Mobilizing metaphors: the popular use of keystone, flagship and umbrella species concepts

  title={Mobilizing metaphors: the popular use of keystone, flagship and umbrella species concepts},
  author={Maan Barua},
  journal={Biodiversity and Conservation},
  • M. Barua
  • Published 26 March 2011
  • Biology
  • Biodiversity and Conservation
Misrepresentation of terminology is a major impediment for attempts at enhancing public conservation literacy. Despite being critically important for improving conservation practice, there have been few systematic analyses of the popular use of conservation terminology. This paper draws from science communication studies and metaphor analysis, to examine how keystone, flagship and umbrella species concepts are used and represented in non-academic contexts. 557 news articles containing these… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

‘Wise contrarians’: a keystone species in contemporary climate science, politics and policy
In the 1980s, celebrity climate contrarians, which we might understand as a kind of ‘keystone species’ or ‘charismatic megafauna’, emerged through resistance to dominant interpretations of scientificExpand
Flagships or Battleships: Deconstructing the Relationship between Social Conflict and Conservation Flagship Species
Flagship species, common components of conservation programs, are frequently implicated in social confl icts. Th is article examines the multiple roles of fl agships in confl icts including theirExpand
The twenty most charismatic species
A concrete list of the most charismatic species is provided and insights into the Western public’s perception of charismatic species are offered, both of which could be helpful to target new species for conservation campaigns. Expand
Why is it Important to Use Flagship Species in Community Education? The Koala as a Case Study
Our paper investigates the conservation and planning implications of the use of an individual flagship species. The koala was chosen, as an example, in a community education intervention in aExpand
Mobilizing Cathedral Metaphors: The Case of ‘Sacred Space, Common Ground’
A range of metaphors has been mobilized to enliven the discourse of cathedral scholarship. Such imaginative terms can also stimulate theory and empirical investigation around the function of iconicExpand
What’s in a name? A content analysis of environmental NGOs’ use of “iconic species” in press releases
There are many designations people give to species in the context of conservation, some ecological (e.g., umbrella, keystone) and some cultural (e.g., flagship). However, “iconic” is a term with usesExpand
A case study of a conservation flagship species: the monarch butterfly
What makes a flagship species effective in engaging conservation donors? Large, charismatic mammals are typically selected as ambassadors, but a few studies suggest butterflies—and monarchs inExpand
Conservation inequality and the charismatic cat: Felis felicis
Conservation resources are limited, making it impossible to invest equally in all threatened species. One way to maximise conservation gains is to focus upon those species with particular publicExpand
Selecting flagships for invertebrate conservation
Empirical evidence is provided that butterflies appeal to diverse audiences and have the potential to be deployed as flagships in different contexts, and a set of heuristic guidelines for selecting flagships to raise awareness of invertebrate diversity and conservation. Expand
Prawns, justice, and relationships of care in Stilbaai, South Africa
This story is concerned with the intersection of governance, stewardship, care taking, and extraction. It is centred on insights gained through repeated encounters with bait prawns during 7 yearsExpand


Language fouls in teaching ecology: why traditional metaphors undermine conservation literacy.
Examination of four frequently used ecology and environmental studies textbooks considered the ways in which commonly used language can obscure or enhance an understanding of ecology and conservation and used the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis and framing theory to examine the approaches reflected in these texts. Expand
Preliminary assessment of the flagship species concept at a small scale
Since these classic Latin American flagship species fail to encompass particularly high numbers or abundances of vertebrate species at a local scale, they appear to be a poor conservation tool when co-opted as umbrella species for delineating the location of very small reserves in the neotropics. Expand
Metaphor, Morality, and Politics Or, Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust 1
[This is an early and much abbreviated discussion of the themes in my book Moral Politics.] In Social Research, vol 62, no. 2 (summer 1995) Metaphor, Morality, and Politics Or, Why Conservatives HaveExpand
Conversations in conservation: revealing and dealing with language differences in environmental conflicts
1. Applied ecology aims to translate research into policy recommendations. However, conflicts frequently develop if these recommendations propose a contentious course of action. A first step towardsExpand
Flagship species on covers of US conservation and nature magazines
It is found that magazines tend to use mammal and bird species rather than invertebrate, fish, amphibian, reptile or plant taxa on their covers, confirming anecdotal observations about conservation organizations focusing their publicity and programmes on large, charismatic species to raise awareness and funds. Expand
Metaphors We Live By
People use metaphors every time they speak. Some of those metaphors are literary - devices for making thoughts more vivid or entertaining. But most are much more basic than that - they're "metaphorsExpand
Flagships, umbrellas, and keystones: Is single-species management passé in the landscape era?
The recognition that some ecosystems have keystone species whose activities govern the well-being of many other species suggests an approach that may unite the best features of single-species and ecosystem management. Expand
The Sociopolitical Dimensions of Wolf Management and Restoration in the United States
This article examines the political cultural context and sociopolitical dimensions of wolf management and restoration in the United States. Drawing on the experiences of various wolf programsExpand
‘Natural disasters’ and newspapers: Post-tsunami environmental discourse
Abstract In this paper we explore the concept of ‘natural disasters’ as opportunities for influencing public perceptions of the environment through the media. We provide a critical analysis of theExpand
A Critical Review of Assumptions About the Prairie Dog as a Keystone Species
It is confirmed that prairie dogs affect a number of ecosystem-level functions but that their influence on prairie vertebrates may be less than previously suggested, and some prairie dog functions are quite large compared to other herbivores in the system. Expand