Must reliable signals always be costly?

@article{Smith1994MustRS,
  title={Must reliable signals always be costly?},
  author={J. Maynard Smith},
  journal={Animal Behaviour},
  year={1994},
  volume={47},
  pages={1115-1120}
}
  • J. M. Smith
  • Published 1 May 1994
  • Economics
  • Animal Behaviour
Abstract Abstract. It has previously been shown that, in some circumstances, animal signals can be a reliable guide to the state of the signaller only if the signal is more costly than is needed to convey the information unambiguously. However, an analysis of a simple model, the Philip Sidney game, showed that there are also circumstances in which cost-free signals can be both reliable and evolutionarily stable. The essential requirement for a cost-free signal to be stable is that the two… 

What are conventional signals?

Cheap talk when interests conflict

This paper analyses a game theory model and presents an empirical example indicating that female rhesus macaques, Macaca mulatta, use honest, low-cost, vocal signals to facilitate interactions when conflicts of interest exist.

The validity of the handicap principle in discrete action-response games

Abstract The validity of the handicap principle has spawned much debate in spite of the existence of a formal treatment. Simple models constructed to further investigate the issue were able both to

Signalling among relatives. II. Beyond the tower of Babel.

This paper proves that in a general Sir Philip Sidney game, any partition of signallers into equi-signalling classes can have a stable signalling equilibrium if and only if it is a contiguous partition, and provides examples of such partitions.

The cost of dishonesty

  • H. Viljugrein
  • Economics
    Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences
  • 1997
It is argued that honest signalling may be maintained although the used signals are not handicaps, and a game theoretic model in the form of a game of signalling is presented: all the existing evolutionarily stable strategies (ESS) are found.

Animal Signals: Models and Terminology

Three classifications of signals are discussed, based on the type of information that they convey, the relationship between their form and that of the object, being signalled about, and the processes that maintain the reliability of the signal.

Signalling among relatives. I. Is costly signalling too costly

It is demonstrated that despite the benefits associated with honest information transfer, the costs incurred in a stable costly signalling system may leave all participants worse off than they would be in a system with no signalling at all.

Communication and Common Interest

Novel computational methods are used to investigate the role of common interest between the sender and receiver of messages in maintaining cost-free informative signaling in a signaling game, employing exact measures of commoninterest, information use, and contingency of payoff that may be applied to a wide range of models and empirical systems.

Efficacy and Honesty in Communication between Relatives

An extended version of Maynard Smith's strategic model of signaling of need between relatives, the Philip Sidney game, is analyzed that incorporates the possibility of perceptual error and shows that even in the presence of noise, there exists over a wide range of parameter values a unique, continuously stable signaling equilibrium.
...