Model and representation: the effect of visual feedback on human performance in a color picker interface

@article{Douglas1999ModelAR,
  title={Model and representation: the effect of visual feedback on human performance in a color picker interface},
  author={Sarah A. Douglas and Arthur E. Kirkpatrick},
  journal={ACM Trans. Graph.},
  year={1999},
  volume={18},
  pages={96-127}
}
User interfaces for color selection consist of a visible screen representation, an input method, and the underlying conceptual organization of the color model. We report a two-way factorial, between-subjects variable experiment that tested the effect of high and low visual feedback interfaces on speed and accuracy of color matching for RGB and HSV color models. The only significant effect was improved accuracy due to increased visual feedback. Using color groups as a within-subjects variable… 

An intuitive color-selection tool

TLDR
This paper argues that it is not the color space per se that is the most important factor underlying the usability of a colorselection tool but rather the color-mixing algorithm, and shows that users are better able to predict the results of subtractive color mixing than they are additive color mixing.

Color-in-fist: a metaphor for color selection with mid-air interaction

TLDR
A mid-air interaction metaphor for color selection was proposed which enabled users to select hue, saturation and lightness simultaneously using mutually independent and intuitive hand motions and showed that the metaphor improved the efficiency of color selection with mid- air interaction.

Colour appearance shifts in two different-sized viewing conditions

This study assessed the effect of size on colour appearance, using a colour matching paradigm where two sizes were presented in a setting similar to a normal colour selection interface. Twelve

An Image-Based Visual Strategy for Working with Color Contrasts During Design

TLDR
A visual framework for working with color contrasts is presented, the foreground and background colors are detected automatically, and views are presented to simulate how a design is viewed with different levels of reduced vision.

Color Search and Replace

We present an interactive image enhancement technique to adjust the global color composition of an image by finding and replacing color gradients. We show how color gradient transformations can

Color Picking

TLDR
The most efficient color picker, which is presently rarely used in popular applications, is much more efficient than the worst one, and it is speculated that this derives from a closer match to the user’s internal representation of color space.

Effectiveness of Color-Picking Interfaces Among Non-designers

TLDR
The results indicate that the palette, map and RGB color pickers found in entry level software probably are the most suitable for users without training in the use of colors.

A Comparison of Five HSV Color Selection Interfaces for Mobile Painting Search

TLDR
Which color palette(s) enable users to complete task faster, how good these resulting drawings were for searching, and what were user experiences are investigated.

Data-Driven Color Manifolds

TLDR
This work shows how color selection usability improves by applying 1D or 2D color manifolds that predict the most likely change of color in a specific context, and demonstrates the increase in task performance of color selection in a user study.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 35 REFERENCES

The Effect of Feedback on a Color Selection Interface

TLDR
Qualitative analysis of the individual matches suggests that feedback assisted users most in their final refinements to the match.

Do color models really make a difference?

TLDR
It is suggested that feedback may be an important factor in usability of a color selection interface using an interface with high levels of feedback and found that increasing feedback improved accuracy of matching.

An experimental comparison of RGB, YIQ, LAB, HSV, and opponent color models

TLDR
A color matching experiment in which subjects used one of two tablet-based input techniques, interfaced through one of five color models, to interactively match target colors displayed on a CRT shows small but significant differences between models in the ability of subjects to match the five target colors.

A human factors study of color notation systems for computer graphics

TLDR
It was found that users of the natural language based system were significantly more accurate in specifying colors, despite the coarse granularity of that system as compared to the other two.

User-oriented color interface design: direct manipulation of color in context

TLDR
Color tools based on a uniform perceptual color space that account for the relativity of color are described and color interface ideas based on such user-oriented color models and approaches are suggested.

Color gamut transform pairs

TLDR
A set of alternative models of the RGB monitor gamut based on the perceptual variables hue, saturation, and value (V) or brightness (L) are presented and algorithms for transforming between these models are derived.

Illumination and Color in Computer Generated Imagery

  • R. Hall
  • Art
    Monographs in Visual Communication
  • 1989
In a very broad sense the historical development of computer graphics can be considered in three phases, each a giant step down the road towards "realistic" computer generated images. The first,

Integrality and separability of input devices

TLDR
The theory of processing of percetual structure is extended to graphical interactive tasks and to the control structure of input devices to help predict task and device combinations that lead to better performance and confirm the importance of matching the perceptual structure of the task and the control structures of the input device.

HWB - A More Intuitive Hue-Based Color Model

TLDR
It is explained that whitening is not the opposite of blackening, and a closely related model, HWB (Hue-Whiteness-Blackness), is introduced that avoids the flaws, is slightly faster to compute, and is very easy to teach to new users.

The free classification of analyzable and unanalyzable stimuli

TLDR
The free classification of two-dimensional analyzable and unanalyzable stimuli was investigated and the results replicated previous work in showing that the city-block metric was appropriate for the analyzables stimuli and that the euclidean metric wasappropriate for unanalyZable stimuli.