Four Territories Comparison

  title={National Identities and Attitudes to Constitutional Change in Post-Devolution UK: A Four Territories Comparison},
  author={Ross Bond and Michael Rosie},
  journal={Regional \& Federal Studies},
  pages={105 - 83}
This paper analyses survey data drawn from two distinct time points (2003 and 2006/07) to examine whether national identities in the UK are associated with support for further constitutional change. It compares all four ‘national’ territories of the UK: England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. We use logistic regression to model the relationships between identities and constitutional attitudes, taking into consideration other relevant social and political variables. While in England there… 
National Identities and the 2014 Independence Referendum in Scotland
This paper discusses the 2014 independence referendum in relation to national identities in Scotland. This is done firstly through reflecting on the referendum franchise and then by examining how
Government Performance, Identity, and Support for Further Devolution in Europe
Over the past three decades, Europe has witnessed a growing trend of devolution, or the transfer of power from states to their regions. Much of the previous scholarship has examined the causes of
Brexit and Territorial Preferences: Evidence from Scotland and Northern Ireland
Has the UK referendum to leave the EU (Brexit) affected territorial preferences within the UK? We draw on comparative theories of such preferences to address this question, as Brexit can be seen as
Understanding English public reactions to the Scottish parliament
Although elite commentators have regularly predicted an English backlash to the asymmetric devolution settlement, public opinion surveys generally reveal widespread acceptance of the principle of
The view from above: Scottish national identity as an elite concept
This article examines the nature of national identity as held by political elites within Scotland. Through an examination of interview data collected from over 60 members of the elected political
Looking up in Scotland? Multinationalism, multiculturalism and political elites
At a time when all the political parties of Scotland are trying to establish a persuasive vision of the nation, inquiry into where ethnic and racial minorities fit into these debates provides one
‘The Essence of the Union …’: Unionism, Nationalism and Identity On These Disconnected Islands
Linda Colley (1996) identified three key ‘glues’ for the British Union state created in 1707: extensive wars with France; a uniting sense of Protestantism; and a burgeoning commercial and military
Perceptions of irregular immigrants’ participation in undeclared work in the United Kingdom from a social trust perspective
Purpose – There is a significant body of work dealing with the topic of undeclared work and irregular immigrants. However, relatively little is understood about the British general public’s
Understanding Majority Attitudes toward Minority Nations in Multinational Federations: The Case of Canada
While a relatively large body of literature has explored the conditions that might promote either reform or the status quo in multinational federations, few studies have explored majority attitudes


National identity in Northern Ireland: stability or change?
ABSTRACT. This article addresses a set of fundamental, long-term factors associated with the Northern Ireland conflict: the pattern of underlying values and attitudes, especially those related to
Political Constructions of National Identity in Scotland and Quebec
The opening of the Scottish Parliament provides a useful opportunity to reflect on the success and struggles of other regional or sub-national Parliaments, particularly those where nationalist
English Identity and Ethnic Diversity in the Context of UK Constitutional Change
At the time of the devolution settlement in the UK, there was widespread concern that the establishment of the Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales would prompt a rise in English
Birth, Blood and Belonging: Identity Claims in Post-Devolution Scotland 1
Scotland is often seen as a good example of a civic/territorial rather than an ethnic/cultural form of nationalism. From the 1970s the campaign for a Scottish parliament stressed an inclusive,
A Stronger or Weaker Union? Public Reactions to Asymmetric Devolution in the United Kingdom
A system of asymmetric devolution was established for the first time in Great Britain in 1999. Its advocates hoped it would strengthen public support for the maintenance of the United Kingdom,
Squaring the Circles: Demonstrating and Explaining the Political ‘Non-Alignment’ of Scottish National Identity
While discussion and introspection about national identity has arguably been a consistent feature of life in Scotland for quite some time, it has been given added impetus by the recent restoration of
Social Constituency and Ideological Profile: Scottish Nationalism in the 1990s
Using data from the 1992 Scottish and British Election Surveys, the authors examine various models which might explain the changes in the level and type of Scottish National Party voting. In the
Being British: A Crisis of Identity?
An assumed decline in Britishness has rekindled concern over the ‘break up of Britain’. The creation of the Scottish Parliament in 1999 is taken as the cause and the effect of Scots having come to
Who are We? Problematising National Identity
While the concern with ‘identity politics’ has grown in recent years, there are few studies of the ways in which people order and negotiate their national identities. The study reported here focuses
Religious and National Identity after the Belfast Good Friday Agreement
National and religious identification processes can be seen as the basis of the conflict in Northern Ireland, and over the course of the conflict preferred social and political identities became