Methods for Combining and Representing Non-Contextual Autonomy Scores for Unmanned Aerial Systems

  title={Methods for Combining and Representing Non-Contextual Autonomy Scores for Unmanned Aerial Systems},
  author={Brendan Hertel and Ryan Donald and Christian Dumas and Seyed Reza Ahmadzadeh},
  journal={2022 8th International Conference on Automation, Robotics and Applications (ICARA)},
Measuring an overall autonomy score for a robotic system requires the combination of a set of relevant aspects and features of the system that might be measured in different units, qualitative, and/or discordant. In this paper, we build upon an existing non-contextual autonomy framework that measures and combines the Autonomy Level and the Component Performance of a system as an overall autonomy score. We examine several methods of combining features, showing how some methods find different… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Contextual Autonomy Evaluation of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles in Subterranean Environments

A fuzzy framework for calculating the autonomy score for a small Unmanned Aerial Systems (sUAS) for performing a task while considering task complexity and environmental factors and introduces a predictive measure which improves upon previous predictive measures, allowing for previous real-world task performance to be used in predicting future mission performance.

Evaluation of Navigation and Trajectory-following Capabilities of Small Unmanned Aerial Systems

Use cases for Small Unmanned Aerial Systems (sUAS) have expanded significantly over the past few years. One use case that is relevant to both civilian and defense missions is reliable operation in



Development of a non-contextual model for determining the autonomy level of intelligent unmanned systems

A simple, quantitative measure for encapsulating the autonomous capabilities of unmanned systems (UMS) has yet to be established and using a high level framework for UMS architectures, such a model for determining a level of autonomy has been developed.


A new model for measuring UGV autonomy level was developed, which provides a predictive measure of a UGV's ability to perform autonomously rather than a retrospective assessment of UGV performance.

Levels of autonomy and autonomous system performance assessment for intelligent unmanned systems

The report is meant to be an extensive review of all past and ongoing efforts to define autonomy and set levels of autonomy for unmanned systems as related to military applications.

Metrics, Schmetrics! How The Heck Do You Determine A UAV's Autonomy Anyway

This paper covers the agreed metrics (an extension of the OODA - observe, orient, decide, and act - loop) as well as the precursors, "dead-ends", and out-and-out flops investigated to get there.

A review of the concept of autonomy in the context of the safety regulation of civil unmanned aircraft systems.

Civil aviation safety regulations and guidance mate- rial classify Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) as ei- ther Remotely-Piloted Aircraft Systems (RPAS) or Autonomous Aircraft Systems (AAS). This

Add or Multiply? A Tutorial on Ranking and Choosing with Multiple Criteria

This paper presents simple additive weighting in a nontechnical way and illustrates its use with data on business schools and finds that the multiplicative approach also has advantages when aggregating the ratings of panel members.

Autonomy levels for unmanned systems framework; volume I: Terminology

  • NIST Special Publication:
  • 2004