More Evidence Challenging the Robustness and Usefulness of the Attraction Effect

@article{Yang2014MoreEC,
  title={More Evidence Challenging the Robustness and Usefulness of the Attraction Effect},
  author={Sybil S. Yang and Michael Lynn},
  journal={Journal of Marketing Research},
  year={2014},
  volume={51},
  pages={508 - 513}
}
Ninety-one attempts to produce an attraction effect (involving a total of 23 product classes and 73 different decoyed choice sets) produced only 11 reliable effects—significantly fewer than expected given the statistical power of the studies. Cross-scenario analyses indicated that the use of meaningful qualitative-verbal descriptions, as well as pictorial depictions, to differentiate choice options substantially reduced the size of those effects. Indeed, the authors found attraction effects at… 

The appropriacy of averaging in the study of context effects

TLDR
It is found that individuals displayed qualitative differences in their choice behavior and a tendency for some people to show either the similarity effect or the compromise effect but not both, and many individuals showed strong dimensional biases that were much larger than any effects of context.

Context effects in similarity judgments.

TLDR
This work provides the first direct experimental demonstration of how an attraction effect can give way to a diagnosticity one, as a distractor option is manipulated.

What really matters in attraction effect research: when choices have economic consequences

Researchers have recently strongly questioned the robustness of the attraction effect, according to which adding a decoy option to an existing choice set affects consumers’ choice behavior. Tying in

Inferiority, not similarity of the decoy to target, is what drives the transfer of attention underlying the attraction effect: Evidence from an eye-tracking study with real choices.

  • M. KrólM. Król
  • Psychology
    Journal of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Economics
  • 2019
18 Recent studies reported that the attraction effect, whereby inferior decoys cause choice reversals, 19 fails to replicate if the choice options are presented in a pictorial rather than abstract

On the practical relevance of the attraction effect: A cautionary note and guidelines for context effect experiments

TLDR
An extensive review of the literature on this topic shows that context effect studies have routinely neglected background factors, and proposes guidelines for implementing context effect experiments in future consumer research, which allow for a more realistic analysis of the attraction effect and related context effects in consumer research.

'Three is better than two': Increasing donations with the attraction effect.

TLDR
A clear and consistent pattern emerged: Participants chose the target alternative more frequently and perceived it as more beneficial (and somewhat less costly) when the decoy was present compared to when it was absent.

The attraction effect and its explanations

The Effect of Expected Value on Attraction Effect Preference Reversals

TLDR
This result is used to clarify the implications of the attraction effect, arguing that although it robustly violates the assumptions of value‐maximising models, it does not eliminate the possibility that human decision making is optimal.

The Attraction Effect in Information Visualization

TLDR
The authors' findings indicate that the bias persists for larger sets of alternatives presented as scatterplots, and this could have important implications for future research on how to further study and possibly alleviate the attraction effect.

A unified conceptualization of the attraction effect

This research focuses on the attraction effect, a phenomenon in which the share of the focal alternative (called “target”), relative to a second alternative (called “competitor”), increases when a
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 15 REFERENCES

Decoy effects and attribute-level inferences.

A decoy effect occurs when the addition of an inferior choice alternative changes the preference relations among the other alternatives in the set. Whereas many authors have suggested that the decoy

Animation Attracts: The Attraction Effect in an On-line Shopping Environment.

Two studies examine the attraction effect—an inconsistent choice behavior typically observed when consumers are presented with two products (target and competitor), both good for different reasons,

Comparison-induced decoy effects

TLDR
Quantitative fits revealed that comparison-induced distortion theory provides a better account of this effect than does adaptation-level theory, suggesting that biases created by language-expressible magnitude comparisons mediate the effects of decoys on evaluation.

Asymmetric Decoy Effects on Lower-Quality versus Higher-Quality Brands: Meta-analytic and Experimental Evidence

Prior research demonstrates that adding decoys to choice sets can increase choice shares of brands similar to decoys while reducing shares of brands dissimilar to decoys. Such effects have been

Adding Asymmetrically Dominated Alternatives: Violations of Regularity & the Similarity Hypothesis.

Abstract : An asymmetrically dominated alternative is one that is dominated by one item in the set but not by another. It is shown that the addition to a choice set of such an alternative can

The Attraction Effect and Political Choice in Two Elections

Findings that challenge several normative assumptions of consumer choice have been documented in the literature on the attraction effect. There has been ample previous empirical evidence supporting

The impact of a product’s country-of-origin on compromise and attraction effects

Product information, such as country-of-origin (COO), often influences consumer choice. This research explores how valence of COO influences the magnitude of the compromise and attraction effects.

Brainfluence: 100 Ways to Persuade and Convince Consumers with Neuromarketing

DESCRIPTION Practical techniques for applying neuroscience and behavior research to attract new customers Brainfluence explains how to practically apply neuroscience and behavior research to better

Context-dependent violations of rational choice in honeybees (Apis mellifera) and gray jays (Perisoreus canadensis)

TLDR
It is shown that honeybees and gray jays are also influenced by the addition of an option to a choice set (i.e., by a change in local context), contradict the view that nonhuman animals should be immune to such psychological effects and that they should conform with normative accounts.