Myth and Memory: Sir Douglas Haig and the Imposition of Allied Unified Command in March 1918

  title={Myth and Memory: Sir Douglas Haig and the Imposition of Allied Unified Command in March 1918},
  author={Elizabeth M. Greenhalgh},
  journal={The Journal of Military History},
  pages={771 - 820}
Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig's claim to have taken the initiative in getting General Ferdinand Foch appointed to the allied supreme command in 1918 needs re-evaluation. After a discussion of the reliability of Haig's diaries, the five elements of the traditional narrative of this crucial event are examined in turn, using both British and French archival records. All five are shown to be mis-representations. Finally, an examination of the postwar record permits a tentative explanation for the… 
22 Citations

Figures and Tables from this paper

Haig's Intelligence: GHQ and the German Army, 1916–1918

Haig's Intelligence is an important new study of Douglas Haig's controversial command during the First World War. Based on extensive new research, it addresses a perennial question about the British

The British Army and the First World War

This is a major new history of the British army during the Great War written by three leading military historians. Ian Beckett, Timothy Bowman and Mark Connelly survey operations on the Western Front

The French Army and the First World War

Introduction 1. The pre-war army 2. 1914: from the frontiers to Flanders 3. 1915: on the offensive 4. 1916: Verdun and the Somme 5. General Nivelle and his 1917 offensive 6. Restoring the Army 7.

Our Corner of the Somme

Villers-Bretonneux is an important site in Australian commemorative imagination. It is there that the Australian National Memorial stands, and where—as Australia’s official historian Charles Bean


  • Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019

A school or nothing

  • Education
    Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019

‘Have we forgotten this place?’

  • Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019


  • Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019


  • Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019


  • Our Corner of the Somme
  • 2019



Lying About Hitler: History, Holocaust and the David Irving Trial

An illumination of one of the most explosive and publicized "holocaust trials" since that of Adolf Eichmann, by a leading historian who acted as chief adviser to the defense. In ruling against the

Anglo-French Relations and Strategy on the Western Front, 1914-18

List of Maps - Acknowledgements - List of Abbreviations - Deficiencies in Preparation: August 1914 - Differences in the Field: Mons and the Marne, August-September 1914 - The Failure of Coordination:

War Diaries 1939-1945

Alanbrooke was CIGS - Chief of the Imperial General Staff - for the greater part of the Second World War. He acted as mentor to Montgomery and military adviser to Churchill, with whom he clashed. As

The First World War

Industrial and ironclad power reached its culmination in the war that engulfed Europe. As events would prove, however, the products of the industrial system of the 20th century, including the

The Killing Ground: The British Army, the Western Front, and the Emergence of Modern Warfare, 1900-1918

This books explains why the British Army fought the way it did in the First World War. It integrates social and military history and the impact of ideas to tell the story of how the army, especially

Anglo-French Relations in the Twentieth Century: Rivalry and Cooperation

Anglo-French Relations in the Twentieth Century is a collection of studies on the key episodes of the difficult and often discordant Anglo-French exchange over the past century. The authors

Supreme Command: Soldiers, Statesmen, and Leadership in Wartime

Using the example of great modern leaders - Lincoln, Clemenceau, Churchill and Ben Gurion - all of whom were without military experience, Supreme Command argues that, in fact, civilian statesman can

Haig's Command: A Reassessment

Part 1 Haig's credentials: personal credentials professional credentials. Part 2 The attrition battles of 1916-17: the Somme Passchendaele - the roots, the battle Cambrai. Part 3 The attrition period

Uncovering Lives: The Uneasy Alliance of Biography and Psychology

Part One Why Psychobiography? 1. The Psychologist as Biographer 2. Starting from Scratch Part Two The Heart of the Theorist 3. Freud as Leonardo 4. The Auntification of C. G. Jung 5. Allport Meets

The First World War and British military history

I. Establishing the Historical Foundations II. The Battle of the Memoirs III. Indirect Approaches IV. The Great War Rediscovered