Nation, identity and the fascination with forensic science in Sherlock Holmes and CSI

  title={Nation, identity and the fascination with forensic science in Sherlock Holmes and CSI},
  author={Ellen Burton Harrington},
  journal={International Journal of Cultural Studies},
  pages={365 - 382}
  • E. Harrington
  • Published 1 September 2007
  • Sociology
  • International Journal of Cultural Studies
Although the popular television series CSI: Crime Scene Investigation presents cutting-edge images and laboratory techniques, it reiterates the reassuring ideological message and the glorification of the man of science that typify Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories. While the Holmes stories use reassuring, formulaic narratives to consolidate a normative national identity and counter increasing disenchantment with empire, CSI replays a similar sort of procedural detective story to reassure viewers… 
Policing, Surveillance, and Terror—and the Return of Sherlock Holmes
  • Darcie Rives-East
  • Art
    Surveillance and Terror in Post-9/11 British and American Television
  • 2019
Chapter 3 examines the phenomenon of the modern television interest in Sherlock Holmes (specifically, the programs Sherlock and Elementary) in light of an increase in television drama and docuseries
Extreme Makeover CSI Edition: Tracing the Forensic Crime Drama's Engagement with Identity Crimes, Plastic Bodies and Self-Transformation Narratives
This article examines discourses on identity and bodily plasticity in the forensic crime drama CSI: Crime Scene Investigation (2000–). It argues that CSI engages with the same cultural debates as
Producing Absolute Truth: CSI Science as Wishful Thinking
Forensic science has come to be assigned an important role in contemporary crime fiction. In this article, I analyze the cultural repertoire of forensic science conveyed by the popular television
From crime lab to mind palace: post-CSI forensics in Sherlock
Abstract This article examines the complex relationship between Sherlock (BBC, 2010–present) and the forensic crime drama genre category. Tracing the televisual genre linkages that Sherlock
Detective fiction has popularly been considered a light form of literary entertainment. However, many of this genre’s practitioners underline the way that their novels engage with contemporary social
The bare bones of social commentary in Kathy Reichs' fiction
Detective fiction has popularly been considered a light form of literary entertainment. However, many of this genre’s practitioners underline the way that their novels engage with contemporary social
Fantasies of control: Numb3rs, scientific rationalism, and the management of everyday security risks
This paper examines the US-made television drama series Numb3rs as a key example of what has been called ‘post-9/11’ television – a form of drama production characterized by a strong reinvestment in
Holmes and the History of Detective Fiction
  • M. Burrow
  • Art
    The Cambridge Companion to Sherlock Holmes
  • 2019
The extent of Holmes’s dominance in our perceptions of late-Victorian detective fiction might lead one to the conclusion that Doyle was the most successful practitioner of detective fiction, even if
Historicizing CSI and its Effect(s): The Real and the Representational in American Scientific Detective Fiction and Print News Media, 1902–1935
Over the past decade, CBS’s hit television show CSI: Crime Scene Investigation has been characterized as novel and innovative, as one of the first times forensic science was made palatable to a
Gothic Returns:The Hound of the Baskervilles
  • J. Allan
  • Art
    The Cambridge Companion to Sherlock Holmes
  • 2019
In bringing together the scientific detective and the supernatural beast of ancient legend, The Hound of the Baskervilles occupies a liminal position, poised between the rational positivism of


Women with a Mission
Prime Suspect constitutes a transitional text in the history of TV crime drama, for its simultaneous intervention into the genre's sexual politics and representation of `realism'. Camerawork is
The Spectacle of Crime, Digitized
One of the most significant features of the television series CSI: Crime Scene Investigationis its central preoccupation – forensic evidence – and the profession practised by its major characters –
The Sign of Four
Arthur Conan Doyle’s second Sherlock Holmes novel is both a detective story and an imperial romance. Ostensibly the story of Mary Morstan, a beautiful young woman enlisting the help of Holmes to find
From Bow Street to Baker Street: Mystery, Detection and Narrative
Part 1 Rite and writing: mystery - mystery and detection, mystery and narrative, mystery and secularization, notes. Part 2 Wronging rights and righting wrongs: crime - the law, the novel, equity,
Adventure, Mystery and Romance: Formula Stories as Art and Popular Culture
In this first general theory for the analysis of popular literary formulas, John G. Cawelti reveals the artistry that underlies the best in formulaic literature. Cawelti discusses such seemingly
Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity
Preface (1999) Preface (1990) 1. Subjects of Sex/Gender/Desire I. 'Women' as the Subject of Feminism II. The Compulsory Order of Sex/Gender/Desire III. Gender: The Circular Ruins of Contemporary
Gender's nature
The distinction between ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ is challenged by arguments that ‘sex’ is equally a social construction, initiating a selfreflexive effort to return feminism to its foundational grounding.
The Recoil of "The Speckled Band": Detective Story and Detective Discourse
"If you ask the ordinary reader which of the Sherlock Holmes short stories he likes best," Jacques Barzun observes in The Delights of Detection, "the chances are that he will say: 'The Speckled
Crime Scene Instigation.
This article focuses on a meeting of forensic scientists who put the television program "CSI: Crime Scene Investigation" under scrutiny.
Memories and Adventures
This autobiography of Arthur Conan Doyle describes the varied aspects of his professional life as a doctor, sportsman, adventurer, political campaigner and author. It recounts the many true