Monism vs. pluralism, the global financial crisis, and the methodological struggle in the field of International Political Economy

  title={Monism vs. pluralism, the global financial crisis, and the methodological struggle in the field of International Political Economy},
  author={Joscha Wullweber},
  journal={Competition \& Change},
  pages={287 - 311}
In recent years, a comprehensive debate has been taking place over the ontological, epistemological and methodological roots underlying the discipline of International Political Economy. A fundamental and sometimes fierce discussion arose over the questions of which research strategies should prevail, which methods should be applied and what kind of knowledge counts as scientific. The debate has tended to reduce the different positions and International Political Economy approaches to American… 

Tables from this paper

Pluralism, socioeconomics and de-coloniality
It is a well-known fact that the neoclassical school of thought dominates economic teaching. In order to provide alternatives, develop a pluralistic approach towards the teaching of economics and
Poststructural Research in International Political Economy: Problematizing and Politicizing Agency, Structure and Objectivity
Poststructural research in International Political Economy (IPE) is a relatively young and growing field of studies that includes a variety of in part very diverse theories and approaches. These
Progress, pluralism and science: moving from alienated to engaged pluralism
Abstract The encompassing scale and scope of International Political Economy (IPE) is rare in the social sciences. Our subject matter affects the way our field organizes and produces knowledge: we
Embedded Finance: The Shadow Banking System, Monetary Politics and Sovereign Power
At the beginning of the financial crisis, attempts were made to counteract its effects in line with the rationale of market liberalism. However, after Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy, it became
Embedded finance: the shadow banking system, sovereign power, and a new state–market hybridity
ABSTRACT With the rise of the shadow banking system, a new form of state–market hybridity has emerged, challenging existing monetary approaches to financial stability. A stable financial system today
The COVID-19 Financial Crisis, Global Financial Instabilities and Transformations in the Financial System
The report explains why the financial crisis induced by the COVID-19 outbreak was not an unpredictable black swan event in an otherwise stable system, and demonstrates that where the financial system is concerned, instability is the rule rather than the exception.


Theory is dead, long live theory: The end of the Great Debates and the rise of eclecticism in International Relations
The history of the discipline of International Relations is commonly told in terms of ‘Great Debates.’ These intellectual clashes resolved little and, indeed, continue to this day. Underneath this
International theory: positivism and beyond: The accomplishments of international political economy
Introduction International political economy (IPE) is concerned with the political determinants of international economic relations. It tries to answer questions such as: How have changes in the
Beyond empire and terror: critical reflections on the political economy of world order
The 10th anniversary is a significant marker in the history of this Centre, the more so since both the study of political economy and the world it contemplates have been undergoing major changes
The slow death of pluralism
ABSTRACT In this essay, I draw attention to what I see as a slow death of theoretical, methodological and empirical pluralism in American-school international political economy (IPE). In the first
International Organization and the Study of World Politics
A distinct subfield of international relations, IPE, has emerged over the last thirty years, largely in the pages of International Organization . IPE began with the study of international political
International Political Economy: A Tale of Two Heterodoxies
International political economy (IPE) originated in the early 1970s. For almost 20 years it has been dominated by separate, largely non-communicating schools, one centred on scholarly institutions in
Political Economy, the ‘US School’, and the Manifest Destiny of Everyone Else
B.J. Cohen's "British school" of theories of international political economy has much broader, classical and European origins and is much broader than he portrays. The "US school" identified by Cohen
Introduction: The International Diffusion of Liberalism
Political scientists, sociologists, and economists have all sought to analyze the spread of economic and political liberalism across countries in recent decades. This article documents this diffusion
The Political Economy of International Relations.
After the end of World War II, the United States, by far the dominant economic and military power at that time, joined with the surviving capitalist democracies to create an unprecedented
The Political Economy of Monetary Institutions
In recent decades, countries have experimented with a variety of monetary institutions, including alternative exchange-rate arrangements and different levels of central bank independence. Political