Multiattribute Risk Analysis in Nuclear Emergency Management

  title={Multiattribute Risk Analysis in Nuclear Emergency Management},
  author={Raimo P. H{\"a}m{\"a}l{\"a}inen and Mats R. K. Lindstedt and Kari Sinkko},
  journal={Risk Analysis},
Radiation protection authorities have seen a potential for applying multiattribute risk analysis in nuclear emergency management and planning to deal with conflicting objectives, different parties involved, and uncertainties. This type of approach is expected to help in the following areas: to ensure that all relevant attributes are considered in decision making; to enhance communication between the concerned parties, including the public; and to provide a method for explicitly including risk… 
Agricultural countermeasures in nuclear emergency management: a stakeholders' survey for multi-criteria model development
This paper argues in favour of a systematic interaction with relevant stakeholders in all phases of the decision analysis, aiming to add in stakeholders' values and practical knowledge in the models developed for decision support.
On the Constructive Role of Multi-Criteria Analysis in Nuclear Emergency Management
In this chapter we argue that multi-criteria analysis, as an iterative process, can be a useful instrument for improving decision-making in complex societal problems. As a possible application, we
Making decisions for incident management in nuclear power plants using probabilistic safety assessment
Decisions by management during nuclear power plant operations may have safety-related and economic consequences, and may affect the relationship with external stakeholders such as regulatory
Sensitivity analyses in multi‐attribute decision support for off‐site nuclear emergency and recovery management
Purpose – Emergency situations may differ in many ways but they share some common characteristics, such as the sudden onset and the need to transparently evaluate various usually conflicting
Uncertainty handling in multi-attribute decision support for industrial risk management
A framework for uncertainty handling is proposed on the basis of a structured uncertainty classification, methods based on Monte Carlo simulation can be used for a consistent modelling, propagation and visualisation of the different types of uncertainty.
Preference elicitation and sensitivity analysis in multicriteria group decision support for industrial risk and emergency management
The resolution of complex decision situations in crisis and remediation management following an industrial emergency requires input from different disciplines. Contributing to the transparency and
Decision Evaluation of Response Strategies in Emergency Management Using Imprecise Assessments
The method proposed can be viewed as a more frugal decision analysis method, decreasing the efforts needed in elicitation of input statements which often is a cumbersome threshold for the use of decision analysis techniques.
Nuclear emergency management: Driven by precedent or international guidance?
There is an urgent need to think more widely about nuclear emergency management, and international guidance provided by organisations such as ICRP and IAEA lack the specificity to help decision makers.
25 years of MCDA in nuclear emergency management
Radiation accidents such as those at Three Mile Island, Chernobyl and, more recently, Fukushima have emphasized the need for supporting all phases of emergency management from the early phases in


Multi‐attribute decision support in the event of a nuclear accident
The multi-attribute aspects of decision support, i.e. methods for supporting decisions when there are several conflicting objectives, are discussed, particularly in relation to the incorporation of uncertainty when there is a risk of an imminent accident.
RODOS and decision conferencing on early phase protective actions in Finland
This work was undertaken in order to study the utilisation of decision conferencing and of the RODOS system when considering early phase protective actions in the case of a nuclear accident.
Deliberation: Integrating Analytical Results into Environmental Decisions Involving Multiple Stakeholders
The National Research Council has recommended the use of an analytic/deliberative decision-making process in environmental restoration decisions that involve multiple stakeholders. This work
Nordic Decision Conference: An exercise on clean-up actions in an urban environment after a nuclear accident
The EKO 4/c working group of the environmental effects and emergency preparedness programme (EKO) of the Nordic Nuclear Safety Research (NKS) organised a decision conference on August 30* and 31 st ,
Decision analysis interviews in environmental impact assessment
It is proved that decision analysis interviews can well be used in assessing the importance of environment impacts and is a useful way of improving stakeholders' participation in environmental decision making and it provides a systematic way of dealing with conflicting opinions.
Decision Support Issues in RODOS: The Needs of Decision Makers
RODOS will be used by a great variety of different decision makers from different backgrounds and with different skills and knowledge bases; later, regional and national politicians and government officials will become involved.
Managing Nuclear Waste from Power Plants
National strategies to manage nuclear waste from commercial nuclear power plants are analyzed and compared. The current strategy is to try to operate a repository at Yucca Mountain, Nevada, to
Problem formulation for multi-criteria decision analysis: Report of a workshop
The focus of the workshop was the problem formulation phase which occurs between the analyst meeting a person with a ‘mess’ and the time he or she begins to analyse a structured problem with several alternatives scored against several attributes or criteria.