Models as speech acts: the telling case of financial models

  title={Models as speech acts: the telling case of financial models},
  author={Nicolas Brisset},
  journal={Journal of Economic Methodology},
  pages={21 - 41}
  • N. Brisset
  • Published 2 January 2018
  • Sociology
  • Journal of Economic Methodology
Abstract This paper intends to bring Austinian themes into methodological discussion about models. Using Austinian conceptual vocabulary, I argue that models perform actions in and outside of the academic field. This multiplicity of fields induces a variety of felicity conditions and types of performed actions. If for example, an inference from a model is judged according to some epistemological criteria in the scientific field, the representation of the world which the model carries will not… 
The model (also) in the world: extending the sociological theory of fields to economic models
ABSTRACT The goal of this paper is to provide a methodological perspective on economic models that accounts for some sociological dimensions of economics, in two senses. Firstly, we are interested in
Samuelson vs Fama on the Efficient Market Hypothesis: The Point of View of Expertise
This paper investigates the polysemic character of the Efficient Market Hypothesis through a comparison of the contributions of the two authors who introduced this hypothesis in 1965, Eugene Fama and
Financial Black Swans: Unpredictable Threat or Descriptive Illusion?
This chapter discusses the threat posed by rare but high-impact events in finance: serious market crashes or financial meltdowns, such as the crisis of 2008. These crises have been metaphorically
When efficient market hypothesis meets Hayek on information: beyond a methodological reading
ABSTRACT Hayek and the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) are often seen as proposing a similar theory of prices. Hayek is seen as proposing to understand prices as information conveyer, incorporating
Why Finance Needs Philosophy (and Vice Versa): Some Epistemic and Methodological Issues
As the world economy has for better or worse become more and more dependent on the financial markets, a rethinking of the role of finance in both theory and practice is necessary. I argue that such a
Models and Data in Finance: les Liaisons Dangereuses
  • E. Ippoliti
  • Business
    Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Technology
  • 2019
In my paper, I examine the role that models play, and the relation between models and data, in financial systems, in particular in stock markets. I discuss several dangerous liaisons between models
A Short Walk on the Wild Side: Agent-Based Models and their Implications for Macroeconomic Analysis
I discuss recent advances in agent-based modelling applied to macroeconomic analysis. I first present the building blocks of agent- based models. Furthermore, by relying on examples taken from recent
Efficient Market Hypothesis, Eugene Fama and Paul Samuelson: A reevaluation
Two main claims are associated with the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH). First of all, the price changes are nearly random in the financial markets. Secondly, the prices reflect the economic
Exploitative Abuse and Abuse of Economic Dependence: What Can We Learn from the Industrial Organization Approach?
This article conducts a detailed analysis of the concept of economic dependence and exploitative abuse based on how their treatment in competition law and economics and their enforcement in European
On the Roots of the Intrinsic Value of Decision Rights: Evidence from France and Japan
Bartling, Fehr and Herz (2014) found that Swiss individuals attach an economically meaningful intrinsic value to make a decision by themselves rather than delegating it to another person. We refine


Models in Economics Are Not (Always) Nomological Machines
This paper evaluates Nancy Cartwright’s critique of economic models. Cartwright argues that economics fails to build relevant “nomological machines” able to isolate capacities. In this paper, I
  • N. Brisset
  • Economics
    Journal of the History of Economic Thought
  • 2017
The issue of performativity concerns the claim that economics shape rather than merely describe the social world. This idea took hold following a paper by Donald MacKenzie and Yuval Millo entitled
The explanation paradox redux
I respond to some challenges raised by my critics. In particular, I argue in favour of six claims. First, against Alexandrova and Northcott, I point out that to deny the explanatoriness of economic
Pataphysics of finance: An essay of visual epistemology
Since the economic crisis of 2008, numerous observers have called into question the way that financial knowledge deals with economic reality. In this challenging context, the time has come to embark
Economics is not always performative: some limits for performativity
The phenomenon of performativity has recently sparked debates about the status of the economic discourse. This paper aims to discuss the subjectivist idea that if economics ‘performs’ (shapes) social
MISSing the World. Models as Isolations and Credible Surrogate Systems
This article shows how the MISS account of models—as isolations and surrogate systems—accommodates and elaborates Sugden and Hausman's accounts of models as explorations and models as credible worlds.
The World in the Model
During the last two centuries, the way economic science is done has changed radically: it has become a social science based on mathematical models in place of words. This book describes and analyses
Virtue, Fortune, and Faith: A Genealogy of Finance
International finance is often understood to be a rational practice, taking place within an autonomous, coherent and clearly bounded structure. This thesis questions the naturalness implied by such
The World in the Model: Figures, Tables, and Boxes
Where do Analysts Come from? The Case of Financial Chartism
probabilistic models of price movements were developed preponderantly in France, which – and this is a significant element – did not have a price recording technology comparable to the ticker. (In