Meta-Analytic Review of Responsiveness-To- Intervention Research: Examining Field-Based and Research-Implemented Models

  title={Meta-Analytic Review of Responsiveness-To- Intervention Research: Examining Field-Based and Research-Implemented Models},
  author={Matthew K. Burns and James Appleton and Jonathan D. Stehouwer},
  journal={Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment},
  pages={381 - 394}
A responsiveness-to-intervention (RTI) approach to diagnosing LD is a leading alter native to current practice. This study con ducted a meta-analytic review of research on four existing large-scale RTI models and other models implemented for research. Twenty-four effect sizes and unbiased esti mates of effect (UEE) were computed. Results found a larger UEE for studies of existing RTI models than those implemented by university faculty for research, but both were strong. The UEE for student… Expand

Tables from this paper

Comparison of Existing Responsiveness-To-Intervention Models to Identify and Answer Implementation Questions
Responsiveness-to-intervention (RTI) is the front-running candidate to replace current practice in diagnosing learning disabilities, but researchers have identified several questions aboutExpand
Development and Initial Validation of a Scale Measuring the Beliefs of Educators Regarding Response to Intervention
This article presents information on the development and initial validation of the 16-item Response to Intervention (RTI) Beliefs Scale. The scale is designed to measure the extent to which educatorsExpand
Understanding Inadequate Response to First-Grade Multi-Tier Intervention
Findings from qualitative observations of intervention sessions suggest inadequate responders demonstrated physical and verbal task avoidance and displayed emotions of hopelessness and shame. Expand
Reviewing the Roots of Response to Intervention: Is There Enough Research to Support the Promise?.
In the United States, Response to Intervention (RtI) is used to promote the use of evidence-based instruction in educational institutions, with the goal of supporting general and specializedExpand
Data Collection and Analysis in Response-to-Intervention: a Survey of School Psychologists
Response-to-intervention (RtI) is a multi-tiered framework designed to prevent academic difficulties by facilitating robust, research-based instruction and providing targeted or individualizedExpand
The role of context in the assessment of “unresponsiveness” within responsiveness-to-intervention: The “relative slope-difference discrepancy model” (RSDDM)
The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the role of context in the identification of learning disabilities (LD) within the responsiveness-to-intervention (RTI) model. In Study 1, using aExpand
Meta analysis of the effectivness of response to intervention models in special education and implications for international implementations
The results of this study provide evidence that RTI can be adopted effectively in other countries and the use of RTI with individuals who speak English as a second language in Saudi Arabia. Expand
Responsiveness-to-Intervention and School-Wide Positive Behavior Supports: Integration of Multi-Tiered System Approaches
The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and No Child Left Behind emphasize the use of scientifically based research to improve outcomes for students. From this emphasis,Expand
How educators perceive the process and implementation of a multi-tiered system of supports (MTSS): a case study.
In this qualitative case study the researcher examined educators’ perceptions of an RTI/MTSS model of instruction and how staff perceptions relate to fidelity of implementation. The purpose of thisExpand
A Meta-Analysis of the RTI Literature for Children at Risk for Reading Disabilities
It is suggested that regardless of type of treatment and identification criteria, response-to-intervention (RTI) conditions were not effective in mitigating learner characteristics related to pretest conditions. Expand


A Meta-analysis of Prereferral Intervention Teams: Student and Systemic Outcomes
Abstract Although prereferral intervention teams (PIT) are common in public schools, there is little and conflicting research to support them. The current article conducted an empirical meta-analysisExpand
Problem‐Solving Model for Decision Making with High‐Incidence Disabilities: The Minneapolis Experience
The problem-solving model (PSM) is used in the Minneapolis Public Schools to guide decisions regarding: (1) interventions in general education, (2) referral to special education, and (3) evaluationExpand
Responsiveness‐to‐Intervention: Definitions, Evidence, and Implications for the Learning Disabilities Construct
Longstanding concern about how learning disabilities (LD) are defined and identified, coupled with recent efforts in Washington, DC to eliminate IQ-achievement discrepancy as an LD marker, have ledExpand
Assessing intervention responsiveness: Conceptual and technical issues.
Implementing an intervention responsiveness approach to the identification of learning disabilities (LD) requires specification of procedures for the assessment process. In this article, the authorExpand
Responsiveness to Mathematical Problem-Solving Instruction
Responsibility to a 16-week mathematical problem-solving treatment as a function of students' risk for disability was assessed and it was suggested that MDR/RDR students' math deficits or their underlying mechanisms explained a greater proportion of variance in responsiveness to problem-Solving treatment than reading deficits or the underlying mechanisms. Expand
Adoption of Intervention-Based Assessment for Special Education
The education reform movement in the United States promises to expand the role of school psychologists by reducing psychometric activities in favor of intervention-based assessment (IBA), whichExpand
Responding to Nonresponders: An Experimental Field Trial of Identification and Intervention Methods
First graders (N = 323) participated in an evidence-based classwide reading program (Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies; PALS). Adual-discrepancy approach was used to identify 56 children whoseExpand
Fidelity of Problem-Solving Implementation and Relationship to Student Performance
Abstract This study examined the fidelity of problem-solving implementation by multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) in 227 schools and the relationship to student outcomes. Judgments about fidelity ofExpand
Intervention-Based Assessment: Evaluation Rates and Eligibility Findings
A statewide sample of Ohio schools employing Intervention-Based Assessment (IBA) reported rates of multifactored evaluation for special education, eligibility findings, and the proportion of childrenExpand
Reading Research for Students with LD
  • H. Swanson
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of learning disabilities
  • 1999
A meta-analysis of instructional research with samples of children and adolescents with learning disabilities in the domains ofword recognition and reading comprehension showed that a prototypical intervention study has an effect size of .59 for word recognition and .72 for reading comprehension. Expand