Mixed quantitative/qualitative method for evaluating compromise solutions to conflicts in collaborative design

  title={Mixed quantitative/qualitative method for evaluating compromise solutions to conflicts in collaborative design},
  author={Dennis R. Bahler and Catherine Dupont and James Bowen},
  journal={Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing},
  pages={325 - 336}
  • D. Bahler, C. Dupont, J. Bowen
  • Published 1 September 1995
  • Computer Science
  • Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing
Abstract Conflicts are likely to arise among participants in a collaborative design process as the inevitable outgrowth of the differing perspectives and viewpoints involved. The opportunities for conflict are magnified if many perspectives are brought to bear on a common artifact early in the design process, as in concurrent engineering or integrated engineering. Design advice tools can assist in the process of resolving these conflicts by making critiques and suggestions conveniently… 
Formalizing Negotiation in Engineering Design
A more comprehensive justification is presented here of the approach to modelling imprecision known as the Method of Imprecision, or MoI, than has previously been offered.
Collaborative design using solution spaces
Constraints arise naturally in many fields of engineering and are therefore suited to formally express project requirements and, when project descriptions in terms of constraints are available, constraint satisfaction techniques such as consistency can be employed to provide computational support during collaboration.
Conflict management in closely coupled collaborative design system
In this paper, an integration-based conflict resolution system (ICRS) is put forward to manage and resolve conflict in a life cycle way and an example is presented to illustrate the process of conflict resolution.
Conflict Management in Collaborative Engineering Design: Basic Research in Fundamental Theory, Modeling Framework, and Computer Support for Collaborative Engineering Activities
The objective of this work was to develop the Theory for Collaboration in support of complex engineering system decisions in a highly distributed and heterogeneous environment.
Constraint-Based Support for Collaboration in Design and Construction
The writers suggest the use of constraint solving to express possibly large families of acceptable solutions in order to facilitate and abbreviate the negotiation process.
Increasing Understanding During Collaboration Through Advanced Representations
An environment which has been specifically designed for multiple ways to represent and manipulate information is presented and the combination of a flexible framework with more rigid modules, such as constraint solvers, provides a useful compromise and, thus, comprehensive support for a range of AEC projects.
The nature and scope of informal negotiation in engineering is explored and discussed, and application of the MoI is illustrated with an example.
A Generic Architecture for Intelligent Networked Colocation in Concurrent Engineering
A generalized form of constraint network is identified and developed, together with companion reasoning methods, as an elegant and powerful technique that can be used as an enabling technology for Concurrent Engineering.
In conventional building design projects architects make pre-design and conceptual design decisions on buildings and hand these down to structural and building services engineers to follow up with
Collision Detection and Conflict Solution Research in Modern Collaborative Design
It is inevitable that there are conflicts in the process of coordination design, and with the solution to a series of conflicts, a better project will be designed.


Mediating Conflict in Concurrent Engineering with a Protocol Based on Utility
A protocol is described, based on the use of economic utility, by which constraint-based design advice systems can recognize conflict, and support and mediate negotiation fairly, and it is believed they are a good basis for building such design advice tools.
An Axiomatic Approach that Supports Negotiated Resolution of Design Conflicts in Concurrent Engineering
A protocol is described by which design advice systems can recognize conflict, and support and mediate negotiation fairly, and Constraint-based languages provide a convenient representation of real-world problems like those encountered in concurrent engineering.
Frames, quantification, perspectives, and negotiation in constraint networks for life-cycle engineering
Toward a Knowledge Medium for Collaborative Product Development
The framework is designed to support information sharing and coordinated communication among members of a product development organization, particularly for the tasks of design knowledge capture, dynamic notification of design changes, and active management of design dependencies.
Decisions with Multiple Objectives
Many of the complex problems faced by decision makers involve multiple conflicting objectives. This book describes how a confused decision maker, who wishes to make a reasonable and responsible
A computational market model for distributed configuration design
  • Michael P. Wellman
  • Economics
    Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing
  • 1995
Despite known shortcomings and limited explorations thus far, the market model offers a useful conceptual viewpoint for analyzing distributed design problems.
Multiagent Compromise via Negotiation
  • K. Sycara
  • Computer Science
    Distributed Artificial Intelligence
  • 1989
Constraint logic and its applications in production: an implementation using the Galileo4 language and system
This chapter presents a constraint-based approach to making the full First-Order Predicate Calculus available for knowledge representation purposes in intelligent networked colocation advice systems for concurrent engineering.
PACT: an experiment in integrating concurrent engineering systems
The Palo Alto Collaborative Testbed (PACT), a concurrent engineering infrastructure that encompasses multiple sites, subsystems, and disciplines, is discussed and PACT's agent-based architecture and lessons learned from the PACT experiments are described.
The Redux' server
  • C. Petrie
  • Computer Science
    [1993] Proceedings International Conference on Intelligent and Cooperative Information Systems
  • 1993
Redux' servers are proposed as a mechanism for federating heterogeneous design agents by encapsulating their design decisions within a simple model and providing coordination services, especially for design revision.