• Corpus ID: 2826715

Minkowski space-time: A glorious non-entity

  title={Minkowski space-time: A glorious non-entity},
  author={Harvey R. Brown and Oliver Pooley},
  journal={arXiv: History and Philosophy of Physics},
  • H. Brown, O. Pooley
  • Published 17 March 2004
  • Philosophy
  • arXiv: History and Philosophy of Physics
It is argued that Minkowski space-time cannot serve as the deep structure within a ``constructive'' version of the special theory of relativity, contrary to widespread opinion in the philosophical community. 

Why Spacetime Is Not a Hidden Cause: A Realist Story

Spacetime realism requires that it is not hidden and not a cause. Its style of explanation is geometrical. It is argued that causal explanation is unworkable for cases of pure gravitation. Non-causal

The Rich Structure of Minkowski Space

Minkowski Space is the simplest four-dimensional Lorentzian Manifold, being globally flat, and hence the simplest model of spacetime – from a General-Relativistic point of view. But this does not

A Pre-History of Quantum Gravity: The Seventeenth Century Legacy and the Deep Metaphysics of Space beyond Substantivalism and Relationism

This essay demonstrates the inadequacy of contemporary substantivalist and relationist interpretations of quantum gravity hypotheses via an historical investigation of the debate on the underlying

General-Relativistic Covariance

  • N. Dewar
  • Physics
    Foundations of Physics
  • 2019
This is an essay about general covariance, and what it says (or doesn’t say) about spacetime structure. After outlining a version of the dynamical approach to spacetime theories, and how it struggles

Do Time-Asymmetric Laws call for Time-Asymmetric Spacetime Structure?

Abstract Many philosophers of physics take the failure of the laws of physics to be invariant under the time reversal transformation to give us good reason to think that spacetime is temporally

The Dynamical Approach to Spacetime Theories

We review the dynamical approach to spacetime theories---in particular, (a) its origins in the development of special relativity, (b) its opposition to the contemporary `geometrical' approach, and

The primacy of geometry

The Constructivist's Programme and the Problem of Pregeometry

Prominently, Norton (2008) argues against constructivism about spacetime theories, the doctrine that spatiotemporal structure in the dynamics only has derivative status. Among other things, he

Special Relativity and Spacetime

In this chapter Cosgrove subjects the concept of Minkowski spacetime to critique in three principal respects: (1) the theory of spacetime articulates no clear meaning to the concept of a single

Did the concepts of space and time change that much with the 1905 theory of relativity

The advent of the 1905 theory of relativity is rightly considered as a breakthrough moment in the history of physics; in particular. it is widely accepted that it brought a new conception of space



Lorentz contraction and dimensionality of reality

The purpose of this paper is to show that the Lorentz contraction of a rod is possible only if the rod’s world path is a real four-dimensional object. This result demonstrates that special relativity

Geometry as a Branch of Physics

Is space really curved? That is a question which, in one form or another, is raised again and again by philosophers, scientists, T. C. Mits and readers of the weekly comic supplements. A question

The timelessness of quantum gravity: I. The evidence from the classical theory

The issue of time is addressed. It is argued that time as such does not exist but that instants, defined as complete relative configurations of the universe, do. It is shown how the classical

Presentism and relativity

In this critical notice we argue against William Craig's recent attempt to reconcile presentism (roughly, the view that only the present is real) with relativity theory. Craig's defense of his

The origin of the spacetime metric: Bell's `Lorentzian pedagogy' and its significance in general relativity

The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the `Lorentzian Pedagogy' defended by J.S. Bell in his essay ``How to teach special relativity'', and to explore its consistency with Einstein's thinking from

On the reality of space-time geometry and the wavefunction

The action-reaction principle (AR) is examined in three contexts: (1) the inertial-gravitational interaction between a particle and space-time geometry, (2) protective observation of an extended wave

On the role of special relativity in general relativity

Abstract The existence of a definite tangent space structure (metric with Lorentzian signature) in the general theory of relativity is the consequence of a fundamental assumption concerning the local

Correspondence, Invariance and Heuristics in the Emergence of Special Relativity

“It is particularly interesting to point to progress in science towards new, better theories, entirely guided by factors internal to the old theory.” In his provocative 1971 essay on the ‘rationale’

Relativity, the Fitzgerald-Lorentz Contraction, and Quantum Theory

The paper reviews former contentions of the writer to the effect that in the realm of classical physics, at any rate, the Michelson-Morley experiment has an illusory significance in relation to the

The End of Time : The Next Revolution in Our Understanding of the Universe

Time is an illusion. Although the laws of physics create a powerful impression that time is flowing, in fact there are only timeless 'nows'. In The End of Time, the British theoretical physicist