Mobile User Experience in Augmented Reality vs. Maps Interfaces: A Case Study in Public Transportation

@inproceedings{Kamilakis2016MobileUE,
  title={Mobile User Experience in Augmented Reality vs. Maps Interfaces: A Case Study in Public Transportation},
  author={Manousos Kamilakis and Damianos Gavalas and Christos D. Zaroliagis},
  booktitle={AVR},
  year={2016}
}
This article comprises a study on user experience when interacting with different modes of mobile interfaces. Our emphasis is on application instances commonly found in mobile app stores, which utilize sensor-based augmented reality or two-dimensional zoomable maps to visualize points of interest (POIs) in the vicinity of the user. As a case study, we developed two variants of an Android application addressed to public transportation users. The application displays nearby transit stops along… 
Advances in Mobile Augmented Reality from User Experience Perspective: A Review of Studies
TLDR
This study aims to present a comprehensive and detailed review of the advances in mobile augmented reality from UX perspective and will help in guiding the developers of MAR to focus on areas that need improvement.
Measuring User Experience of Mobile Augmented Reality Systems Through Non-instrumental Quality Attributes
TLDR
This paper surveys the development and advancements in MAR from UX viewpoint, and a systematic study on measuring user aesthetics as non-instrumental quality attributes to measure the UX for existing MAR applications is presented.
Visualization of Environment-related Information in Augmented Reality: Analysis of User Needs
TLDR
The findings suggest that the way in which information is presented to pilots should be chosen based on the category of the information, namely, whether it is terrain-related or flight-related, and showed that future AR applications should be designed to be transferable between different platforms: glasses, mobile phones, and tablets.
Natural interaction with large map interfaces in VR
TLDR
A preliminary investigation into how interaction with such very large display interfaces can take place, using a virtual reality headset as the sole input and interaction method is presented.
Enhancing cultural heritage outdoor experience with augmented-reality smart glasses
TLDR
An augmented reality smart glasses (ARSG)-based mobile guide with location and orientation-based functionalities that provided visitors with context-aware information regarding the points of interest (POIs) in their field of view (FOV) was developed and compared with a more conventional smartphone-based guide.
Usability Testing of Mobile Augmented Reality Applications for Cultural Heritage - A Systematic Literature Review
TLDR
An overview of the existing literature to date regarding the usability testing of Mobile Augmented Reality applications developed for cultural heritage, and the perceived ease of use, usefulness and enjoyment were confirmed by a majority of the papers.
Interacting with large maps using HMDs in VR settings
TLDR
This paper presents a preliminary investigation into how interaction with such very large display maps can take place, using a virtual reality headset as the sole input and interaction method.
Audio augmented reality in public transport for exploring tourist sites
TLDR
This work presents the design, development, and usability evaluation of AudioTransit, an audio AR tour guide using the public transport network for exploring urban tourist sites with which the design and implementation of audio AR systems in tourism are investigated.
Android-Based Augmented Reality in Education Activity for Children
TLDR
An android application to introduce the types of land transportation based on augmented reality technology which is visualized in 3-dimensional (3D) form for education as well as entertainment is proposed.
Using immersive video technology for construction management content delivery: a pilot study
TLDR
A pilot experiment where a combination of 360, 180 3D, and flat videos was incorporated as an educational instrument in delivering construction management content shows a positive perception toward using immersive videos in construction education.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 11 REFERENCES
User evaluation of mobile augmented reality scenarios
TLDR
An online survey for evaluating the user acceptance of five different mobile AR scenarios, as well as for understanding the potential and risks or mobile AR in general, shows ambivalent attitudes towards mobile AR services and implies that the scenarios demonstrating pragmatic relevance were valued over pleasure oriented ones.
Towards designing better map interfaces for the mobile: experiences from example
TLDR
This paper discusses lessons learnt from designing and implementing mobile map interfaces through two examples: tourist maps and traffic maps, and discusses the rendering, user interaction, and system adaptations required.
Adaptation to Context — A Way to Improve the Usability of Mobile Maps
TLDR
The purpose of the evaluation was to identify preliminary design principles for maps on small displays, as well as the main benefits and obstacles in using topographic maps on mobile devices, and the mobile contexts relevant for topographic mobile maps were identified.
A Study of User Perception, Interface Performance, and Actual Usage of Mobile Pedestrian Navigation Aides
TLDR
A study to compare actual usage of navigation tools against user perception of the tools and performance with the tools in a series of wayfinding tasks indicates that independent surveys can align well with extreme cases while performance may not actually be a good indicator of usage preferences.
Navigating maps with little or no sight: An audio-tactile approach
TLDR
A novel audio-tactile methodology is described, and the results from its pilot study reported, which integrates speech, verbal landmarks, earcons and recorded environmental sound to build a small spatial hypermedia system.
Smartphone Augmented Reality Applications for Tourism
TLDR
An overview of current smartphone AR applications outlining tourism-related domain-specific design challenges is presented, aiming at developing a better understanding of the design space for smartphone context-aware AR applications for tourists.
Pedestrian navigation with augmented reality, voice and digital map: final results from an in situ field study assessing performance and user experience
TLDR
In the context of GPS-enhanced pedestrian navigation, digital map and voice-only interfaces lead to significantly better navigation performance and user experience in comparison to AR interfaces, leading to the conclusion that AR is still suffering from usability and hardware issues leading to higher uncertainty of navigating persons.
Augmented reality technologies, systems and applications
TLDR
Challenges augmented reality is facing in each of these applications to go from the laboratories to the industry, as well as the future challenges the authors can forecast are also discussed in this paper.
Tactile Wayfinder: Comparison of Tactile Waypoint Navigation with Commercial Pedestrian Navigation Systems
TLDR
It is found that the Tactile Wayfinder freed the participants' attention but could not keep up with the navigation system in terms of navigation performance, and no significant difference was found in the acquisition of spatial knowledge.
A Mixed Reality Interface for Real Time Tracked Public Transportation
TLDR
This work presents work towards full mixed reality interfaces, where virtual vehicles are a) embedded in a mobile 3D map, depicting a real city, and b) visualized directly with augmented reality on top of a real world view.
...
...