Narrative and evidence. How can case studies from the history of science support claims in the philosophy of science?

@article{Kinzel2015NarrativeAE,
  title={Narrative and evidence. How can case studies from the history of science support claims in the philosophy of science?},
  author={Katherina Kinzel},
  journal={Studies in history and philosophy of science},
  year={2015},
  volume={49},
  pages={
          48-57
        }
}
  • Katherina Kinzel
  • Published 1 February 2015
  • Philosophy
  • Studies in history and philosophy of science
Using History as Evidence in Philosophy of Science: A Methodological Critique
This article offers a critical review of past attempts and possible methods to test philosophical models of science against evidence from history of science. Drawing on methodological debates in
Negotiating history: Contingency, canonicity, and case studies.
Historical Case Studies: The “Model Organisms” of Philosophy of Science
Philosophers use historical case studies to support wide-ranging claims about science. This practice is often criticized as problematic. In this paper we suggest that the function of case studies can
Case Studies, Selective Realism, and Historical Evidence
Case studies of science concerning the interpretation of specific theories and the nature of theory change over time are often presented as evidence for or against forms of selective realism:
The Case Study Method in Philosophy of Science: An Empirical Study
There is an ongoing methodological debate in philosophy of science concerning the use of case studies as evidence for and/or against theories about science. In this paper, I aim to make a
Pluralism in Historiography: A Case Study of Case Studies
In history the same historical episodes can be reconstructed from multiple perspectives, leading to different interpretations and evaluations of the same events, and sometimes even to different
Contrasting Cases: The Lotka-Volterra Model Times Three
How do philosophers of science make use of historical case studies? Are their accounts of historical cases purpose-built and lacking in evidential strength as a result of putting forth and discussing
State of the field: Are the results of science contingent or inevitable?
Could Science be Interestingly Different?
In this paper, I investigate the issue of the contingency and inevitability of science. First, I point out valuable insights from the existing discussion about the issue. I then formulate a general
NORMATIVITY IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE MARIE I. KAISER
  • Philosophy
  • 2019
This paper analyzes what it means for philosophy of science to be normative. It argues that normativity is a multifaceted phenomenon rather than a general feature that a philosophical theory either
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 66 REFERENCES
The Dilemma of Case Studies Resolved: The Virtues of Using Case Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science
  • R. Burian
  • Philosophy
    Perspectives on Science
  • 2001
Philosophers of science turned to historical case studies in part in response to Thomas Kuhn's insistence that such studies can transform the philosophy of science. In this issue Joseph Pitt argues
Beyond Case-Studies: History as Philosophy
Dissatisfaction with hasty philosophical generalizations from a small number of conveniently chosen case-studies has contributed significantly to a widespread disillusionment with the whole
Pluralism in Historiography: A Case Study of Case Studies
In history the same historical episodes can be reconstructed from multiple perspectives, leading to different interpretations and evaluations of the same events, and sometimes even to different
Narrative Constraints on Historical Writing: The Case of the Scientific Revolution
The Argument In this paper three canonical studies of the scientific revolution are subjected to narratological analysis. Underlying this analysis is the assumption that in any single product of
More than a Marriage of Convenience: On the Inextricability of History and Philosophy of Science
History of science, it has been argued, has benefited philosophers of science primarily by forcing them into greater contact with "real science." In this paper I argue that additional major benefits
Narrative Explanations: The Case of History
Narratives are stories, a telling that something happened. A narrative explanation, presumably, presents an account of the linkages among events as a process leading to the outcome one seeks to
THE MISSING NARRATIVIST TURN IN THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF SCIENCE
The narrativist turn of the 1970s and 1980s transformed the discussion of general history. With the rejection of Rankean historical realism, the focus shifted to the historian as a narrator and on
Metahistory. The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe.
Since its initial publication in 1973, Hayden White's Metahistory has remained an essential book for understanding the nature of historical writing. In this classic work, White argues that a deep
Theory-Ladenness and Scientific Instruments in Experimentation
Since the late 1950s one of the most important and influential views of post-positivist philosophy of science has been the theory-ladenness of observation. It comes in at least two forms: either as a
...
...